One of the most treacherous aspects of the doctrine of hidden defects is the time limit. Many buyers do not realise that they do not have years to sue their seller — often not even a full year. Whoever waits too long definitively loses their rights, no matter how strong their case on the merits. In this article, we set out how much time you really have, when the period starts running, and how you can extend it if necessary.
What does the law say?
Article 1648 of the old Belgian Civil Code is remarkably vague. It provides that an action based on hidden defects must be brought "within a short period, depending on the nature of the defects and the customs of the place where the sale was concluded". The law therefore does not specify how long that period is. The trial judge assesses this on a case-by-case basis.
That vagueness is no coincidence. The legislator wanted flexibility: a defect in a tractor requires a faster reaction than a hidden moisture problem in a house, because evidence otherwise risks being lost. But in practice, that flexibility also creates uncertainty.
The six-month rule of thumb
Based on published case law, a rule of thumb has emerged: in real estate cases, six months from the discovery of the defect is often the outer limit. This is not a statutory period, but a factual pattern applied by many courts and courts of appeal.
Concrete examples:
- Summons issued four months after discovery: generally timely (Brussels, 26 November 2013).
- Summons issued six months after discovery: usually still within the margin, provided concrete action was taken in the meantime.
- Eight months without concrete action: generally late (Mons, 5 June 2014, JLMB 2017, 20).
- A simple e-mail to the seller does not count as concrete action: it does not prove serious negotiations.
Important: these are guidelines, not laws. The judge assesses sovereignly, having regard to the specific circumstances.
When does the period start running?
A common misconception: the short period does not run from the purchase, but from the moment you know or ought to know of the defect. Dry rot that only manifests itself five years after the purchase during renovation works opens the period at that moment. An asbestos problem only detected during a new expert examination, the same.
The Court of Cassation expressly confirmed this rule in a judgment of 23 June 2022 (Cass., AR C.20.0470.N). The period runs from the moment when the seller — where a reseller is involved — knew or ought to have known of the defect, regardless of when he himself is summoned.
What does "ought to know" mean? That is a factual assessment. Anyone who receives clear indications of a defect — for example an inspection report, a neighbour's notification, or a first sign of damage — is deemed to know of the defect from that moment. You cannot close your eyes and thereby avoid the period running.
How is the period suspended?
The short period is not an unforgiving forfeiture period. Various elements can suspend it.
Serious negotiations. When, after discovering the defect, you enter into a dialogue with the seller — in writing, with concrete settlement proposals — the period is suspended for as long as the negotiations continue (Liège, 22 September 2016, JLMB 2018, 346). But the threshold is high: a mere e-mail is not enough. Case law requires the negotiations to be "serious" — concrete figures, technical annexes, a prospect of an amicable settlement.
A court-ordered expert investigation. Requesting an independent expert examination through the court may suspend the period, provided you simultaneously bring the case on the merits — even if only with a provisional claim for one euro (Ghent, 11 December 2020, TBO 2021, no. 1, 61). A purely precautionary action, without a claim on the merits, offers less protection.
Consulting your legal expenses insurer. According to a judgment of the Ghent Court of Appeal, the fact that you first had to consult your legal expenses insurer and obtain additional objective advice may also be an element that suspends the period (Ghent, 2 May 2017). Such circumstances — which you do not control yourself — may allow for a few additional months without the period expiring.
Criminal proceedings. If criminal proceedings are pending for, for example, construction fraud linked to the defect, the rule "le criminel tient le civil en l'état" may come into play. But beware: a criminal complaint can significantly delay civil proceedings.
What if the seller gave a specific warranty?
An important exception: if the seller expressly warranted the non-existence of a specific defect, the short period of article 1648 old Civil Code does not apply (Court of First Instance Walloon Brabant, 3 June 2015, Amén. 2016, 117).
Example: the deed of sale literally states that "the seller warrants that the house is free from dry rot". Three years later, you nevertheless discover dry rot. In that case, you can rely on the ordinary ten-year limitation period for contractual non-performance. That is a world of difference compared to the short period of six months.
The chain of sellers: a special situation
What if you have meanwhile resold the property yourself? Until recently, the rule was: the period of your own action against the original seller only starts to run from the moment you are sued by your own buyer (Cass., 25 June 2010).
However, the Court of Cassation nuanced this rule in 2022. If you already knew or ought to have known of the defect while you were still the owner, the period starts to run at that earlier moment (Cass., 23 June 2022, AR C.20.0470.N). Practical consequence: a reseller who waits until he is sued by his own buyer may in the meantime have lost his own indemnity action.
The lesson: as soon as you, as a reseller, suspect a defect, immediately take action against your own seller, even if you are not yet being sued yourself.
Forfeiture or limitation period?
A technical but important debate: is the short period a forfeiture period (no suspension or interruption possible) or a limitation period (suspension and interruption possible)? Case law is divided. The Antwerp Court of Appeal in 2021 qualified the period as a "kind of limitation period", precisely because the practice of suspension by negotiations suggests that it cannot be a strict forfeiture period (Antwerp, 22 March 2021, TBO 2021, no. 3, 194).
In practice, the distinction matters little for strategy: you should in any case act quickly and build up evidence of your steps.
Practical strategy
Day 1 — discovery. Document immediately: photos, videos, written description, possibly an initial technical assessment.
Week 1 — formal notification. Send the seller a registered letter with a detailed description of the defect. Make clear that you reserve your rights.
Month 1-3 — amicable attempt. Open serious negotiations. Engage your lawyer. Carefully document all communications.
Month 3-4 — preparation. If no solution is in sight: have a unilateral technical report drawn up or request a court-ordered expert investigation.
Month 5-6 — ultimate action. If necessary, issue a summons on the merits. Do not wait until after six months without any clear suspending circumstance.
For the full legal framework on hidden defects in real estate, consult our comprehensive guide.
Have you just discovered a hidden defect and are you worried about the time limit? A quick legal analysis can make the difference between an admissible and a late action. Contact us as soon as possible at info@reius.be.