You sign the notarial deed. You receive the keys. You start moving in. And then, three weeks later, you discover something is seriously wrong with the property. Damp in the walls. A leaking roof. A hidden problem the previous owner never mentioned. The question you ask yourself: has the fact that I have meanwhile "accepted" the property limited my rights?
The short answer: yes, for some claims it has. But not for all. And the most recent case law of the Court of Cassation has significantly tightened the rules of the game.
What exactly does "acceptance" mean?
Under Belgian law, the seller's main obligations are viewed in two phases. In the first phase, the seller must deliver goods that correspond to what was sold — the so-called conforming delivery. In the second phase, he must protect you against hidden defects that render the property unsuitable for its normal use.
The pivotal moment between those two phases is acceptance. As long as you have not accepted the property, you can rely on a lack of conforming delivery: you can demand that the seller still carries out the works, or refuse delivery on grounds of non-conformity. Once you accept — expressly by signing, or tacitly by taking the property into use without reservation — you are legally saying, in effect: "what I received corresponds to what I bought".
The breakthrough of the Cassation ruling of 6 January 2022
In an important judgment, the Court of Cassation stated this logic very sharply. The Court held that a buyer who accepts the delivered goods can no longer claim rescission of the sale on the ground of non-conformity of the delivered goods (Cass., 6 January 2022, AR C.21.0165.N, RABG 2022, issue 7, 521).
The Court goes even further: where a claim for hidden defects has been brought too late and is therefore inadmissible, the claim based on the delivery obligation can no longer be upheld either. In other words: you cannot let the short time limit for hidden defects expire and then pursue proceedings via the delivery obligation instead. The Court expressly closes that door.
A year later, the Court confirmed this line in a consumer sales context: after expiry of the statutory two-year warranty period, only the common law rules on hidden defects apply, no longer article 1604 of the old Civil Code on conforming delivery (Cass., 13 January 2023, AR C.22.0135.N).
What remains open after acceptance?
The warranty obligation for hidden defects under article 1641 of the old Civil Code. That expressly remains in place, even after acceptance. The rationale is logical: if the defect was truly hidden, you could not see it at the time of acceptance, and your acceptance can hardly be interpreted as agreement to that defect.
But — and here is where the shoe pinches — the claim for hidden defects is bound by the "short time" of article 1648 of the old Civil Code. In practice, this often amounts to six months from the moment you know or ought to know of the defect. Anyone who lets that time limit expire without serious negotiations or legal steps definitively loses their right. The Court of Cassation left no doubt about that in 2022.
What if the non-conformity only comes to light later?
A question that occupies legal scholars: what if the delivery seemed conforming at first sight, but subsequently turns out to contain a hidden non-conformity? A property that seemed habitable at the time of acceptance, but subsequently proves to be legally unfit — is that a lack of conforming delivery or a hidden defect?
Case law addresses these situations through what is called the functional criterion of the hidden defect. A defect is hidden not only where the property is intrinsically affected, but also where it is functionally unfit for the use the buyer wishes to make of it — provided the seller knew of that use. In this way, many cases of hidden non-conformity are nevertheless brought within the scope of article 1641 of the old Civil Code.
A telling example: the Brussels Court of Appeal held that a seller who delivered a studio that was legally unfit for occupation and letting had breached his delivery obligation as long as the buyer had not accepted the delivery. But once accepted, the case shifted to the hidden defects regime (Brussels, 11 June 2020, RW 2022-23, issue 9, 343).
Practical consequences: how do you prevent acceptance from working against you?
Before the notarial deed: carry out a thorough site inspection. Walk through the property systematically, photograph everything, ask the seller for specific declarations about points you find doubtful. If there are signs of damp, or a smell of mould, expressly request a written declaration.
At the deed: have reservations recorded if necessary. Do you suspect there is a problem, but do you still want or need to sign? Ask the notary to expressly include your objection in the deed. A notarial deed is a document whose statements have evidential value. What you have recorded there will apply afterwards.
After the deed: act quickly. Have you discovered a problem shortly after taking possession? Do not wait weeks to formally give the seller notice of default. A registered letter, with photographs and if possible an initial technical opinion, is essential to prevent the short time limit from expiring. Engage a lawyer immediately: he or she can choose the correct legal qualification — hidden defect, error, fraud or pre-contractual liability — and steer the proceedings towards the right legal basis.
The crucial lesson from recent Cassation case law
The evolution of Cassation case law since 2007 unmistakably points in the same direction: the Court is putting an end to the practice whereby buyers circumvented the short time limit of article 1648 of the old Civil Code by subsequently invoking a lack of conforming delivery. Anyone who is too late, is too late.
For you as a buyer this means: act quickly, choose the right legal basis, and seek advice in good time. For you as a seller it means: a proper acceptance of the property is an important shield against later claims, provided that you have acted in good faith.
For the broader context of your rights as a buyer and the various possible claims, please consult our comprehensive guide on hidden defects when buying a house.
Have you discovered a defect in a recently purchased property and are you unsure which claim is still available? Contact us at info@reius.be for a swift assessment of your file.