You believe there is a hidden defect in the home you have just purchased. Dampness, a foundation issue, incorrectly installed insulation. You know the law protects you — but without solid evidence, your case remains weak. And one wrong reflex (having the repairs carried out yourself) can cause your right to warranty protection to evaporate entirely.
This page explains which types of evidence work, when a court-appointed expert examination is necessary, and which pitfalls you must avoid in order to safeguard your rights as a buyer.
The burden of proof lies entirely with you as the buyer
Article 1641 of the old Civil Code grants you rights — but you bear the burden of proof. You must demonstrate four things:
- There is a defect. The mere fact that a component does not work or looks worn is not enough. You must show that the home lacks a characteristic it should normally have had.
- The defect is serious enough. The home must be unfit for normal use, or its use must be seriously impaired. Read more in our analysis of when a defect is serious enough.
- It existed at the time of the sale. A defect that arose after the purchase cannot be claimed against the seller. You must therefore date when the problem originated — often the trickiest part of the evidence.
- It was hidden. A defect that you should have noticed during a normal inspection falls outside the protection. We elaborated on this in our spoke on when a defect is truly hidden.
You may prove each of these elements by any legal means: photos, witness statements, technical reports, expert opinions. The trial judge assesses this at his or her sovereign discretion (Cass., 7 September 1984).
The court-appointed expert examination: often indispensable
In practice, a court-appointed expert examination is almost always required to prove a hidden defect. An independent technician appointed by the court then performs four tasks:
- Establish precisely what the defect is.
- Investigate since when it has existed — crucial to proving that it was already present at the time of purchase.
- Assess whether it was detectable during a normal inspection.
- Estimate the costs required for repair — which serves as the basis for a price reduction or damages.
The examination is organised on an adversarial basis: the seller and, where applicable, his contractor or architect may be present, ask questions, and have their comments recorded in the report. The final report forms the backbone of the case file.
The judge may not order it lightly
A court-appointed expert examination is expensive — often several thousand euros in advance, to be funded by the claimant. Recent case law emphasises that the examination has a subsidiary character and that the judge may not order it lightly (Court of First Instance Walloon Brabant, 17 January 2022, Res Jur.Imm. 2022, no. 1, 50).
In certain cases, a simpler site visit with technical assistance will suffice. This applies in particular when:
- The defect is visually evident and easy to document.
- The parties agree on the facts and are only disputing the legal qualification.
- The repair costs are limited and disproportionate to a full expert examination.
Ask your lawyer whether a court-appointed expert examination is necessary, or whether a less intrusive means of proof will suffice. Misjudging this costs time and money.
The fatal mistake: repairing before the expert examination
The most common pitfall for buyers is understandable but disastrous: you discover the problem, you have it repaired, and only then do you attempt to hold the seller liable.
That does not work. Anyone who makes it impossible to prove a hidden defect through their own actions loses their right to warranty protection. The seller must be given the opportunity to observe the defect with his own eyes — if only to contest its cause and extent.
The same applies if you have significantly transformed the property in the meantime. A thorough renovation erases traces and makes any later expert examination impossible.
The correct approach upon discovery
When you discover a suspected hidden defect, strictly follow these steps:
- Document immediately. Take photos with date stamps, videos, and possibly time-stamped evidence such as a registered letter to yourself with the photos attached. Ensure that the evidence establishes a timeline.
- Serve the seller with a formal notice by registered mail. Describe the defect concretely, ask him to come and inspect it, and expressly state that you reserve your rights to warranty protection.
- Invite the seller to a joint inspection. In case of refusal or unavailability: have a bailiff draw up a formal report of findings. That has evidentiary value in later proceedings.
- Compile a file before any works. Building survey report, technical photos, and possibly a unilateral expert opinion by an independent expert.
- Only then carry out urgent protective works if the home threatens to become uninhabitable. Also document those works meticulously.
- Obtain legal advice. The deadline under article 1648 of the old Civil Code is short, and strategic decisions (court proceedings, unilateral expertise, negotiation) have direct consequences for your evidentiary position.
The value of photos and witness statements
Photos are typically the most frequently used means of evidence, but they are not always sufficient. The judge wants to know when they were taken and in what circumstances. Therefore, always use a device that captures dates in the metadata. If in doubt: have the photos certified by a bailiff or preserve them with a digital timestamp via a trusted service.
Witness statements can help, but generally have limited legal value when they come from family members or friends. Employees of a contractor who carried out works on the property can be valuable witnesses — they have technical expertise and no partiality.
Emails, WhatsApp messages and text messages with the seller in which the defect is discussed are legally valid evidence in Belgium. Print them out or take screenshots, and preserve metadata such as sending times.
What if you documented too late?
Not all hope is lost. A court-appointed expert can often still establish afterwards whether a defect existed prior to the purchase — through analysis of building-physics traces, materials research, or by consulting earlier building plans and permits. The evidentiary position is then weaker but not impossible.
In addition, alternative legal grounds exist that you can invoke when the evidence for warranty protection falls short — such as mistake, fraud, or the direct action against the original contractor. Our pillar article on hidden defects provides the full overview.
How Reius Advocaten can assist you
Every hidden-defect case stands or falls with the evidence. Reius Advocaten guides you from the first observation onwards: we assess whether the facts can be qualified as a hidden defect, we organise the correct evidentiary steps (formal notice, bailiff's report of findings, expert examination), and where necessary we apply for a court-appointed expert examination.
Contact us via info@reius.be or through our contact form. The sooner you seek advice, the better you can safeguard your evidentiary position — and the greater the chance you will obtain what you are entitled to.