Reius Advocaten – Vastgoedrecht Brussel

Advocaten - Avocats - Lawyers

Reius Lawyers · 363 Avenue Louise box 26 · 1050 Brussels · info@reius.be · +32 2 616 08 10 Printed on 5 November 2026
Sale & Purchase

Mistake versus fraud in a home purchase: which is stronger?

Vianto Pashku - Lawyer · · 7 min
Table of contents

In short

When the short period for hidden defects has expired, mistake, fraud and pre-contractual liability remain available. Three routes, each with its own conditions and prospects.

Not every problem arising after the purchase of a home fits within the narrow definition of a hidden defect. Sometimes the essence of the matter is not so much that the property is physically defective, but that you feel misled: the seller withheld crucial information, or you had a mistaken understanding of the facts at the time of purchase. In such cases Belgian law offers other routes: mistake, fraud and pre-contractual liability. This article sets them out.

Three distinct legal concepts

Mistake (Articles 1109-1110 old Civil Code). At the time of the purchase, you had a mistaken understanding of an essential element of the property. Without that mistake, you would not have bought or would not have bought on the same terms. The mistake must be excusable — you must not have been unnecessarily naive or negligent.

Fraud (Article 1116 old Civil Code). The seller actively misled you, either through false statements or by concealing important information. A stratagem — active or passive — led you to believe something untrue. Unlike with mistake, your error in a fraud case need not be excusable: it is the bad faith of the seller that justifies the error.

Pre-contractual liability (Articles 1382-1383 old Civil Code; since Book 6 of the Civil Code: Article 6.5). The seller committed a fault in his pre-contractual duty to inform. He did not inform you correctly or fully about essential characteristics of the property. You claim damages on an extra-contractual basis.

In practice these three concepts often overlap. A seller who conceals important information simultaneously breaches his pre-contractual duty to inform (pre-contractual liability), may create an excusable mistake on your part (mistake), and if the concealment was intentional, it constitutes a stratagem (fraud).

Why choose between these concepts?

The right choice partly determines your prospects. The differences lie mainly in the evidentiary threshold, the sanction and the time limit.

The evidentiary threshold. For mistake, you must show that your error was excusable. A buyer who has failed to carry out the minimum investigations expected of a normal buyer cannot rely on mistake. For fraud this requirement does not apply: even an imprudent buyer may invoke the fraud of the seller.

The sanction. Mistake and fraud lead to the nullity of the sale (Article 1117 old Civil Code), unless you opt for incidental fraud (see below). Pre-contractual liability leads to damages on an extra-contractual basis. The warranty for hidden defects offers a choice between rescission and a price reduction.

The time limit. A claim based on mistake or fraud is time-barred after ten years (since the entry into force of Book 6 of the Civil Code: five years for certain aspects). A pre-contractual claim is time-barred after five years. A claim for hidden defects must be brought within a "short period" — often only six months.

These differences in time limits are crucial. When you are out of time for a hidden defects claim, mistake, fraud or pre-contractual liability may still offer relief.

Fraud by concealment: an important development

A notable development in the case law: the concealment of an important fact may in itself constitute a stratagem. You therefore need not necessarily prove an active lie — deliberate silence about an essential element may suffice.

A striking example comes from the Antwerp Court of Appeal. In one case, involving the transfer of a plot of land, the notarial deed contained an incorrect statement by the seller that the land did not fall under the Forestry Decree — whereas he knew that a reforestation obligation did in fact exist. The court held that the seller had breached his pre-contractual duty to inform and that his conduct constituted incidental fraud. The incorrect statement and the concealment of important information together constituted a "stratagem within the meaning of Article 1116 old Civil Code" (Antwerp, 14 July 2022, NJW 2022, no. 471, 844).

The court added an important principle: where fraud leads to the annulment of the contract, the fraudster cannot invoke the "imprudence or even gross and inexcusable negligence" of his co-contractor. The fraudster remains liable for the full compensation of the damage, regardless of any fault on the part of the victim.

That last point is particularly important: in cases of fraud, even a careless buyer is protected.

When the same set of facts opens several routes

An important insight from Belgian case law: the same set of facts can be legally characterised in different ways. The Court of First Instance in Hasselt expressly confirmed this rule: the mere fact that the claimants' main argument was based on hidden defects does not render their claim based on mistake or fraud inadmissible. Whatever one relies on — hidden defect, mistake, fraud or non-conforming delivery — is always "the same set of facts, each time given a different legal characterisation" (Hasselt Court of First Instance, 1 April 2020, Limb.Rechtsl. 2020, no. 3, 253).

This gives counsel flexibility. But beware: not every court is equally accommodating. A writ of summons focused solely on hidden defects, with a factual account describing only the symptoms after the sale, does not automatically lend itself to being re-characterised as mistake or fraud. The facts you invoke in the writ must fit the legal concept you rely on.

In practice, careful counsel does well to include in the writ both the principal claim and subsidiary claims, each time with the facts supporting each claim. For example: principally, nullity for fraud; subsidiarily, rescission for hidden defects; even more subsidiarily, damages for pre-contractual liability.

Incidental fraud: keeping the property while getting compensation

A useful distinction: the difference between principal fraud and incidental fraud.

Principal fraud: without the fraud, you would not have bought at all. The sanction is the nullity of the sale, with full compensation.

Incidental fraud: you would still have bought, but at a lower price. The sanction is damages equal to the difference — comparable to a price reduction.

In practice, many buyers opt for incidental fraud when they wish to keep the property. It allows them to remain in the home and receive financial compensation.

The role of pre-contractual liability

Where you cannot prove a stratagem (no fraud), but the seller has clearly fallen short of his duty to inform, pre-contractual liability remains a valuable fallback option.

A telling example: the Antwerp Court of First Instance held that the owner of an apartment had breached his pre-contractual duty to inform and was guilty of concealment when, in putting the property up for sale, he promoted it because of the fine view from the terrace, while being aware of imminent construction plans on the neighbouring plot that would significantly restrict that view (Antwerp Court of First Instance, 17 November 2015, RW 2016-17, no. 17, 671).

No hidden defect (the property itself functioned perfectly), no fraud (no active stratagem), but a breach of the duty to inform. The buyer received damages.

The Antwerp judgment of December 2022: the counter-current

Not all cases go in the buyer's favour. In a judgment of December 2022, the Antwerp Court of Appeal held that a buyer may not simply rely on a sales advertisement and has his own duty to investigate the condition of the property (Antwerp, 19 December 2022, Limb.Rechtsl. 2023, no. 3, 193). A person who, placed as a prudent and foresighted buyer in the same circumstances, should reasonably have gathered more information, can hardly rely on the shortcomings of the seller.

The lesson: even in pre-contractual liability, the buyer's diligence is a factor that weighs in the balance — although in cases of fraud it is largely neutralised.

Practical tips

Carefully collect evidence of what the seller said or wrote. Sales advertisements, emails, oral statements supported by witness testimony, mentions in the preliminary sales agreement. The more written evidence, the stronger your case.

Document what the seller should have said but concealed. Sometimes the proof of fraud is not what the seller said, but what he should have said. An independent investigation after the purchase may show that information of which the seller was aware was not shared.

Combine legal grounds in your writ of summons. A writ that covers several alternative legal grounds offers a better chance of success. Ensure that the facts you invoke fit each legal ground.

For the broader framework of your options in the event of a dispute after the purchase, see our pillar page on hidden defects.

Do you suspect that you were misled when buying a home? Mistake, fraud and pre-contractual liability each require a specific approach. Contact us at info@reius.be for an initial analysis.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between fraud and simple concealment?

Case law has blurred the boundary. Deliberate concealment of an important fact may in itself constitute a stratagem and therefore fraud. It depends on the seller's awareness and the importance of the concealed information.

For a mistake claim, must I prove that my mistake was excusable?

Yes. For mistake, you must show that your error was reasonable given the information available to you. A buyer who has not carried out normal investigations can hardly rely on mistake. For fraud, however, this requirement does not apply.

How long do I have to bring a claim for fraud?

The limitation period for the action for nullity based on fraud is in principle ten years (Article 2262bis old Civil Code), running from the discovery of the fraud. For damages on an extra-contractual basis, a five-year period applies.

Can I invoke fraud against the notary or the real estate agent?

Possibly, if they actively participated in the deception or breached their own duty to inform. The Brussels Court of Appeal, in a judgment of 2020, expressly confirmed that a real estate agent must inform potential buyers of the essential factual and legal characteristics of the property being offered for sale (Brussels, 11 June 2020, RW 2022-23, no. 9, 343).

What if only the agent misled me, not the seller himself?

You have two parallel claims. Against the agent personally on the basis of his pre-contractual liability and his deontological obligations (BIV rules). Against the seller on the basis of fraud by his agent: Article 1116 old Civil Code characterises fraud by an intermediary as fraud by the party itself, provided that the intermediary acted within the scope of his mandate. The seller cannot hide behind his agent. In practice, both are often summoned so that liability can be established jointly and severally by the court.

Is fraudulent concealment the same as fraud?

Not always, and the distinction is crucial. The Court of Cassation distinguishes between 'positive active' fraud (a lie, a manipulated certificate) and concealment (withholding information). Concealment is only fraud where a duty to speak existed — for example because the information was essential to the purchase decision and the seller was aware of its relevance. Cassation 8 June 1978 established that criterion. In practice, courts more often qualify concealments as 'culpa in contrahendo' (pre-contractual fault) than as fraud, with a lighter burden of proof as a consequence.

Unsure about your situation?

The lawyers at Reius are ready to provide you with personal legal advice.

Book a consultation →