Suppose you have bought a house and, after moving in, you discover a damp problem in the cellar. You approach the seller. Their lawyer replies that you should have conducted a normal viewing, that the problem was visible to "any attentive visitor", and that you therefore no longer have any rights. Is that correct?
Not necessarily. The law does indeed require a defect to be hidden in order to fall under Article 1641 of the old Civil Code, but the test is more nuanced than many sellers think. In this article, we set out what a judge really expects from a buyer during the viewing.
The legal definition
Article 1642 of the old Civil Code is clear: the seller is not liable for visible defects that the buyer could have observed themselves. A defect is therefore not hidden when a buyer would have noticed it during a normally attentive inspection.
The Court of Cassation has refined this rule: a defect is not visible if it cannot be discovered by a normally attentive but basic inspection during viewing or delivery (Cass., 29 March 1976; Cass., 9 October 2006, AR C050276.F). The standard is therefore: attentive, but not expert. No buyer is expected to break open a roof to detect hidden damp, or to drill through walls to trace dry rot.
The key Ghent judgment: the abstract test
An important judgment of the Ghent Court of Appeal has further developed this test. The court held that the assessment of the visible nature must be carried out "in the abstract": the reference person is someone with the same technical knowledge and skill as the buyer, placed in the same circumstances (Ghent, 17 November 2022, T. Verz. 2023, no. 2, 215).
That is an important nuance. A defect may be considered hidden for a private buyer, even if it would have been detectable for a professional building contractor with the same specific knowledge, experience or equipment. The court expressly states: for a layperson in construction matters, the requirements are lower than for someone from the trade.
In concrete terms, this means: if you are an ordinary private individual buying a house, you may be compared with another normal private individual — not with a contractor or architect. A seller arguing that "any contractor would have seen it" will not succeed if you yourself are not a contractor.
What falls within a "normally attentive inspection"?
Over the years, case law has developed a number of principles regarding what is expected of a buyer:
- A normal walk-through of the house, in all accessible rooms. You cannot simply skip a room or the attic.
- Visual inspection of floors, walls, ceilings and visible pipes. Disturbances such as clear cracks, mould stains, sagging or efflorescence should stand out.
- Attention to what appears unusual. A strong smell, an odd temperature fluctuation, floors that are not level — these are signals that an attentive buyer does not simply ignore.
- Reading the urban planning information and sale documents. What is stated in official documents is deemed to be known to you.
What falls outside?
- Destructive investigation. You are not allowed to break down walls, open floors or examine ceilings. Everything hidden behind finishes cannot be seen — and therefore remains hidden, even if the defect is dramatic.
- Technical measurements. You are not required to bring damp meters, have infrared scans carried out or take building experts with you. Those who do so, do so voluntarily.
- Reading technical documents in foreign languages. In a notorious example, a buyer's claim failed because he had not read a German construction specification — but the court ruled that the specification had been made available to him and that he could have asked for it (Court of First Instance Dendermonde, 5 February 2010). This case concerned the excusability of mistake, not so much the hidden nature.
What if the seller has deliberately concealed the defect?
A hidden defect that the seller has actively camouflaged obviously remains hidden — and moreover, it opens the door to fraud. In a decision by the Liège Court of Appeal, it was held that a seller who had installed cladding walls to hide damp problems was acting in bad faith. He could no longer rely on the exclusion clause (Liège, 11 February 2013, JLMB 2013, 2093).
The lesson: even if the defect would have been visible with some attention, it remains hidden when the seller has actively camouflaged it. Case law punishes bad faith severely.
The role of the parties' capacity
An important factor is the capacity of both the buyer and the seller. A layperson against a layperson is assessed differently from a layperson against a professional. A professional waste manager who claimed not to have seen concrete waste on a site was unsuccessful: given his professional knowledge, it was visible (Liège, 25 March 2013).
The same logic applies in reverse. The judge weighs whether the specific knowledge or experience of the buyer should have enabled him to detect the problem. An architect who buys his own house has a higher duty of care than an average couple.
Practical tips for the buyer
Document your viewing. Take photos, keep a written report, ask the seller for specific declarations on points you find doubtful. Whoever can demonstrate that they carried out a thorough viewing is in a stronger position.
Ask the seller concrete questions. A written question (for example by email) about damp problems, asbestos or planning breaches, and the seller's written denial, is excellent evidence if the opposite later proves true.
Consult a building expert when in doubt. A professional site inspection is not obligatory, but for large purchases or older houses it is often a wise investment. The cost is minimal in relation to the purchase price and can save you from a later dispute.
Practical tips for the seller
Be transparent about what you know. An honest mention of problems in the preliminary sale agreement protects you against later claims. Remember: concealment can be qualified as fraud, and fraud opens up remedies that go far beyond hidden defects (see our spoke on mistake, fraud and pre-contractual fault).
Avoid camouflage. Covering an asbestos wall with a plasterboard, painting over mould, laying a tiled floor over a cracked cellar floor — these are all acts that can be interpreted as fraud.
For a full overview of the legal framework surrounding hidden defects, see our comprehensive guide.
Do you have doubts about the visibility of a defect you have discovered? A quick analysis can profoundly influence the procedural outcome. Contact us at info@reius.be.