Since November 2022, asbestos has become a new legal reality in Belgian real estate transactions. Anyone selling a property built in 2000 or earlier must now provide the buyer with an asbestos certificate. At first glance, this seems to put an end to asbestos as a hidden defect: everything is in the certificate, isn't it? In reality, the situation is more nuanced. In this article, we explain when you still have rights after purchase, how the certificate affects your position, and what pitfalls you should be aware of.
The legal framework: the Materials Decree and the asbestos certificate
The so-called Materials Decree of 23 December 2011 — amended on 29 March 2019 — has introduced an obligation since 23 November 2022. Anyone selling in Flanders an accessible construction with a "risk construction year" (construction from 2000 or older) must provide a valid asbestos inventory certificate to the buyer before signing the private deed (Article 33/14 of the decree).
An asbestos certificate is no small piece of paper. It is an extensive document, drawn up by a certified asbestos expert, which inventories the presence and condition of asbestos-containing materials in the property. It contains photos, locations, conclusions and recommendations for the management or removal of the asbestos.
The preliminary sales agreement (compromis) must state whether the content of the asbestos certificate has been communicated to the buyer, including the date, summary conclusion and the unique code of the certificate. In the notarial deed, the notary must verify these formalities.
Non-compliance carries a heavy sanction: the buyer may claim nullity of the transfer.
What effect on hidden defects?
An asbestos certificate that has been properly communicated undermines the possibility of invoking asbestos as a hidden defect — for those aspects included in the certificate. A buyer who has received the certificate is deemed to be informed. Asbestos thus becomes semi-visible.
But — and this is the crux of the matter — an asbestos certificate does not cover everything. Three important limitations.
Limitation 1: the asbestos expert does not perform destructive inspections. He does not remove walls, break open floors or dismantle cupboards. What is hidden behind finishes remains outside his findings. An asbestos sheet hidden behind a plasterboard wall installed by the seller himself therefore remains concealed — even if an asbestos certificate exists.
Limitation 2: the owner must inform the expert of what he knows about hidden asbestos. The decree expressly provides that if the owner is aware or ought to be aware of enclosed or covered asbestos-containing materials, he must disclose this to the asbestos expert (Article 33/10, §3). Does he conceal this? Then he acts in bad faith, and his liability for hidden defects remains fully intact.
Limitation 3: the certificate covers only accessible constructions. Asbestos in the soil or in sealed spaces may fall outside the certificate.
Asbestos hidden behind finishes: still a hidden defect
Suppose you buy a house with a valid asbestos certificate. A year later, during renovation work, you discover asbestos sheets hidden behind a plasterboard wall installed by the previous owner. The asbestos expert had been unable to see them.
Two scenarios.
Scenario A: the seller knew and concealed it. For example, because he installed the plasterboard wall himself to hide the asbestos sheets. In that case, the seller acts in bad faith and you can rely on all available legal remedies: warranty for hidden defects (without the exoneration clause protecting him), additional compensation for the remediation costs, and even fraud (dolus) in the event of active concealment.
The Brussels Court of Appeal, in a judgment of 5 February 2021, expressly confirmed that Article 1643 of the former Civil Code only deprives the seller of the ability to rely on an exoneration clause when there is bad faith — which means that the buyer must demonstrate that the seller had knowledge of the defect (Brussels, 5 February 2021, JT 2022, issue 6890, 152).
Scenario B: the seller did not know. For example, because a previous owner had carried out the works, and the current seller had no knowledge of the enclosed asbestos. In that case, the seller is in good faith and can rely on the exoneration clause. The same Brussels judgment of 5 February 2021 clarifies that a layperson carrying out works in his own home is not obliged to identify asbestos.
The crucial question is therefore always: did the seller know about the enclosed asbestos, or ought he to have known?
When ought the seller to know about asbestos?
Case law is not unnuanced. Three categories stand out.
Sellers who carried out the works themselves. Anyone who installed the plasterboard wall concealing the asbestos, or who laid the carpet over the asbestos glue, can hardly maintain that he knew nothing. The judge will presume that he did indeed have knowledge.
Specialised sellers. Contractors, project developers and other construction specialists are subject to a regime of presumed knowledge (Cass., 15 January 2021). They are deemed capable of identifying asbestos, even in subtler forms such as floor adhesive or roofing sheets.
Sellers with indications. When the post-intervention file (PID) states that works have been carried out typically associated with asbestos, or when earlier expert reports had mentioned asbestos, the seller cannot feign ignorance.
Asbestos and consequential problems: soil contamination
Another, often underestimated aspect: asbestos can lead to soil contamination. The asbestos certificate sometimes expressly mentions a risk of soil contamination, for example due to asbestos residues in the garden or flaking asbestos sheets next to a roof.
When you receive an asbestos certificate mentioning such a risk, and you nevertheless buy without further soil investigation, you are on thin ice. The court could rule that you were aware of the risk and accepted it (see our spoke on risk acceptance). Those who receive signals would do well to investigate them before signing.
What about asbestos in the common parts of an apartment building?
A separate regime applies to apartment buildings. A separate asbestos certificate for the common parts will become mandatory — with a postponement until 1 May 2025. Until that date, asbestos in the common parts can still fall under the classic regime of hidden defects.
For the private parts, the certificate obligation has already been in force since November 2022.
Practical tips for the buyer
Read the asbestos certificate thoroughly. It is an extensive document, sometimes running to dozens of pages. Do not skip any pages. Pay attention to mentions of suspicions, risks or recommendations for further investigation. What it contains counts as knowledge on your part.
Request the post-intervention file. The PID shows which works have been carried out since 2001. Combine it with the asbestos certificate to get a complete picture of the history.
Consult a lawyer in case of doubt. Interpreting an asbestos certificate, especially in combination with a PID, requires legal experience. A quick screening before the preliminary sales agreement can avoid many costs later.
Document your questions to the seller. Ask concrete questions about hidden asbestos, about works he has carried out himself, about the history of the property. His answers — especially if they later prove to be incorrect — are crucial evidence.
Practical tips for the seller
Be fully transparent with the asbestos expert. Do not conceal any works you have carried out or had carried out. Do not conceal any suspicions. The sworn statement the owner must make is not a formality: an incorrect statement opens the door to liability for hidden defects and for fraud.
Keep supporting documents. Invoices for earlier asbestos removals, certificates from professionals, correspondence — anything demonstrating that you acted with due care protects you afterwards.
For the complete legal framework on hidden defects in real estate, consult our pillar article.
Have you discovered asbestos after buying a house, or are you being held liable yourself? The interplay between asbestos certificate, PID and warranty obligation requires precise legal analysis. Contact us at info@reius.be.