When selling an older property, much attention goes to the asbestos certificate and to the warranty against hidden defects. But before those rules apply, there is an obligation that is often underestimated: the pre-contractual duty to inform. Anyone who knows about asbestos and keeps that knowledge to themselves can put the sale at risk — even when the certificate is in order, and even when the asbestos does not legally qualify as a "serious" defect. This article discusses what you, as a seller, estate agent or notary, must disclose, when concealment turns into fraud, and which documents play a key role.
The pre-contractual duty to inform (Article 5.16 Civil Code)
Since the reform of the law of obligations, the duty to inform has been expressly enshrined in law. Article 5.16 of the Civil Code obliges parties to communicate to each other during negotiations the information required by the law, good faith and customary practice, where the other party cannot reasonably be expected to know that information itself and is legitimately entitled to rely on the other party's cooperation. Applied to asbestos, this comes down to a simple principle: what you know about asbestos in the property, you must share with your prospective buyer.
This duty is broader than merely filling in a form. It covers everything the buyer would reasonably want to know in order to make an informed decision: a known asbestos roof, a previously carried out or deliberately neglected remediation, a problem that came to light during earlier works. Furthermore, the duty to inform is mutual, but in practice the seller has the most knowledge of their own home — and so the heaviest share of the burden rests on them.
Concealment can be fraud (Article 5.35 Civil Code)
The duty to inform has teeth. Anyone who deliberately withholds essential information in order to close the sale does not merely commit a breach: knowingly concealing information can constitute an artifice and therefore fraud within the meaning of Article 5.35 of the Civil Code. Fraud allows the buyer to claim annulment of the sale, where appropriate together with damages.
Two nuances are crucial. First, fraud is not presumed: the buyer who invokes it must prove it — they must demonstrate that the seller knew about the asbestos and deliberately concealed it in order to mislead them. Second, fraud is not the only avenue. Even when intent cannot be established, withholding information can cause a mistake. Importantly, a mistake induced by the other party's concealment is generally regarded as excusable, so that it can constitute a ground for annulment even in the case of a buyer who was somewhat careless. In other words, a silent seller cannot hide behind the argument that the buyer should have been more attentive. How a buyer can invoke mistake or fraud to have a property sale annulled is explained in a separate article.
Why this comes before hidden defects
The great advantage of the duty to inform for the buyer is that it is independent of the strict threshold that applies to hidden defects. Under the warranty against hidden defects (Article 1641 et seq. of the Civil Code), the defect must be "sufficiently serious": the mere presence of asbestos is not enough, there must be a substantial impairment of use or safety. This requirement does not apply to the pre-contractual duty to inform or to fraud. Here, it is the deception itself that counts: if the seller deliberately concealed what they knew, the sanction may apply even when the asbestos would not technically qualify as a serious defect. The duty to inform therefore comes before hidden defects both chronologically and legally, and offers the buyer an independent ground. How the warranty for hidden defects itself works is explained in our guide on asbestos in real estate.
The post-intervention file and the soil certificate
Asbestos is not only revealed by the asbestos certificate. Proper information exchange also involves other documents. The post-intervention file (PIF) is mandatory for works carried out on the building after 1 May 2001. It compiles data on the materials used and the interventions performed and can thus demonstrate that asbestos-containing applications were used or that an asbestos roof was subsequently covered over. An incomplete or manipulated PIF can in itself be read as an artifice.
In addition, there is the soil certificate, which must be delivered before the sale, on pain of nullity of the agreement. That certificate can reveal a completed soil remediation or a known contamination — information of direct relevance to the buyer that the seller may not sweep under the carpet.
A classic pitfall deserves particular attention: the PIF that will "be provided later". In practice, that later delivery often does not happen, and then the seller is left empty-handed in the face of accusations of concealment. Therefore, provide the PIF at the time of the preliminary sales agreement, not afterwards. Anyone who places the documents on the table in a timely and complete manner refutes in advance any discussion about bad faith.
The role and duty of investigation of the estate agent and notary
The seller is not alone in this. The estate agent and the notary must also ensure a correct and complete exchange of information. Their duty is, however, not absolute: they are expected to act with normal diligence, not to possess technical asbestos expertise. They must ask the right questions, request the necessary documents and point out the parties' obligations — but they are not required to search for hidden asbestos behind walls or under floors themselves.
A common misunderstanding concerns the wording in the deed. The declaration that the seller "to their knowledge is not aware of any hidden defect (asbestos, dry rot)" is not an exoneration clause, but a simple confirmation of a factual situation. It does not therefore exclude the seller's liability; if it later turns out that they were indeed aware, such a sentence offers no protection (Commercial Court Brussels, 12 December 2003). Anyone who really wants to cover themselves needs a properly drafted exoneration clause — and even that does not work against a seller who knew of the defect.
An example from practice
How real the risk is, is shown by a case in which buyers only learned after the purchase, through the neighbours, that the seller had previously been criminally convicted and had been required to carry out a soil remediation. That information had never been communicated to them. Such facts go to the heart of the pre-contractual duty to inform: they are objectively relevant to the decision to buy, and knowingly withholding them opens the door to fraud or at least to pre-contractual liability. It also shows why it is in the seller's interest to put unpleasant truths on the table themselves: transparency at most costs negotiating power, concealment potentially costs the entire sale. What rights a buyer has when a problem known before the purchase was concealed from them is discussed in a separate article.
The asbestos certificate does not discharge the seller
Finally, a persistent misconception. Anyone who has an asbestos certificate drawn up sometimes thinks that they are thereby "in order" and need not say anything more. That is incorrect. The certificate is an obligation of means, based on a non-destructive investigation; "asbestos-safe" is not the same as "asbestos-free". The legislator has therefore expressly retained a strengthened duty to speak for the owner (Article 33/10 of the Materials Decree): asbestos that is enclosed or covered and that the owner knows or ought to know must be disclosed by them, even if it is not mentioned in the certificate. The certificate therefore supplements the duty to inform, but never replaces it. What the asbestos certificate exactly entails and when you need it is explained in what an asbestos certificate is and when you need it.
In short: the safest attitude for every seller is complete openness, in a timely manner and in writing, with all relevant documents attached to the preliminary sales agreement.
How Reius Advocaten can assist you
Are you in doubt about what you must disclose, or how to safely word the deed and the clauses? Reius Advocaten assesses your duty to inform, reviews your preliminary sales agreement and documents, and assists you when a buyer or seller invokes concealment, mistake or fraud. Feel free to get in touch via info@reius.be or the contact form.