When you succeed in proving a hidden defect in your property, a range of remedies opens up. The law gives you, and you alone, two main routes to choose from: undoing the sale (your money back, the property back to the seller) or keeping the sale at a lower price (a partial refund of the price). On top of that, in certain cases, you can also claim damages. In this article, we set out the choice and the practical consequences.
The two main remedies under Article 1644 of the old Civil Code
The old Belgian Civil Code gives the buyer a double option once a hidden defect has been established. In legal terms these are known as the actio redhibitoria and the actio aestimatoria — terms you may come across in legal literature or judgments.
Rescission of the sale (actio redhibitoria). You return the property, the seller returns the purchase price. In addition, the seller must reimburse you for the costs you incurred directly in connection with the purchase: notary fees, registration duties where applicable, and any expert fees. The sale is undone as fully as possible.
Price reduction (actio aestimatoria). You keep the property but receive part of the purchase price back. The amount is typically determined based on the cost of remedying the defect, or based on the difference in market value between the property with and without the defect.
Contrary to what many sellers believe, as a buyer you cannot hand this choice over to the judge or the seller. The Court of Cassation expressly confirmed on 23 March 2017 that the choice belongs solely to the buyer (Cass., 23 March 2017, AR C.15.0232.F). The judge may reject an offer of repair in kind from the seller if you do not want that repair.
You can still change your choice during the proceedings
An important point: if you initially claimed rescission, you can still switch to a price reduction during the proceedings, and vice versa. The Court of Appeal of Mons expressly confirmed this rule: the buyer may reconsider during the proceedings and bring the other claim, unless they have expressly waived it (Mons, 19 November 2019, JLMB 2021, no. 9, 404). The buyer does not have to justify the reasons for their choice.
This flexibility is valuable. It is not uncommon for new information to come to light during proceedings — a higher repair cost than originally estimated, a favourable opportunity to sell the property in its current state — that renders your original choice outdated.
When is rescission the better option?
Rescission makes sense when:
- The defect is so serious that the property no longer serves its purpose. A home that is structurally unfit for habitation, land that remains permanently contaminated, a building with fundamental stability issues.
- The repair cost approaches the purchase price. When repair would require 60% or more of the price, there is little point in continuing to invest in a fundamentally defective property.
- The seller acted in bad faith and you prefer to walk away. After discovering fraud or concealment, some buyers simply want out of the transaction, regardless of the rational trade-off.
- The property has not been occupied in the meantime. The sooner after purchase you claim rescission, the easier the restitution.
When is price reduction the better option?
Price reduction makes sense when:
- You want to keep the property despite the defect. You have planned renovations, you enjoy living there, or market conditions make a new purchase unfavourable.
- The defect can be remedied at a reasonable cost. You have it repaired and you get the amount back. Little changes in your day-to-day experience.
- Rescission would become practically complicated. If you have carried out renovation work in the meantime, the restitution calculations can become complex. A price reduction is then often simpler.
How is the price reduction calculated?
Two approaches appear in case law.
Based on the repair cost. The judge sets the amount of the price reduction at the cost of the works needed to remedy the defect, possibly increased by loss of rent during the works (Mons, 19 November 2019, JLMB 2021, no. 9, 404). In practice this is the most commonly used method, especially for concrete material defects.
Based on the loss of value. The judge has an expert calculate what the property is worth with and without the defect, and awards the difference as a price reduction. This can be more favourable when the defect cannot really be remedied — for example, a permanently lost building possibility or irreversible unsuitability.
In both cases, a court-appointed expert is often designated. The Court of Cassation has expressly confirmed this approach (Cass., 20 April 2012, AR C.11.0608.F).
An important nuance: the calculation does not take into account the price at which you may have resold the property later. The loss in value is determined at the time of the original purchase, not at a later transaction (Cass., 10 March 2011).
Additional damages in the event of bad faith
In addition to the choice between rescission and price reduction, you can, in certain cases, claim additional damages. This is possible when the seller knew or should have known about the defect (Article 1645 of the old Civil Code).
What falls under such additional damages?
- Temporary housing when you could not occupy the property during the works.
- Moving costs as a result of the rescission or the works.
- Lost rental income when you had intended to rent out the property.
- Professional expert fees you had to incur.
- Moral damages in exceptional cases, in particular in cases of fraud or concealment.
The Court of Appeal of Liège, for example, held that a buyer forced to rent a new home because of damp issues was entitled to compensation for the "loss of enjoyment" linked to that double rent (Liège, 11 February 2013, JLMB 2013, 2093).
Against a specialised seller, there is a presumption of knowledge, which often makes additional damages achievable (see our spoke on the specialised seller).
Abuse of rights: when will the judge reject your choice?
Although the choice is in principle free, the judge can find abuse of rights when you act disproportionately. A buyer who demands full rescission for a defect that is easily repaired (for example, EUR 8,000 in repair works on a property worth EUR 400,000) may run into abuse of rights.
A telling example: in a case where buyers had carried out renovation works before the notarial deed and discovered a damp problem in the process, the Brussels court ruled that it would amount to abuse of rights to demand full rescission — all the more because the works the buyers had carried out in the meantime made the property less valuable for the sellers (Court of Brussels, 29 March 2019, TBO 2019, no. 6, 439). The sale was rescinded, but the sellers were awarded compensation for the loss of value caused by the works.
The message: the choice is your right, but within the limits of reasonableness.
Chain of sellers and joint and several liability
A specific issue arises with successive sales. When a home has been resold several times and a hidden defect is eventually established, each seller in the chain can in principle be held liable. In certain cases, the court can order several sellers jointly and severally (in solidum) to refund their respective price and pay additional damages.
There is, however, one exception: when a contractor is in the chain (for example, in new-build homes), that qualitative chain of claims is broken (Cass., 15 September 2011). The principal of a construction contract cannot directly sue the subcontractor on the basis of Article 1641 of the old Civil Code.
Practical tips
Weigh the options early. Although you can switch during the proceedings, it is strategically wiser to have a well-founded choice from the outset. It sets the tone of the negotiations and the content of your writ of summons.
Have an expert crunch the numbers. For the price reduction, you need a precise repair estimate. For rescission, you must be able to show that the problems are so far-reaching that the property is unusable for you. In both cases, an independent technical report is valuable.
Document your additional damages. Double rent, expert fees, lost income — everything must be carefully documented with invoices and correspondence.
For the full legal framework, see our pillar on hidden defects in real estate.
Unsure which claim stands strongest in your file? An initial analysis by a specialised lawyer can chart the strategic course. Get in touch at info@reius.be.