Virtually every preliminary sale agreement for existing real estate contains some version of the formula: "The property is sold in the state in which it stands, with all visible and hidden defects." Many sellers and even real estate agents believe this clause constitutes an impregnable line of defence against later claims. That is a dangerous illusion. In this article, we set out when the clause works — and when it falls away.
What exactly is an exoneration clause?
An exoneration clause is a contractual provision by which the seller limits or excludes his statutory obligation to warrant against hidden defects. Article 1643 of the old Civil Code expressly permits this principle: the parties may agree that the seller does not have to warrant against hidden defects.
In practice, three formulations are common:
- The general exoneration: "sold in the state in which it stands, with all visible and hidden defects."
- The partial exoneration: for example "sold without warranty for the moisture problem in the cellar, which the buyer accepts".
- The contractual warranty: for example "the seller warrants that the roof has been free of leaks since the last works in 2020". This is not an exoneration but the opposite: a specific guarantee.
The basic rules
Between private individuals, the general exoneration clause is in principle valid. That is the default rule.
In a B2C relationship — i.e. where the seller is a business and the buyer a consumer — the clause is void. Article VI.83, 14° of the Code of Economic Law renders such a general exoneration non-binding on the consumer. A property developer selling a home to a private buyer cannot rely on this clause to escape his warranty obligation.
In sales between businesses (B2B), exoneration is in principle possible, provided that the essence of the delivery obligation is not eroded.
The major exception: bad faith
This is the heart of the matter. Article 1643 of the old Civil Code provides that the seller may only rely on the exoneration clause if he is in good faith. Anyone who knew or ought to have known of the defect cannot hide behind a general clause.
The Brussels Court of Appeal has summarised the rule succinctly: article 1643 of the old Civil Code deprives the seller of the possibility to invoke an exoneration clause where there is bad faith, meaning that the buyer must show that the seller had knowledge of the existence of the specific defect (Brussels, 5 February 2021, JT 2022, no. 6890, 152).
The crucial question is therefore: how do you prove knowledge on the part of the seller? Three scenarios occur most frequently.
Scenario 1: the specialised seller
The Court of Cassation has expressly confirmed that a presumption of knowledge rests on the manufacturer and on the specialised seller, whether or not he is a professional (Cass., 15 January 2021, AR C.20.0241.N). The court assesses the degree of specialisation and the technical competencies.
Who falls under this regime?
- Contractors and architects who sell their own home.
- Property developers and real estate investors.
- Anyone with professional knowledge directly related to the defect.
For this category, the presumption applies: they are deemed to know the defect, unless they prove that it was truly undetectable. The burden of proof is reversed. This significantly weakens the exoneration clause.
Scenario 2: the self-builder
The position of the self-builder is more nuanced. A DIY builder is not automatically regarded as a specialised seller. But in an important judgment of 18 February 2019, the Court of Cassation held that even a self-builder "must know" that certain technical standards must be respected (Cass., 18 February 2019, AR C.18.0346.N).
In the case at hand, non-professional sellers had constructed a house without the assistance of a contractor or architect, and had departed from the original concept of a watertight concrete tank for the cellar. When water infiltration occurred, the Court of Cassation held that the sellers "should at the very least have realised that their manner of construction would give rise to problems", since any prudent self-builder must know that appropriate measures are required to make a cellar watertight. The exoneration clause was set aside.
The lesson: self-builders too are deemed to have certain basic knowledge. Anyone who departs from the standards without calling in a professional can no longer use his ignorance as a shield.
Scenario 3: deliberate concealment
Anyone who actively conceals the defect automatically loses the protection of the clause. A seller who installs false walls to hide moisture problems, a painter who paints over mould, a tiled floor covering a cracked cellar floor — these are all acts qualified as bad faith (Liège, 11 February 2013, JLMB 2013, 2093).
Beyond neutralising the exoneration clause, concealment also opens the door to fraud (article 1116 of the old Civil Code), which gives the buyer additional legal remedies.
A valid clause for a known defect: how?
What if the seller does know about a defect and still wants to exonerate himself for it? That is possible, but under strict conditions. The clause must specifically mention the defect. A general clause is not enough; you must name the problem.
Example of a valid clause: "The buyer declares to be aware of the presence of a moisture problem in the cellar, as described in the attached technical report dated X. The buyer accepts this defect and expressly waives any claim in this respect."
Example of an invalid clause (for a known defect): "Sold in the state in which it stands, with all visible and hidden defects." Too general, too vague, no proof that the buyer agreed to this specific problem.
What about B2C: the role of the Code of Economic Law
An important point for anyone buying from a professional: the Mons Court of Appeal has expressly confirmed that a business-seller cannot rely on an exoneration clause for hidden defects vis-à-vis a consumer, even where that consumer has themselves purchased the property with a view to later resale (Mons, 8 January 2019, JLMB 2019, no. 17, 785).
This is important protection for private buyers. Anyone buying a home from a property developer, a real estate investor or a dealer in real estate has a much stronger position than the standard clauses in the preliminary sale agreement suggest.
Practical tips for the buyer
Investigate the seller's capacity. Is he an architect, contractor, property developer or someone with demonstrable construction knowledge? Document this. His profession or expertise may be decisive for the application of the presumption of knowledge.
Gather evidence of earlier works. Photos, testimonies from neighbours, permit applications, tender numbers — anything showing that the seller carried out or had works carried out can prove knowledge.
Request specific declarations. In case of doubt: have the seller declare in writing that there are no moisture problems, no asbestos present, no urban planning infringements. If the opposite later emerges, this is powerful evidence of bad faith.
Practical tips for the seller
Be specific. A general clause offers much less protection than a specific mention of known problems.
Disclose what you know. Transparent disclosure of problems, coupled with the buyer's specific acceptance of the risk, protects you better than an attempt to sweep everything under a vague exoneration.
Avoid concealment. The boomerang is bigger than you think. What you try to hide can later be qualified as fraud, with sanctions reaching much further than an ordinary warranty claim.
For the full framework of your rights as buyer and seller, consult our pillar on hidden defects when purchasing a house.
Do you have doubts about the validity of an exoneration clause in your file? A quick analysis can clarify a lot. Contact us at info@reius.be.