The rent under a commercial lease is in principle fixed for nine years, with only an annual indexation. However, the Belgian Commercial Lease Act offers both parties an opening to adjust the rent to changing market conditions. This mechanism is called rent review and is set out in Article 6 of the Act.
The statutory rule: 15% threshold
Article 6 of the Commercial Lease Act provides:
"Upon the expiry of each three-year period, the parties have the right to request the Justice of the Peace to review the rent, provided they prove that the normal rental value of the leased property, as a result of new circumstances, is at least 15% higher or lower than the rent set in the lease agreement or fixed at the last review."
Two cumulative conditions are therefore required:
New circumstances have arisen since the conclusion of the agreement (or since the last review).
Those circumstances have changed the normal rental value by at least 15%.
The judge decides on the basis of equity, without taking into account the favourable or unfavourable return that is attributable solely to the tenant.
What are "new circumstances"?
The Belgian Court of Cassation provided important clarification in 2024 (Cass. 19 April 2024, AR C.23.0401.F). "New circumstances" must be understood as:
"Objective circumstances, independent of the will of the parties, which durably influence the rental value of a commercial premises, but which were not present when the rent was determined and have arisen since, so that they could not be taken into account when determining the rent."
Concretely this means:
The circumstance must be objective (not subjective)
It must be independent of the will of the parties
It must be durable (not a temporary fluctuation)
It must have arisen after the conclusion of the agreement or after the last review
Important exception: improvement works carried out on the premises by the landlord, even with the tenant's consent, do not as a rule constitute a new circumstance. The landlord therefore cannot request a rent increase based on its own investments in the premises.
Examples of new circumstances
Possible legitimate new circumstances from case law and doctrine:
Change in the district or neighbourhood: upgrading through new public facilities, or deterioration through decline
New infrastructure: a metro extension, a new shopping street, a large commercial development
Demographic evolution: significant population growth or decline in the catchment area
Amendment of the zoning plan: a ban on new shops in the area, or conversely liberalisation
Economic shocks: the Court of Cassation in 2024 recognised an uncertain economic climate due to a global pandemic as an objective circumstance when determining the normal rental value (Cass. 4 October 2024, AR C.23.0272.N)
Covid-19 as a new circumstance?
This question has been intensely debated. A court in East Flanders held that Covid-19 can only be accepted as a "new circumstance" if it is proven that (1) the corona crisis has resulted in a general rise or fall in commercial rents and (2) a durable effect can be expected during the following three-year period (Court of East Flanders, Ghent division, 15 March 2024).
The burden of proof therefore weighs heavily on the party invoking Covid. A merely temporary drop in turnover is insufficient. You must demonstrate that market conditions have changed durably.
Actual rent versus normal rental value
An important principle from a Cassation judgment of 21 December 2023 (AR C.23.0046.N): the review is based on the normal rental value, not on the rent actually paid.
Concretely:
The comparison must be made between the normal rental value at the conclusion of the agreement and the normal rental value at the time of the review application
Indexation and contractually stipulated adjustments are not counted when determining the 15% threshold
This can lead to notable situations. A rent that has already risen sharply through indexation since the original agreement may still be below the "normal rental value" — and therefore give rise to an upward review.
How does the court carry out the valuation?
In the event of a dispute, the Justice of the Peace typically appoints a court-appointed expert. The Commercial Lease Act provides some criteria (Article 19):
The customary rent in the district, agglomeration and region
The particular nature of the business carried on
The advantage of any subletting
The judge is not guided by the tenant's overall return, especially where that return extends far beyond the boundaries of the premises (for example, an online web shop that uses the premises only for storage). This was confirmed in Justice of the Peace Bruges, 23 May 2024.
The judge balances the interests of all parties involved and adheres to the fundamental agreements of the original commercial lease. He cannot simply interfere with the "building blocks" of the contract: partial agreements on uncontested terms are definitively binding (Justice of the Peace Ghent, 24 March 2025).
The strict three-month deadline
The rent review claim can only be brought in the last three months of the current three-year period (Article 6, third paragraph). Too early or too late: the claim is inadmissible.
The revised rent takes effect on the first day of the next three-year period. During the proceedings, the previous rent can be claimed provisionally.
The review request does not suspend the enforceability of the rent (Justice of the Peace Arlon, 21 February 2024). You must therefore continue to pay the old rent during the proceedings, otherwise you risk default proceedings.
The burden of proof on the applicant
The burden of proof lies with the party requesting the review. You must demonstrate both the existence of the new circumstances and the change of at least 15% in the rental value.
To be taken into consideration — and to persuade the judge to appoint an expert — your request must at the very least have an appearance of merit and be supported by sufficiently concrete and precise elements (Justice of the Peace Arlon, 21 February 2024).
In practice: a mere assertion is not enough. You need:
A valuation by a real estate expert or broker
Concrete comparison points in the area
Evidence of objective changes (municipal decisions, infrastructure works, demographic figures)
Practical tips
For the tenant seeking a reduction:
Build your file early. Start collecting evidence at least six months before the deadline.
Find a real estate expert with experience in commercial leases in your segment.
Compare with recently concluded leases in the area — not with asking prices.
For the landlord seeking an increase:
Actively track the evolution of the neighbourhood and the market.
Document infrastructure works and upgrades in the surroundings.
Do not count on improvements you have made yourself — they do not count.
For both parties:
- Explore whether an amicable settlement is possible. Proceedings can take one to two years and quickly cost several thousand euros in expert fees.
Would you like a full overview of your position as commercial tenant or landlord? Read our guide on rights and obligations under commercial leases.