You buy a house. A few months later, you discover that the extension at the rear was never permitted. Or that the attic was converted into living space without a permit. Or that you receive a restoration order from the municipality because a multi-family dwelling had been unlawfully split into units. What are your rights?
Building violations form an interesting legal crossroads. They can constitute a latent defect, a disturbance of title (warranty against eviction), grounds for error or fraud, or precontractual liability of the seller. Which route is strongest depends on the specific circumstances. In this article, we outline the different avenues.
Not every permit issue is the same
First, an important nuance. "No permit" is a collective term covering very different situations. The legal consequences differ per category.
The permit is entirely missing. An extension, outbuilding or division that never received a permit and for which there is no prescription or regularisation. Here you stand strongest legally.
The violation has prescribed. Work carried out without a permit, but so long ago that the criminal statute of limitations has expired. The work is not thereby "permitted", but is no longer punishable. A restoration order may still be possible in certain cases.
The work is deemed permitted. For works predating 1 January 1962 (depending on the municipality), a statutory presumption of permit often applies, provided the work is still unchanged. In that case, there is usually no problem.
The permit was issued but not correctly executed. The plans are permitted, but the execution deviates. The deviation may or may not be minor.
Regularisation is possible. In some cases, the violation can still be regularised. That does not change the defect — a defect that can be regularised remains a defect (see below).
Track 1: the latent defect
The classic route. A missing permit can constitute a latent defect when it makes the normal use of the property unsuitable or seriously burdens it.
The Court of Appeal of Antwerp has accepted a missing permit as grounds for rescission of the sale, "even if a regularisation can subsequently be obtained" (Antwerp, 29 October 2012, TBBR 2014, 215). That is an important ruling: the fact that a regularisation is technically possible does not remove the defect. The buyer does not have to bear the burden of a regularisation procedure.
But there are nuances. A mere planning infringement without an enforcement order is not automatically regarded as a latent defect. The Court of Appeal of Liège dismissed a claim where a mere infringement without concrete enforcement threat was invoked (Liège, 10 May 2012, TBBR 2015, no. 1, 23). The question is always: does this affect use in a meaningful way?
An extension that is actually being used and for which no enforcement threatens is a less serious defect than a missing permit for a division for which the municipality actively initiates restoration proceedings.
Track 2: the warranty against eviction
For some building violations, a second doctrine can be invoked: the warranty against eviction under Article 1626 of the old Civil Code. This doctrine is not subject to the short time limit of Article 1648 old CC — an important strategic advantage when you are too late for a latent defect claim.
The Court of Cassation has expressly confirmed that the absence of a planning permit can constitute a disturbance of title. Where a third party — the authorities in this case — has the right to initiate a restoration order due to the absence of a permit under the Flemish Planning Code, the seller must indemnify the buyer (Cass., 31 March 2017, TBBR 2018, no. 6, 323).
A concrete example: in one case, a multi-family dwelling was sold, but the permit for the division was missing. The municipality initiated a restoration order to return the property to a single-family dwelling. The court of first instance in Ghent classified this as an eviction for which the seller owed indemnity (Ghent Court of First Instance, 29 March 2011, TBO 2011, 179). The buyer was reimbursed for the works.
The limit? A merely theoretical infringement without concrete threat of eviction is insufficient. There must be a real risk of disturbance of possession. An attic that was converted without a permit but is actually being used without the municipality taking action does not constitute a disturbance of title (see the earlier Liège 2012 decision).
Track 3: fraud and error
Where the seller has declared in the preliminary contract or the notarial deed that everything is in order with the permits, while knowing the contrary, this opens the door to fraud.
A telling example: the Court of Appeal of Antwerp ruled that a seller who wrongly declared in the authentic deed that the land was not covered by the Forest Decree — while knowing that a reforestation obligation existed — committed incidental fraud. The court called this "a breach of the precontractual duty of information" and "an artifice within the meaning of Article 1116 old CC" (Antwerp, 14 July 2022, NJW 2022, no. 471, 844).
The limitation period for a fraud claim is five years — much broader than the short time limit of Article 1648 old CC. For those who are too late for latent defects, fraud can therefore be a valuable alternative.
Track 4: the warranty clause
Sometimes the seller has included specific representations or warranties in the preliminary contract. For example: "the seller warrants the regularity of the constructions carried out" or "the seller declares that no works requiring a permit have been carried out without a permit".
Such clauses create a contractual warranty independent of the warranty for latent defects. When they are breached, you fall back on the general limitation period of ten years for contractual non-performance.
But beware: the Court of Appeal of Brussels has ruled that such warranty clauses must be interpreted restrictively. A clause stating that the seller "remains personally liable for the erection of buildings through his own doing" was interpreted as limited to the necessary construction works, not to additional consequential damages such as moving costs or lost income (Brussels, 17 May 2006). The more specific and comprehensive the clause, the better it protects you.
The chain of evidence: what must you prove?
For a latent defect claim, in addition to the ordinary elements, you must above all prove that the seller knew or ought to have known of the problem — especially if you want to defeat the exoneration clause.
In practice, sellers often escape by claiming ignorance. The Court of Appeal of Liège accepted that there was no proof of knowledge, "even if his father carried out the dubious works" (Liège, 10 May 2012, TBBR 2015, no. 1, 23). The burden of proving knowledge is therefore real.
How can you prove knowledge?
- The construction plan in the seller's possession. In itself insufficient to prove knowledge of a building violation, ruled the Brussels court (Brussels Court, 31 October 2013), but valuable in combination with other elements.
- The planning information accompanying the sale. It contains permit applications, refusals and enforcement actions. A seller who has these documents is deemed to know them.
- The post-intervention file which the seller must hand over at sale. Works after 2001 are included, and indicate knowledge of what has been carried out.
- Testimony from neighbours or workmen who can confirm that the seller actively carried out or had the works carried out.
Concurrence with criminal proceedings
A specific point of attention: building violations are often also criminal offences. When a criminal complaint is filed, the principle "le criminel tient le civil en l'état" applies. The civil procedure is suspended until the criminal procedure is concluded.
That is not always in your favour. A criminal procedure can take years. In consultation with your lawyer, you must weigh whether a criminal complaint is in your interest. Sometimes a swift civil rescission via the warranty against eviction is more effective.
Practical tips for the buyer
Request the planning information before the preliminary contract. Read it thoroughly. Look at permit applications, refusals, complaints and enforcement actions.
Request the post-intervention file. Works that do not fit into a permit but do appear in the PIF are a red flag.
Carry out a visual inspection on site. Does the actual situation match the cadastral plan? An extension not shown in the cadastre is an important signal.
Engage a lawyer quickly. The choice between latent defects, warranty against eviction, fraud or contractual warranty co-determines the time limit within which you must act and the chances of success.
Practical tips for the seller
Be explicit about what you know. Do not conceal works carried out without a permit. A transparent mention in the preliminary contract, coupled with a specific acceptance of risk by the buyer, protects you much better than a general exoneration.
Avoid inaccurate declarations in the notarial deed. A declaration that everything is in order when you know there is a problem constitutes incidental fraud. The consequences are severe.
For the full framework, consult our pillar on latent defects.
Have you discovered a building violation after purchase, or are you being pursued as a seller? The correct legal classification is essential. Contact us at info@reius.be.