Contracts drawn up by property developers regularly contain a clause that severely limits liability for defects: the developer would only be liable for hidden defects for one year after provisional acceptance. It sounds innocuous, but such an exoneration clause hollows out the buyer's protection. Case law therefore sees through it. This article explains why such clauses are usually null and void, on which three independent grounds, and what that means for you as a buyer or as an association of co-owners (ACO).
What exactly is an exoneration clause?
An exoneration clause is a contractual provision by which a party limits or excludes its liability. In the construction context, it typically involves a clause in which the property developer stipulates that, after provisional acceptance, he can only be held liable for hidden defects for a limited period — often one year. After that, he would be discharged from all liability.
For the developer, this is attractive: it drastically shortens the period during which he can be held to account. For the buyer, it is damaging, because hidden defects by definition only manifest themselves later, sometimes years after acceptance. Liability of barely one year after provisional acceptance means, in practice, that hardly any real warranty period remains.
The question is therefore whether a developer may limit his liability in this way. In most cases, the answer given by the courts is: no.
The first ground: the ten-year liability cannot be shortened
The first reason why such a clause fails is that it clashes with the ten-year liability for defects affecting stability. This liability — governed by Article 1792 of the Civil Code and, as regards the developer, by Article 6 of the Breyne Act — is a matter of public policy because it concerns public safety: it relates to the soundness of buildings.
What is a matter of public policy cannot be modulated contractually. A clause limiting liability to one year after provisional acceptance therefore cannot contract away that ten-year period. For serious defects that threaten stability, the developer remains liable for ten years, regardless of what the contract provides. The scope and operation of that period are examined further in our spoke on minor hidden defects and time limits.
The second ground: consumer protection
The second ground lies in the Code of Economic Law. The period within which a consumer can act against defects may not be shortened to such an extent that statutory protection is hollowed out. A clause reducing the warranty period to one year touches on that consumer protection.
A defence often raised by developers is that the ACO is not a consumer but an undertaking — after all, it holds an enterprise number, manages numerous apartments and is represented by a professional building manager. Case law has rejected that defence. The status of consumer remains attached to the individual co-owner who bought as a consumer. The fact that the common interests are represented through the ACO legal entity does not deprive that co-owner of his consumer rights. A buyer who directly bought a home off-plan enjoys consumer protection; the fact that he ends up in the collective of the ACO cannot deprive him of that protection. There is even legislative initiative on this point to recognise the ACO as an intermediate figure between consumer and undertaking.
The third ground: the hollowing out of the mandatory two-stage acceptance
The third ground is specific to the Breyne Act and concerns Article 9. That provision requires acceptance to take place in two stages, with at least one year between provisional and final acceptance. The aim is that the building goes through all seasons before it is definitively approved.
An exoneration clause that limits liability for hidden defects to one year after provisional acceptance would hollow out that mandatory two-stage acceptance. The reasoning is subtle but powerful: if liability for minor hidden defects is made so short, a final acceptance could take place despite defects attributable to the developer that have not been remedied. The statutory protection of the mandatory two-stage acceptance — precisely intended to bring defects to light — would then become meaningless. That is why the period may not be shortened in this way.
Three grounds, and two are enough
The strength of this case law is that the three grounds stand independently side by side. The nullity of the exoneration clause rests on a cumulative basis: the non-reducible ten-year liability, consumer protection through the Code of Economic Law, and the hollowing-out reasoning in relation to Article 9 of the Breyne Act. Strictly speaking, two of the three already suffice, but the cumulative character closes off every escape route.
For anyone who finds such a clause in their contract, the message is reassuring: the presence of the clause does not mean that your rights are lost. As a rule, the clause is null and void, and the statutory time limits continue to apply. How those time limits work exactly and when they start to run is dealt with in detail in the pillar on the acceptance of a new-build apartment.
It is also worth being alert to the moment when the clause is invoked. Developers often only pull out the exoneration clause when a buyer or ACO brings a claim, hoping to block it immediately. Do not let that reflex discourage you: the validity of the clause is a legal question that the court itself assesses, and the three grounds of nullity apply regardless of how forcefully the other party presents the clause. A timely legal analysis of your contract makes clear which time limits actually apply to you.
What about other clauses?
Not every limitation of liability is prohibited. For minor hidden defects — which do not affect stability — liability is in principle not a matter of public policy, so something can be agreed contractually on this point. But there too, a limit applies: one may not fully exonerate the legitimate possibility of acting against hidden defects, and the period for reacting may not be made artificially so short that no real warranty remains. Too short a period for protest is subject to the same test as the exoneration clause itself.
The parallel with invoicing terms is illuminating. Everyone knows the clause requiring an invoice to be protested within eight days. In the case of hidden defects, it works differently: one may not artificially curtail the period for acting on the basis of a minor hidden defect by contractually setting too short a warranty period. The difference between a valid time provision and a disguised exoneration lies precisely in the question of whether a real, meaningful warranty still remains. A clause that in fact amounts to hollowing out any warranty will be requalified and set aside by the court, even if it is formally presented as a mere time-limit arrangement.
Practical conclusion
A clause limiting the property developer's liability to one year after provisional acceptance will, as a rule, not stand up. It clashes with the non-reducible ten-year liability, with consumer protection, and with the mandatory two-stage acceptance under the Breyne Act. So do not be put off by such a clause in your contract.
Finally, it is useful to realise that the nullity of the exoneration clause does not mean that every contractual arrangement concerning liability is worthless. Valid clauses — for example on the way defects are established or a reasonable notification period that does not hollow out the warranty — remain in force. The court cuts out the invalid clause and leaves the rest of the agreement intact. For you, this means: do not read your contract as one whole that stands or falls with a single clause, but have each clause tested separately for its validity.
Does your purchase agreement contain an exoneration clause, or is the developer invoking it to fend off your claim? Reius Advocaten reviews the validity of the clause and your remaining rights. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.