A new-build project runs smoothly — until the property developer runs into financial difficulty. The construction site stalls, works drag on, and in the worst case the developer goes bankrupt. For buyers, who have often already paid substantial amounts and do not yet have a finished apartment, this is a nightmare. What then happens to your apartment, and what protection do you have? This article walks through the various scenarios, from a struggling developer, via judicial reorganisation, to actual bankruptcy.
The grey zone: a struggling developer
Not every difficulty amounts immediately to bankruptcy. A common scenario is the developer who is not yet bankrupt and has not even applied for judicial reorganisation, but is structurally short of cash. The result is that the completion deadline for the works keeps slipping — the site simply does not get finished.
For an individual buyer wondering what to do, a sensible first step is to make the association of co-owners (ACO) operational. As soon as the first apartment is sold and the deed is transcribed, the co-ownership comes into being and the Belgian Apartment Act applies. It therefore pays to check early whether the ACO can be brought to life, so that the various buyers and owners can jointly deliberate on the initiatives they wish to take. On your own you are in a weaker position than as an organised group.
Scenario 1: judicial reorganisation
If the developer faces a judicial reorganisation, the starting position is relatively reassuring: in principle, ongoing contracts continue. Judicial reorganisation is specifically intended to allow the business to continue, and the terms of the existing contracts remain in force in principle.
What you may experience, however, is that certain adjustments are proposed as part of the reorganisation plan. It might be suggested that a particular finish is dispensable, or that the finishing works be carried out by another contractor. Such adjustments may form part of a solution-oriented plan to bring the developer back out of the red. The essential point remains, however, that the contracts continue, which is the least bad outcome for the buyers.
Scenario 2: bankruptcy with unfinished works
Things become more troublesome when the developer actually goes bankrupt. Here you must distinguish between two situations, depending on whether or not the works have already been completed.
If the works have not yet been completed, they obviously still need to be finished. It is precisely for this that the Breyne Act (the Belgian statute protecting buyers of housing to be built) offers important protection: the completion guarantee. This guarantee is designed to ensure that the building is finished when the builder defaults. The trustee in bankruptcy is at the controls and is in principle expected either to continue performing the contract, or, through the completion guarantee, to have the works continued or completed by others.
That is precisely why the Breyne Act came into being: buyers who paid in instalments and, on bankruptcy, were left with an unfinished building and without their money. The completion guarantee is a direct response to that historical risk. If you want to know more about the protective regime of the Breyne Act, read our spoke on the circumvention structures around the Breyne Act, which covers the scope of application in detail.
Scenario 3: bankruptcy with units already delivered
If the works have been completed and delivered, a different, more technical question arises, particularly when the bankrupt developer still has unsold units in its patrimony. Must the trustee, in respect of those unsold apartments — which are still owned by the bankrupt developer — contribute to the common charges of the ACO?
Here, case law is divided on the question whether this is a debt within the estate or a debt of the estate — a distinction that determines whether and how the ACO can recover its contribution. A defensible position is that the trustee's choice to retain those units in the bankrupt developer's patrimony is enough to require the trustee to bear the contribution to charges as well: whoever chooses to remain within the co-ownership arrangement also bears the associated charges. The parallel is with rent for a property that is retained after bankruptcy. These are, however, issues that can raise considerable discussion and require thorough analysis of the specific file.
The distinction between a debt within and a debt of the estate is not academic hair-splitting: it determines the ranking with which the ACO can enforce its claim. A debt of the estate — an obligation entered into by the trustee itself in the context of the administration — generally enjoys better treatment than an ordinary debt within the estate, which must queue up with the other creditors. For an ACO seeking to recover its common charges from a bankrupt developer with unsold units, that qualification therefore makes a substantial difference to the prospects of actual payment. It is therefore advisable to file the claim early and with proper substantiation, and to have its qualification legally assessed.
What you can do yourself
The common thread through all these scenarios is that organised action pays off. Buyers who purchased from a developer expecting it to complete everything, and who have no experience with construction files themselves, are particularly vulnerable when left with an unfinished building. By making the ACO operational early, the owners can deliberate collectively and exercise their rights coherently.
Equally important is to invoke in good time the safeguards offered by the Breyne Act — the completion guarantee in particular — and, in the face of impending discontinuity, to seek legal advice before the situation escalates. Moreover, when a new-build ACO reaches a deadlock because both the developer and the syndic are "burnt", the appointment of a judicial administrator can provide a way out.
A final point of attention concerns timing. The earlier buyers take signals of financial difficulty seriously, the more room for manoeuvre remains. Anyone who waits until the site is completely at a standstill or until bankruptcy is a fait accompli loses valuable time and negotiating power. A proactive ACO that documents the degree of completion, maps out the advance payments made and verifies the guarantees, stands much stronger when negotiating with the trustee or the guarantee institution. Preparation is often decisive for the final outcome in this type of file.
Practical conclusion
A struggling or bankrupt developer is a serious situation, but not one without legal remedies. In judicial reorganisation, contracts in principle continue; in bankruptcy with unfinished works, the completion guarantee under the Breyne Act provides protection; and where units have already been delivered, there is a defensible basis for requiring the trustee to contribute to charges. Make the ACO operational early and seek assistance in good time. The wider framework can be found in our pillar on delivery.
It is worth keeping the distinction between the various guarantees sharply in mind. The completion guarantee concerns the finishing of the building, while other securities may relate more to the reimbursement of amounts already paid. Which guarantee applies in your situation and how you concretely invoke it depends on the nature of the contract and the moment at which the difficulties arise. An early inventory of the guarantees provided — often found in the purchase deed and accompanying documents — is therefore one of the first steps a well-informed buyer or ACO takes.
Is the developer of your project at risk of running into difficulty, or are you left with an unfinished building after a bankruptcy? Reius Advocaten assists buyers and ACOs in invoking guarantees and organising a coordinated approach. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.