The acceptance of your apartment does not close the door. Even after you have accepted the works, defects may emerge that were not visible at the time of acceptance — a leaking roof, water infiltration, a finishing defect that only manifests itself later. This is what the liability for minor hidden defects is for. It is less well known than the ten-year liability, but at least as important in practice. This article explains what a minor hidden defect is, which time limits apply, and why the starting point of the period is crucial.
What is a minor hidden defect?
A minor hidden defect is a defect that was not visible at the provisional acceptance and only manifests itself afterwards. "Minor" here means that the defect is not so serious as to affect the stability of the building — because in that case it falls under the ten-year liability, a heavier and stricter regime.
Two conditions apply. The defect must not have been visible at the provisional acceptance — what was visible and recorded falls under the ordinary acceptance regime, not under hidden defects. And it must concern an abnormal characteristic of the building: a deviation from what one could reasonably expect.
Case law adopts a rather broad range. At the lower end of the spectrum, the question is whether the buyer, had he known of the defect at the time of purchase or acceptance, would have raised an objection — a minimal threshold. At the upper end, the minor hidden defect borders on the serious stability defect. Between these two extremes lies the scope of application of minor hidden defects.
The difference with visible defects and stability defects
Much discussion arises because co-owners confuse three categories. Visible defects are noted at the provisional acceptance and recorded in the minutes; if you do not, they are deemed accepted. Minor hidden defects are precisely not visible at that moment and appear later. Stability defects, finally, affect the solidity or suitability of the building and fall under the ten-year liability of public policy.
This distinction is not a play on words. It determines which regime, which time limit and which contractual latitude apply. Anyone who confuses these categories complicates his own construction file — a pitfall we address further in the pillar on acceptance. Signing the acceptance minutes, incidentally, does not cover hidden defects: these remain enforceable even after you have accepted the works.
The time limits: ten-year warranty, reasonable period to react
For minor hidden defects, there are in fact two time limits that you must not confuse.
The warranty period is ten years. That is the outer limit: the defect must manifest itself within ten years to still fall under this regime.
In addition, there is the procedural period: as soon as the defect appears, you must react and bring your claim within a reasonable time. For a long time, case law linked that reasonable period closely to the short period under sales law (articles 1641 to 1648 of the Civil Code). Today, the assessment is more nuanced: in assessing reasonableness, the courts take strong account of the circumstances specific to the contract for works — could the owner have detected the nature of the defect earlier, what was its complexity, and so on. The reasonable period is therefore assessed contextually.
The crucial point: when does the period start running?
Here lies an insight that saves many buyers. The Court of Cassation has ruled that the reasonable period does not start running after the completion of the works, but only at the moment when one detects or could have detected the defect.
That is an important nuance. It means that the period can only start on the moment when the hidden defect actually reveals itself — which may possibly be several years after the end of the works. The only absolute limit remains the ten-year warranty period within which the defect must manifest itself. Acceptance minutes, however signed, do not change any of this: they do not cover defects which at that moment could not yet be detected.
In practice, this means that when a defect appears late, you are not automatically too late simply because the works were carried out years ago. What is decisive is when you could reasonably have discovered the defect.
That anchor point — the final acceptance as the starting point for certain periods, and the detection of the defect as the starting point for the reasonable response period — can even be a reassuring argument within the association of co-owners. When co-owners hesitate to sign the minutes of final acceptance out of fear of no longer being able to claim anything afterwards, one can explain to them that signing does not prevent them from later invoking the liability of the construction actors on the basis of hidden or stability defects. This avoids the acceptance being needlessly blocked by a misunderstanding about the scope of the signature.
Proving fault, and the contractual latitude
Unlike the ten-year liability for stability defects, the liability for minor hidden defects is a fault-based liability: you must prove the fault. There is no presumption of fault in your favour.
Moreover, the liability for minor hidden defects is not of public policy. As a result, there is some contractual latitude to derogate from it — but that latitude is limited. One may not fully exclude the legitimate possibility of acting against hidden defects, and one may not artificially make the response period so short that the guarantee effectively disappears. An overly broad exoneration clause of the property developer is struck down for this reason. The liability may apply to the contractor, but also to the architect, the engineering firm or the stability engineer, depending on who committed the fault.
An important practical element is that the rights under a contract for works transfer upon sale. A subsequent buyer steps into the shoes of the original owner and can therefore invoke the guarantee for minor hidden defects, even though he himself never concluded a contract with the contractor. This is particularly relevant in an apartment building, where units often change hands within the warranty period. Anyone buying an apartment where warranty periods are still running thus also acquires the associated rights of action — an element that receives little attention at the time of purchase but can represent considerable value.
Practical conclusion
Minor hidden defects offer you a valuable safety net after acceptance: a ten-year warranty, with a reasonable response period that only starts running when you could detect the defect. Keep the three categories — visible, minor hidden and stability — clearly apart, and do not hesitate to seek legal advice when a defect appears late, because you are often less late than you think. The broader framework can be found in our pillar on acceptance.
Finally, be mindful of the evidentiary aspect. Because this is a fault-based liability and the reasonable period is assessed contextually, it is wise to immediately document the situation when a defect appears: photographs, the date of detection and a technical analysis of the cause. That file supports both the proof of fault and the proof that you reacted in time. The better the observation is recorded, the stronger your position when the contractor or his insurer disputes the reasonableness of your response period or the hidden nature of the defect.
Is a defect appearing after acceptance and are you unsure whether you can still claim? Reius Advocaten assesses the nature of the defect, the applicable regime and the time limits. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.