Most people know the court-appointed administrator from the context of severely neglected, older apartment buildings where the financial or technical management has completely broken down. Less well known is that the same figure can also be useful in a brand-new building. When a new-build project gets bogged down in a conflict between buyers, developer and managing agent, appointing a court-appointed administrator can break the deadlock. This article explains when and how that can be done, and why it is sometimes the better choice.
What is a court-appointed administrator in co-ownership?
Since the most recent amendment to Belgian apartment ownership law, a court-appointed administrator (bewindvoerder) can be appointed to take over the management of an apartment building when its normal functioning breaks down. It is a far-reaching measure: the administrator steps into the place of — or alongside — the ordinary bodies to make the building manageable again.
Classically, this figure is considered in situations where the financial management is at risk or where technical progress is impossible, typically in older buildings with major renovation issues. The court-appointed administrator is then an instrument to pull a building that is in a downward spiral back on track.
Why also for a new-build?
The surprising insight is that the court-appointed administrator can equally serve in a brand-new building. In that case the trigger is not decay, but an explosive conflict surrounding the provisional acceptance and the initial functioning of the association of co-owners (VME).
A telling example is a case before the Justice of the Peace in Beringen (judgment of 30 October 2020). A couple had purchased an apartment in September 2017 under the Breyne Act; the VME had been established in February 2017. The couple was engaged in proceedings against the property developer over a problematic and late completion and over the accounts to be drawn up. At the general meeting of August 2020, the couple was not even invited, on the ground that they had not yet met all their obligations towards the developer — there was no notarial deed and no transfer of ownership. The ownership dispute was itself a consequence of the discussion about the provisional acceptance.
In that poisoned situation, a court-appointed administrator was appointed, without the parties opposing it. The reason was that both the developer and the managing agent were "burned": the developer had initially put himself forward as a candidate managing agent, which led to suspicions of conflicts of interest. A neutral, objective figure was needed to defuse the situation. That such developer-managing agent constructions lead to problems fits with what we discuss regarding the allocation of charges between the developer and the VME.
When is a court-appointed administrator appropriate?
The court-appointed administrator comes into view when the ordinary functioning of the VME can no longer proceed in an independent and credible manner. That is preeminently the case when the key figures — the developer and the managing agent — are no longer perceived as neutral, for instance due to conflicts of interest or deep division within the group.
In the Beringen case, many formalities were not even examined, because all parties involved — counsel for the VME and the co-owners themselves — agreed on the appointment. Ordinarily, a court-appointed administrator is appointed at the request of co-owners who together represent a certain share of the quotities, but where there is consensus about the need for a neutral third party, the threshold can in practice be lower. In other words, the instrument is above all useful to unblock an explosive or gridlocked situation.
The fact that the formalities weigh less heavily in such a consensus case does not mean that they are absent. If the appointment is contested, the applicant must demonstrate that the ordinary functioning of the VME is genuinely at risk and that appointing a court-appointed administrator is a proportionate response to the impasse. The judge assesses this in concreto, based on the factual state of the building and the credibility of the existing bodies. It is therefore not automatic: the court-appointed administrator is an exceptional instrument intended for situations where normal management demonstrably no longer functions, not for an ordinary disagreement between co-owners.
The alternative: a mediator?
One might also think of a mediator in such a collective conflict. In practice, however, mediators are rarely used in the context of a VME, and there is a reason for that. Mediation is generally seen as a person-to-person process, one on one. In an association of co-owners, however, you are dealing with an entire group, which brings particular points of attention to make the mediation legally valid and to safeguard the rights and opportunities of all involved.
It is precisely because of that group context that people often shy away from a mediator and instead turn to the figure of the court-appointed administrator. That said, mediation may still be conceivable in some cases as a less intrusive alternative, provided it is properly framed.
The court-appointed administrator alongside the managing agent
An important practical preference is that the court-appointed administrator — often a lawyer, but it can also be a professional managing agent — is best kept alongside the professional managing agent rather than fully replacing them. The court-appointed administrator then acts as a kind of "guardian angel" on the managing agent's shoulder, intervening when things really cannot move forward.
That model has one downside — you pay two figures, which increases the costs — but it keeps day-to-day management in the hands of the managing agent while the court-appointed administrator, with the distance and independence of a lawyer, can intervene at pivotal moments. For a lawyer, this is often a more suitable role than that of full replacement, precisely because they can attest to that complete objectivity and independence.
The choice between a court-appointed administrator who replaces and one who operates alongside the managing agent depends on the nature of the impasse. If the distrust is total and the managing agent no longer functions, a replacing or interim figure may be needed. If the management is still workable in itself but the neutral arbiter is missing to help the group over a point of conflict, the guardian angel formula often suffices. In both cases the aim is the same: to make the building capable of decisions again without the interests of an individual co-owner or of the minority being buried.
Practical conclusion
The court-appointed administrator is not only a remedy for neglected old buildings, but also an instrument to unblock a poisoned new-build VME, especially when the developer and the managing agent are no longer perceived as neutral. It works best when the court-appointed administrator operates alongside the managing agent rather than replacing them. The broader framework of the provisional acceptance and the initial functioning of the VME can be found in our pillar on acceptance.
Anyone considering requesting the appointment of a court-appointed administrator would do well to document the impasse as concretely as possible beforehand: which decisions are not being taken, what conflicts of interest are at play, and why the existing bodies can no longer act neutrally. That preparation not only strengthens the request, but also helps to realistically assess whether a court-appointed administrator really is the appropriate solution, or whether a less intrusive instrument will suffice. A specialised lawyer can help make that assessment and, if appropriate, guide the procedure.
Is your new-build VME stuck in a conflict with the developer or the managing agent? Reius Advocaten will assess whether appointing a court-appointed administrator offers a way out and will guide the procedure. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough on the facts. Considered in law.