Delivery is the pivotal moment in any new-build project. It is the moment at which the building site becomes a building: the contractor physically places the co-owners in possession of the completed works, risk transfers, and a series of legal mechanisms is triggered. Yet there is much uncertainty around this moment. Co-owners confuse provisional and final delivery, fear that a signature will forfeit their rights, and often do not know who is entitled to sign what. This guide clearly sets out the four delivery moments in an apartment building, with their legal consequences, pitfalls and the protection you enjoy as a buyer and as an Association of Co-owners (ACP).
What is delivery, from a legal standpoint?
The Civil Code barely defines delivery; in general construction law the term hardly appears expressly. It does appear in the Breyne Act. Legal doctrine describes delivery as the act by which the contractor makes the result of its work available to the principal, so that the latter has the opportunity to inspect it and, after approval, to take receipt.
A comparison with the delivery of a car clarifies matters. You go to the showroom, check whether the correct model and colour are there and whether there is no visible damage, and then take the keys. What you notice at that moment you raise; what emerges only later falls under the warranty. It works the same way for a building: delivery is the moment at which you declare you take receipt of the work, subject to what you observe.
That moment has three important consequences. The contractual phase between developer and buyers is concluded, risk over the building passes from the contractor to the principal, and the liability of the construction actors is thereafter approached from a different angle than during the construction process. It is also a fault line from an insurance perspective: the site cover (All-Site-Risks policy) ends and is replaced by the building's block policy.
Which regime applies: the Breyne Act or ordinary law?
Two regimes exist for delivery, and within one building they may coexist. That distinction determines which formal requirements and which protections apply.
The Breyne Act (the Housing Construction Act) is mandatorily applicable to agreements involving the obligation to build or complete a residential dwelling, where the buyer must make payments before completion (art. 1 Breyne Act). It applies to housing and to mixed use, and also to the transfer of ownership of an existing dwelling coupled with an order for renovation or extension works. This has a surprising consequence: in a building with commercial space on the ground floor, the trader is not buying a dwelling and therefore does not fall under the Breyne Act, whereas his neighbours above do. Within the same ACP, buyers may thus be attached to different legal bases. Excluded are, among others, social housing companies, municipalities and inter-municipal bodies (art. 2 Breyne Act).
Where the Breyne Act does not apply, ordinary construction law governs. There, delivery is not subject to formal requirements: there is no statutorily prescribed two-phase structure and acceptance may even be tacit. Precisely for that reason, a well-drafted construction agreement that formalises the delivery process is no luxury — often the "template" is even borrowed from the Breyne Act.
Because the Breyne Act is a mandatory protective regime, constructions are sometimes set up to escape it. The Court of Appeal of Liège (28 April 2016) struck down such a set-up: shell construction sold via the developer, finishing works via a separate construction agreement with the same contractor. The court held that both agreements formed a single transaction, aimed at having a dwelling built, so that the obligations of result under the Housing Construction Act did apply. Anyone wishing to know more about these circumvention techniques can read our spoke on circumvention constructions around the Breyne Act.
Four delivery moments, not two
Here lies the greatest misunderstanding. In an apartment building, delivery consists not of two but of four distinct acts: the provisional delivery of the private units, the provisional delivery of the common parts, the final delivery of the private units, and the final delivery of the common parts.
This distinction is no formality. Delivery of the private units is a matter for the individual owner; delivery of the common parts requires action by the entire ACP. Co-owners continually mix up these levels. A typical consequence: an owner experiencing a problem in his own unit — a missing cellar cupboard, an unfinished garden — blocks the final delivery of the common parts at the general assembly, in the belief that otherwise his private complaints will be lost. The two, however, are independent of one another.
Moreover, the Breyne Act imposes an order and a time frame (art. 9): the final delivery may not take place before one year after the provisional delivery, and the final delivery of the common parts must precede the final delivery of the private units, insofar as normal habitability is ensured. The one-year period is intended to let the building experience all seasons so that hidden construction defects can manifest themselves. In practice, that order for the common parts is often neglected, because the remaining retention balance is so small that the final delivery passes tacitly. The full elaboration of these four moments is set out in our spoke on the four delivery moments in an apartment building.
The legal consequences of provisional delivery
Provisional delivery is the real pivot point. Crucial to understand: it merely establishes the completion of the works, not their acceptance. The Court of Cassation has drawn this nuance sharply — provisional delivery has as its sole purpose and effect the establishment of the completion of the works and does not in itself constitute recognition of defects, even if these are visible. Completion and acceptance are two different things.
Nonetheless, important mechanisms are triggered. Under the Breyne Act, provisional delivery covers the nullities under the construction agreement (such as the nullity due to a defective description of the unit that the buyer could invoke upon sale off-plan). The first half of the retention and the completion guarantee are released. Under ordinary law, at that moment the performance period — and therefore delay penalties — ends and the warranty period starts. Risk transfers, with the associated insurance consequences.
A common fear among co-owners is that signing the minutes of provisional delivery deprives them of rights. The opposite is true: those minutes are a "photo finish" of the state of affairs at the moment of taking possession and constitute a valuable piece of evidence as well as a lever to have the recorded imperfections rectified. It takes nothing away from the right to challenge later defects that only manifest themselves afterwards.
Provisional delivery as a benchmark for charges
The provisional delivery of the common parts also determines from when the ACP bears the common charges. In a judgment of 2 September 2021, the Court of Cassation held that all costs relating to the common parts remain the responsibility of the promoter until the moment of provisional delivery of those parts. A contrary agreement in the deed of purchase may set an earlier moment, but never before the moment at which the common parts can be used in accordance with their intended purpose.
This judgment is a powerful lever against promoters who appoint themselves as the first syndic and pass site costs — gas, water, electricity consumed during construction — on to the ACP. The elaboration of this leverage judgment can be read in our spoke on the allocation of charges between promoter and ACP.
Who is entitled to sign the delivery document?
A persistent pitfall. For the common parts, no one may simply sign the delivery: this requires a special mandate from the ACP. A syndic or an individual co-owner who, without such a mandate, conducts the walk-through and signs, places himself and the others in a precarious position. If an owner signs on behalf of the group without a mandate, a representation problem arises and the other co-owners may turn against it.
A special rule applies to the promoter who is still owner of units: at the delivery of the common parts he does not exercise rights linked to the co-ownership and must abstain from voting on that matter (art. 3 Royal Decree Breyne Act). This is an autonomous provision, separate from a proxy's duty to abstain. When it concerns delivery, it is therefore best to refer expressly to the Royal Decree under the Breyne Act.
Incidents: refused delivery and abuse of rights
Conflicts often arise around delivery. The promoter may not refuse provisional delivery for merely minor or trivial shortcomings; only where the works are truly unfinished is postponement justified. Conversely, the promoter may not misuse delivery as a means of pressure. The court of Antwerp (11 June 2019) qualified as abuse of rights the conduct of a promoter who withheld the keys as long as he had not been paid for disputed additional works — he abused his dominant position vis-à-vis a buyer under pressure to move quickly into his apartment. The contractor was ordered to hand over the keys.
Where the parties cannot reach agreement, the court can confirm the delivery. It is also not contrary to correct performance to refuse provisional delivery until an expert report brings clarity on the reported defects (see Court of First Instance West Flanders, Bruges division). A final delivery may be refused as long as the defects noted at the provisional delivery have not been remedied.
What after acceptance? Your remedies
Delivery does not close the door. Even after acceptance, you retain rights. For minor hidden defects — defects not visible at delivery — a ten-year warranty period applies, and the claim must be brought within a reasonable time from the moment the defect is or could be established. This is contractual liability, not of public order, but the period may not be artificially shortened and the right to challenge hidden defects may not be entirely excluded. An exoneration clause limiting liability to one year after provisional delivery is therefore null and void — as our spoke on the exoneration clause of the building promoter shows.
For serious, stability-threatening defects, the ten-year liability of art. 1792 CC applies. This is of public order: no contractual modulation, no shortening, no suspension. Issue and serve the writ within the ten years — a mere appointment of an expert or an insurance declaration does not suffice to preserve the term. Increasingly, water infiltration affecting the health of the building is also accepted under this regime.
A final, important point: both the ACP and the individual co-owner may sue the construction actors for defects in the common parts — the ACP for the whole, the individual owner up to his share. How that procedural capacity is precisely divided and what you can do in the case of an inactive ACP is dealt with in separate spokes.
Practical conclusion
Delivery is not a moment to fear, but to prepare thoroughly. Understand the four moments, know which regime applies to your purchase, sign nothing on behalf of the community without a mandate, and seek technical advice before any legal step — to measure is to know. A strong construction file, built up from the provisional delivery onwards, is your best protection.
Are you facing the delivery of a new-build apartment, or is your ACP encountering a promoter who obstructs delivery or passes on site costs? Reius Advocaten assists both individual buyers and Associations of Co-owners throughout the delivery process and the subsequent liability claims. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.