Anyone buying a new-build apartment will sooner or later hear the word "acceptance" (oplevering) — usually for the first time at the very first general meeting of the association of co-owners (VME). Many buyers think it involves a single moment, or at most two: a provisional and a final acceptance. In an apartment building, that is incorrect. There are four distinct acceptance operations, and anyone who confuses them often blocks the entire file. This article explains which four moments exist, in what order they must take place, and why that distinction protects rather than threatens you.
Two types of parts, two phases each
Acceptance breaks down along two axes. On the one hand, the distinction between the private parts (your own unit) and the common parts (the corridors, roof, façade, entrance hall). On the other hand, the distinction between provisional acceptance (a finding that the works are completed) and final acceptance (the actual approval).
Together, these two axes yield four operations: the provisional acceptance of the private parts, the provisional acceptance of the common parts, the final acceptance of the private parts, and the final acceptance of the common parts. Experience shows that even seasoned co-owners constantly confuse these levels.
The difference is not merely academic. Acceptance of your private unit is your own affair: you sign as an individual owner. Acceptance of the common parts, by contrast, requires action by the entire VME, and no one may sign it without a specific mandate from the general meeting.
Why the order is fixed by law
Under the Breyne Act (the Belgian Housing Construction Act), the order is not a matter of choice. Article 9 provides that final acceptance of the works may not take place earlier than one year after provisional acceptance. That one-year period serves a purpose: the building must go through all four seasons, so that any construction defects — damp, cracking, insulation issues — can manifest themselves before the work is definitively approved.
In addition, article 9 provides that the final acceptance of the common parts, including access routes, must precede the final acceptance of the private parts, provided that normal habitability is ensured. The logic is that the common infrastructure — through which everyone reaches their apartment — must be in order first.
In practice, that order for the common parts is often neglected. The remaining balance of the guarantee that is released by the final acceptance of the common parts is usually so small that this step passes tacitly, while the developer does everything possible to formalise the final acceptance of the private parts. A court in Brussels pointed out that the statutory order is prescribed only for final acceptance; for provisional acceptance, the Breyne Act does not expressly impose that order, which also makes practical sense because finishing works on the common parts sometimes cause damage to already accepted private units.
The classic pitfall: throwing everything on one pile
This is where the biggest problem arises. An individual co-owner who is missing something in their own unit — a promised cellar cupboard that is not there, a garden that was not laid out — tends to want to handle the entire acceptance, private and common, in a single procedural move. At the general meeting, they then block the final acceptance of the common parts, in the belief that otherwise they will forfeit their private complaints.
That is a misunderstanding. Acceptance of your private unit and acceptance of the common parts are separate matters. By holding up the acceptance of the common parts, such an owner takes the entire group hostage without strengthening their own position. Sometimes that blockade is deliberately used as leverage, but legally it is rarely tenable and often counterproductive.
The opposite reflex also occurs: owners who hold up every acceptance out of fear of hidden or stability defects, thus completely paralysing the file. Yet it is precisely by pursuing the acceptances that one can take up the correct legal position, because they record the visible situation and set the time limits running.
Provisional acceptance: completion, not approval
The key insight is that provisional acceptance merely establishes that the works are completed — not that they are accepted. The Belgian Court of Cassation has made this clear: provisional acceptance has as its sole aim and effect the recording of completion and does not in itself imply recognition of defects, even visible ones. Completion and delivery are two different things; one can even record completion and postpone delivery.
Precisely for that reason, signing the minutes of provisional acceptance is not a risk but a protection. The minutes are a snapshot of the situation at the time of occupancy and serve both as evidence and as leverage to enforce the noted defects. Provisional acceptance also starts the guarantee period, ends the performance period (and therefore the delay penalties) and transfers the risk to the building owner. A more in-depth overview of those legal effects can be found in our pillar on the acceptance of a new-build apartment.
Watch out for tacit acceptance
Under ordinary construction law — that is, outside the Breyne Act — acceptance is not subject to any formal requirements. That sounds flexible, but it contains a trap: acceptance can also take place tacitly, without any formal minutes ever being signed. Case law infers such tacit acceptance from various acts: full and unreserved payment of the contract price or the final settlement, occupation or use of the works without reservation, or unreserved release of the guarantee.
The practical lesson is that you should never pay, move in or release the guarantee without reservation as long as there are visible defects. Anyone who does so risks being deemed to have accepted the work — with all the consequences that has for later complaints. Always formulate your reservations in writing when performing any act that could be construed as acceptance.
Under ordinary law, there is moreover no statutory two-phase structure. Nevertheless, we recommend contractually providing for a provisional and a final acceptance there as well, with a year in between — the same seasonal logic applies. A well-drafted construction contract that lays down the method of acceptance prevents many later disputes about whether and when the work was accepted.
Who signs, and the role of the architect
For the common parts, only someone with a specific mandate from the VME may sign the acceptance document. A syndic or co-owner who conducts the walk-through and signs without a mandate puts the entire group in an uncertain position. Beware also of tacit acceptance: unreserved occupation or payment may, under ordinary law, count as acceptance.
A specific point of attention is the role of the architect during the walk-through. It seems logical that the building's architect should assist the VME in the acceptance of the common parts, but this is a delicate situation: the architect bears responsibility for their own design and their supervisory duty during the works. One may wonder whether they can advise the VME sufficiently independently on whether or not to accept the building. An independent technical adviser is therefore often the better choice.
Acceptance with reservations: what do you record?
During the walk-through, you draw up a list of defects — an acceptance with reservations. Those remarks can be of various kinds. You may find that there has been a deviation from the plans and specifications. Here a particularity comes into play: until provisional acceptance, the original parties could, in specific circumstances, still make small "as built" changes to the plans and even to the statutes, but that possibility disappears at the time of provisional acceptance. Deviations that you note at that moment should therefore be expressly recorded in the minutes.
You can also note defects in the construction, materials or finishing. What constitutes a "defect" sometimes gives rise to debate. If natural stone was promised in the specifications and the contractor installs a ceramic tile "with the look of natural stone," that is a defect for the resident, even if the contractor argues that the alternative is easier to maintain. Such deviations from what was promised should be recorded in the minutes, so that they remain a subject of discussion before final acceptance.
The intention is that these minutes be worked through point by point before final acceptance takes place. Final acceptance can be refused as long as the defects noted at the provisional acceptance have not been remedied. New defects that only manifest themselves between the provisional and final acceptance do not fall under that initial, visible list, but may fall under the guarantee for hidden or stability defects.
Practical conclusion
Remember the four moments and keep them apart: private and common, provisional and final. Do not sign anything on behalf of the community without a mandate, and preferably have yourself assisted at the acceptance of the common parts by an independent technical expert rather than by the building's architect. That way, acceptance becomes an instrument in your favour rather than a source of blockages. The broader framework can be found in our pillar on acceptance.
Are you facing the acceptance of your apartment or of the common parts, and do you want to know which signature has which consequence? Reius Advocaten guides buyers and VMEs through the four acceptance milestones. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.