When renovating or demolishing buildings dating from before 2001, asbestos is the rule rather than the exception. For the contractor, this creates layered liability: environmental criminal liability towards the authorities, labour-law liability towards employees, and contractual liability towards the client. Anyone commissioning demolition or removal works would do well to understand how these three tracks interlock — and precisely where the risks lie.
Self-removal or specialised firm: what VLAREM II allows
The basic rules are set out in VLAREM II (article 4.7.0.1). Not every asbestos application must be removed by a licensed firm. Under strict conditions, a private individual may personally remove certain bonded, undamaged applications — asbestos cement panels, corrugated sheets, floor tiles — provided no free fibres are visible (§2). The decree attaches clear safety requirements to this (§3): moistening or fixing the material, working manually and carefully, not breaking or throwing, disposing in sealed packaging, keeping minors away, and personal protection with at least a P3-type dust mask. Working asbestos with tools that release fibres is expressly prohibited: high-pressure cleaners and sanders may not be used.
High-risk and non-bonded applications — sprayed asbestos, certain insulation, damaged material with loose fibres — fall outside this exception. These may only be removed by a licensed, specialised undertaking. Moreover, the lenient "do-it-yourself" regime never applies to a professional contractor: he is expected to use the best available technique and to carry out the works properly and safely.
Demolition: destructive inventory and demolition monitoring plan
Demolition adds a second layer of obligations. In addition to the non-destructive asbestos inventory, a destructive asbestos inventory often has to be drawn up, mapping hidden asbestos and the other waste streams before the first stone is removed. For substantial demolition projects, a demolition monitoring plan is also mandatory (VLAREMA, article 4.3.3). The thresholds: full or partial demolition of an infrastructure work exceeding 250 m³, a residential building exceeding 5,000 m³ or a non-residential building exceeding 1,000 m³.
During the works, there is a duty to demolish selectively: hazardous waste such as asbestos-containing material is collected separately, rather than piled together indiscriminately. For monitoring, there is a licensed demolition management organisation — in Flanders, this is Tracimat. A demolition contractor who joins the scheme has the demolition certified, reducing the risk of disputes and additional costs afterwards. The fact that selective demolition increases the cost makes clear prior agreements all the more important.
Negligent demolition: prosecution of both company and manager
Anyone disregarding these rules enters the realm of environmental criminal law. The criminal case law is strict and expects a deterrent effect from the penalties imposed. In one case, a contractor who had worked negligently was criminally convicted, with both the legal person and the natural person involved being sanctioned (Corr. Ghent 22 April 2008). This cumulation of company and manager is not an isolated event. In a more recent case, in which the mandatory hermetic zone had not been applied when removing an asbestos-containing vinyl floor, the charges were likewise declared proven (Corr. East Flanders, Ghent division, 21 January 2020). Hiding behind the company therefore offers the actual operator no guarantee.
The employer remains responsible, even with an external contractor
On the shop floor, the Code on Well-being at Work also applies. An employer must draw up an asbestos inventory, carry out a risk analysis, in certain cases prepare a management programme, and inform its employees. A common misunderstanding is that this obligation disappears once a specialised firm is engaged. The Court of Cassation has confirmed that the employer's obligation regarding the asbestos inventory continues to exist, including where the employer engages an external contractor for the actual works (Cass. 25 November 2019). You outsource execution, not your responsibility.
Who bears the risk of "unforeseen" asbestos?
Contractually, the question arises whether asbestos is an unforeseeable circumstance justifying a price revision. The answer depends on what the contractor knew or could have known. Anyone who was aware of asbestos — for example because a prior report recommended further investigation — and nevertheless quoted a fixed price, assumes that risk and can no longer invoke unforeseeability afterwards (Liège 19 March 2019, referring to the unforeseeability rules of the general specifications). A professional is furthermore expected to know his duties of care and, in the case of older buildings, to take the possible presence of asbestos into account.
Even a contractor who has taken on a contractual obligation of result is not entirely without an exit: on the basis of articles 1147-1148 of the Civil Code, he can escape that obligation by demonstrating an external cause or force majeure — even the fault of a third party or the injured party himself. But the burden of proof is heavy, and mere "it turned out worse than expected" does not suffice.
A professional contractor is not a professional seller
An important nuance: a professional contractor is not automatically treated as a professional seller. There is no principled rule that, like the professional seller, he is deemed to be aware of every hidden defect (Cass. 5 December 2002). Yet that reassurance is relative. Lower case law nevertheless imposes an aggravated liability on the professional contractor: he can only exonerate himself by proving the undetectable nature of the defect, and he bears that burden himself (Liège 11 June 2007). Whether he succeeds depends heavily on the nature of the assignment and on whether it involves an obligation of result or an obligation of means. If, on the other hand, the contractor himself acts as the seller of what he built, the assessment shifts again: how the case law treats the contractor or self-builder as seller is discussed in a separate contribution.
Contaminated material and the qualitative claim
A particular scenario is that of material contaminated with asbestos — think of blasting grit that turned out to contain asbestos fibres. If such contamination is detected and the works come to a standstill, the question is who bears the loss: the contractor who used the material, or the supplier or producer of it? The contractor who is sued can defend himself under articles 1147-1148 of the Civil Code by demonstrating a non-attributable external cause. Importantly for the client, the duty to indemnify passes with the goods: as a qualitative claim, he can directly sue the supplier of the defective material (Cass. 18 May 2006). The loss therefore does not necessarily remain with the last link in the chain.
Address asbestos expressly in the specifications
The common thread is that almost every asbestos dispute in construction contracts traces back to what was — or precisely was not — agreed in advance. If works begin without anything being put on paper about asbestos, discussion inevitably follows as to whether the problem was already covered by the original quote and whether the contractor should have foreseen it. What is foreseeable and what is not can be modulated contractually. Therefore, expressly include asbestos in the specifications: set out who carries out which preliminary investigation, how any findings are dealt with, and who bears the additional cost. In this way you avoid a halted worksite and a disrupted schedule. If, in all this, the contractor spreads asbestos to adjoining plots, nuisance between neighbours also comes into play — you can read more about this in asbestos and neighbour nuisance. How this contractor liability fits into the full asbestos file can be found in our guide on asbestos in real estate.
How Reius Advocaten can assist you
Do you have a concrete file as a client or contractor in which asbestos plays a role? Reius Advocaten guides you in assessing your rights and obligations, reviews your specifications and contractual arrangements, and represents you where necessary in proceedings, even where the works are already at a standstill. Feel free to get in touch via info@reius.be or the contact form.