The Breyne Act — the Housing Construction Act of 9 July 1971 — is a mandatory protective regime. It arose after buyers who paid in instalments for a home yet to be built lost their money when the builder went bankrupt and were left with an unfinished building. Since then, the Act imposes stringent obligations on anyone selling homes off-plan: mandatory contractual particulars, a guarantee scheme, and a two-stage acceptance procedure. Precisely because that protection is strict, some construction professionals try to escape it. This article sets out the best-known avoidance structures and why they rarely hold up in court.
Why parties try to escape the Breyne Act
The Breyne Act imposes obligations on the seller-builder that he would rather do without. The contract must contain a whole series of mandatory particulars (art. 7), on pain of nullity. A guarantee scheme of five per cent plus a completion guarantee applies. Acceptance must take place in two stages, with at least one year between the provisional and the final acceptance. And the developer's ten-year liability cannot be shortened (art. 6).
For the buyer these are valuable safeguards; for the seller a straitjacket. That is why, in practice, there is a recurring temptation to structure the transaction so that it formally appears to fall outside the scope of the Breyne Act. However, the Act is of mandatory law, and case law looks through the structure to the true nature of the transaction.
Structure 1: splitting the transaction into two agreements
The classic avoidance structure consists of splitting the purchase into two separate agreements: a sale agreement for the shell with the developer, and a separate construction agreement for the finishings, directly between the buyer and the contractor. By "defragmenting" the transaction in this way, parties hope to escape the strict regime of the Housing Construction Act.
The Liège Court of Appeal was confronted with such a set-up (judgment of 28 April 2016). The same contractor carried out both the shell (invoiced to the developer) and the finishings (invoiced to the buyer), with an internal agreement determining the allocation. The court held that both agreements in reality constituted a single transaction, aimed at having a home built for residential use. Consequently, the obligations of result under the Housing Construction Act did apply, and the contractor and the developer were held jointly and severally (in solidum) liable for the defects in the building.
The lesson is clear: splitting the contracts changes nothing about the economic reality. Where the whole is aimed at building a home, the Breyne Act applies, and the in solidum liability that follows cannot be contracted away.
Structure 2: letting buyers contract individually
A second variant apparently shifts the initiative to the buyers themselves. Each individual buyer is asked to conclude a separate construction agreement with the contractor, as if each of them personally takes the initiative to engage a contractor, while in reality a project coordinator directs everything.
This too is an attempt to escape the strict Breyne Act. The reasoning applied by case law is the same as for the first structure: as soon as a coordinating supervision drives the whole and the intention is to jointly produce homes, the courts look through the formal split. The separate contracts together form a single construction project for residential use.
Structure 3: having the co-owners' association act as principal
A third, more sophisticated technique tries to have the co-ownership itself act as principal — for example in the redevelopment of a building to be renovated. The idea is that the co-owners' association (VME/ACP) has the works carried out, so that the relationship is not characterised as an off-plan sale under the Breyne Act.
However, that does not align with the nature of the co-owners' association. Its sole purpose is the management of the building, not its construction. A structure in which the association acts as builder therefore conflicts with the principle of speciality that delimits its powers. The circumvention fails because the association cannot legally fulfil the role that parties wish to assign to it.
The renovation clause as a circumvention technique
A final manifestation is the renovation clause. Here the buyers contractually undertake to carry out certain renovation or finishing works, so that the transaction is not presented as the purchase of a home to be built under the Breyne Act. Case law qualifies such a clause as a technique to circumvent the Housing Construction Act. If, moreover, the buyers' renovation undertaking is not determined or determinable, nullity also threatens on the ground of an invalid subject-matter.
What protection applies once the Breyne Act is applicable?
When the court looks through the structure and declares the Breyne Act applicable, the buyer regains the full package of protection. That is precisely what the avoidance structure sought to prevent, and it is substantial.
First, the nullity sanction of article 7 revives. The agreement must contain a series of mandatory particulars — a precise description of the private and common parts, the plans, the authentic base deed and the by-laws of co-ownership, the financing and the delivery deadlines. A single infringement of article 7 suffices to nullify the entire agreement, a nullity that the buyer can invoke up until the passing of the notarial deed. A mere draft base deed does not suffice; it must be a copy of the base deed drawn up in authentic form.
Second, the mandatory two-stage acceptance with at least one year between them (art. 9) applies, together with the guarantee scheme with release in two halves. Third, the ten-year liability cannot be shortened (art. 6). An exoneration clause purporting to limit liability for hidden defects to one year after provisional acceptance is therefore null and void.
A further point gaining importance in case law is that the status of consumer remains attached to the individual co-owner who bought as a consumer, even where the common interests are represented through the legal personality of the co-owners' association. A seller cannot, therefore, evade consumer protection by hiding behind the fact that the association formally is an undertaking with a company number.
Practical conclusion
The message for anyone buying an apartment or home off-plan: do not be misled by a formal split of the contracts. The court looks at the true nature of the transaction, and where the whole is aimed at building a home for residential use, the mandatory protection of the Breyne Act applies — including the two-stage acceptance and the guarantee scheme. For details on how that acceptance procedure works, see our pillar on the acceptance of a new-build apartment.
Do you have doubts as to whether your purchase falls under the Breyne Act, or is the seller proposing a structure with split contracts? Reius Advocaten assesses the true nature of your agreement and your protection as a buyer. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.