The contractor no longer shows up. Or he does show up, but delivers poor work. Or communication has completely broken down and you want just one thing: to end this cooperation. At first glance, that seems simple — you say "it's over", you look for another contractor, and you subsequently claim back what you overpaid.
In reality, it rarely goes so smoothly. Belgian contract law recognises several ways to end a construction contract, and the consequences differ fundamentally. Termination is not the same as rescission. Extrajudicial rescission by notification is not the same as judicial rescission. And extrajudicial replacement of a subcontractor has its own conditions. Anyone who chooses the wrong route, or who fails to execute it correctly, may end up being presented with the bill for the fallout themselves.
The difference between termination, cancellation and rescission
Three concepts, three completely different legal realities.
Termination (Article 1794 old Civil Code for construction contracts) is the unilateral right of the client to end the cooperation without fault on the part of the contractor. It operates for the future, not retroactively. The contractor is compensated for what he has already done and for what he loses.
Rescission (Article 5.90 Civil Code) is a response to a breach of contract by the other party. It operates retroactively: the contract is deemed never to have existed, with mutual restitution of performances. The party rescinding due to the breach can also claim damages.
The term cancellation is a Flemish synonym for termination. French-language case law refers to "résiliation unilatérale" or simply "résiliation". Legally the same reality as termination.
The Brussels Court of Appeal refined the relationship between the two on 15 December 2022 (T.Aann. 2024, issue 2, 166). The first-instance judge had ruled that a claim for rescission was without object, because the contract had already been terminated. The Court corrected this: nothing prevented the rescission of the contract prior to the date of termination. Moreover, no element indicated that the parties requesting rescission had waived their right to invoke that rescission. Rescission and termination concern two different mechanisms — termination unilaterally ends the contract on a specific date, whereas rescission enables the contract to be ended with retroactive effect.
Unilateral termination under Article 1794 old Civil Code
Article 1794 old Civil Code provides that the client can unilaterally terminate a construction contract, even without fault on the part of the contractor. The contractor is then entitled to compensation for his expenses, his losses, his performances already delivered and — unless usage dictates otherwise — his lost profit. The same logic is adopted in Article 7.4.32 of the draft Book 7 of the Civil Code.
The Explanatory Memorandum to Book 7 clarifies that the existing principles for assessing lost profit remain unaffected. "The starting point for assessing compensation for lost profit is that the interests of the client and the contractor must be balanced. Account must be taken, among other things, of the costs saved by the contractor and the possibility for the contractor to enter into contracts with third parties as a result of the termination." In a favourable economic climate in which the contractor can easily find replacement contracts, the lost-profit compensation therefore shrinks accordingly.
The Antwerp Court of Appeal ruled on 27 June 2023 (NjW 2024, issue 509, 831) that a contractually agreed termination fee is not a penalty clause. It is not reviewable under Article VI.83, 17° and 24° of the Code of Economic Law and not subject to mitigation. For clients, this means: an agreement in the contract on a lump-sum termination fee must be taken seriously — the judge will not simply set it aside because it turns out to be high.
Termination is in principle not subject to any formal requirements, unless the parties agree otherwise. The only requirement is that the other party is unambiguously notified of the will to end the contract. In the absence of contractual formal requirements, termination can therefore be inferred from conduct and statements of the terminating party. Our advice remains: in writing, by registered post, with a clear date and reasoning.
Rescission for breach (Article 5.90 Civil Code)
Rescission comes into play when there is a sufficiently serious non-performance by the contractor, or when the parties have contractually agreed that a specific shortcoming justifies rescission. Article 5.90 Civil Code provides three routes to rescission: judicial, on the basis of an express rescission clause, or by notification from the creditor to the debtor.
Case law ensures that termination and rescission do not become confused. The Court of First Instance of Hainaut, Tournai Division, ruled on 16 January 2023 (TBBR 2024, issue 4, 174) that refusing access to the construction site or sending the contractor's staff away can, under certain circumstances, be regarded as an expression of the client's will to terminate the construction contract within the meaning of Article 1794 old Civil Code — but this must be proven. In the case before the court, that proof was not delivered. The contractor had, however, failed to perform the construction contract despite an express request from the client; this constituted a sufficiently serious shortcoming to justify rescission to the contractor's detriment.
An important consequence of rescission: because it has retroactive effect, the contractor is obliged to return the advance received to the client. However, interest only runs from the date of the judgment pronouncing rescission. For a contractor who himself wishes to obtain restitution for performances rendered, he must prove the amount of those performances and the resulting enrichment of the client.
Extrajudicial rescission by notification
Since the reform of Book 5 of the Civil Code, the creditor can rescind the contract himself without first going to court. Article 5.93 Civil Code provides that the creditor, after taking useful measures to establish the non-performance, can rescind the contract at his own risk by means of a written notification to the debtor. That notification specifies the shortcomings.
It is a "heavy-handed remedy" — powerful but risky. Article 5.94 Civil Code provides that the notification is ineffective when the requirements for rescission are not met or when the rescission is abusive. Anyone who rescinds too quickly, or who cannot prove the breach, may themselves be in breach of contract and liable for damages to the other party.
Concrete requirements: a clear notification that describes the breach precisely, together with the reasoning as to why that breach justifies rescission. A registered letter is a practical recommendation. Prudent clients have the notification prepared by a lawyer: the shortcomings must be precisely listed, and the notification must be substantively sound in the event the contractor takes the matter to court.
Extrajudicial replacement of a subcontractor
If you work with a main contractor who himself deploys subcontractors, a similar problem sometimes arises on a different axis: the main contractor wants to get rid of a failing subcontractor and appoint another himself, passing on the additional cost. This is extrajudicial replacement, a specific variant within the broader framework of rescission for breach.
The Ghent Court of Appeal considered such a case on 16 February 2022 (TBO 2022, issue 6, 358) and ruled that the conditions for extrajudicial replacement had been met. The main contractor had asked the subcontractor several times to do what was necessary, which he did not: this inert and negligent attitude on the part of the subcontractor made the matter sufficiently urgent. The subcontractor had never disputed the shortcomings alleged. The subcontractor's interventions were inadequate. Swift and decisive action by the main contractor was called for. The initiative also fitted within the duty to mitigate damages.
But one judgment sounds a warning: the announcement must be crystal clear. The Antwerp Court of Appeal on 14 February 2022 (Limb.Rechtsl. 2022, issue 4, 291) dismissed a counterclaim by a main contractor against his subcontractor because the main contractor had only stated in his registered letter that "the cooperation is being terminated". He had not expressly notified the subcontractor of his decision to replace. Result: he could not recover the additional cost of the replacement contractor from the original subcontractor. The message for practice: say what you are doing. A notice of default must not only state that the work is substandard, but also expressly announce the intention of extrajudicial replacement if no improvement occurs within a reasonable period.
What if the works have become impracticable?
Sometimes the situation changes so drastically during the works that performance seems impossible — a permit that is annulled, ground conditions that turn out differently than anticipated. The client may then look for grounds to unilaterally end the contract without fault.
The Brussels Court of Appeal tempered such attempts on 3 June 2022 (JLMB 2023, issue 32, 1424). A client invoked force majeure and lapse due to disappearance of the subject matter. The Court accepted neither. Force majeure requires an impossibility of performance not attributable to the debtor. In the case before the Court, the construction project was not doomed to failure, given the repeated adaptations by the authorities. For lapse due to disappearance of the subject matter, the actual subject matter must have disappeared — the parties had, by mutual agreement, replaced the original programme with a new construction programme, so the redefined subject matter had not disappeared. When the client, in those circumstances, decided to abandon the project, the situation could not be interpreted otherwise than as a unilateral cancellation by the client, with a right for the contractor to compensation under Article 1794 old Civil Code.
The lesson: practical difficulties are rarely force majeure. Anyone wishing to call off a complex project usually falls back on termination — and therefore pays the corresponding compensation.
Practical step-by-step plan for ending a contract
A considered route to "showing your contractor the door":
First step — written notice of default. Preferably by registered post. Describe the breach precisely (which agreements were not observed, which defects were established, which documents can support you). Give a concrete deadline for remedy.
Second step — protective evidence. Photographs, bailiff findings, technical reports, witness statements from professionals. In case of disputed or complex defects: an adversarial expert examination before you end the contract.
Third step — choice of legal route. Termination is more expensive but less risky in terms of proof. Rescission may yield damages but requires proof of serious breach. Extrajudicial rescission by notification is fast but can boomerang if incorrectly applied.
Fourth step — written notification of the chosen route, mentioning all relevant dates and facts. This can simultaneously include the announcement of an extrajudicial replacement if a subcontractor is involved.
Reius Advocaten assists both private individuals and businesses at every stage of a termination file — from the first notice of default to substantive proceedings. A wrong step in this matter is often more expensive than the works themselves. Contact us at info@reius.be for an initial analysis.
Want to know your full position as a client? Read our guide on the rights and obligations of the client.