You built or renovated, and it later turns out that the works were not covered by a valid planning permit. The permit had expired, had been annulled, or the execution deviated from it. An unpleasant finding. An even more unpleasant question: can you still hold your contractor or architect liable under the contract, or is everything that was agreed legally non-existent? Belgian case law offers a nuanced answer — with major practical consequences.
Many building owners face a double shock at that moment: an administrative sanction (restoration, regularisation or demolition) and a private-law file in which the question of fault suddenly becomes crucial. Who knew what? Who should have warned? And how far does the liability extend of the architect who drew up the plans or the contractor who carried them out? In this article you will read how the Courts of Appeal of Brussels and Antwerp have recently answered these questions, and what steps you can take yourself to protect your position.
No automatic nullity
The basic principle: a construction or architect's contract is not automatically void when the works have been carried out without or contrary to a permit. The Court of Appeal of Brussels ruled on 25 January 2024 (Brussels 2nd ch. F, JLMB 2024, issue 42, 1903) on a case in which houses had been built after the planning permit had lapsed or contrary to the permit issued. The court rejected the argument of automatic nullity and set out the following principle: the contracts are not void if the illegality committed dates from after the conclusion of the contract and is unrelated to its subject matter.
The reasoning: the architect's contract itself had a lawful subject — the drawing up of plans and/or supervision of the works. That the performance subsequently became unlawful does not affect the validity of the contract itself, unless the parties intended to circumvent the statutory architectural supervision obligation. A person in an unlawful situation who claims damages is not necessarily pursuing the protection of an unlawful interest. The interest in bringing an action is only unlawful when the claim seeks to maintain an unlawful situation.
For you as building owner, this means: even in the event of permit problems, you can still hold your contractor or architect liable in contract for non-performance, defective performance or breach of the duty to inform. The permit issue plays out on a different legal level.
The architect and the demolition: a heavy responsibility
Another case shows how far-reaching the liability can be. The Court of Appeal of Antwerp ruled on 6 June 2023 (Antwerp B2E2nd ch. no. 2022/AR/272, Limb.Rechtsl. 2023, issue 4, 327) on a building project that had initially started under a valid permit, but the permit was later annulled. The building had to be demolished — a hefty cost.
The architect was held liable on the basis of a breach of his pre-contractual duty to inform (articles V.2 and VI.64 of the Code of Economic Law). He had insufficiently informed the building owner about the main characteristics of his service — including which tasks were his, what the relationship was between his tasks and those of the contractor, and how site supervision was arranged. Because of this failure, there was no clarity as to who had to warn the building owner and when.
The court ruled that the failure to comply with the duty to inform constituted fault within the meaning of article 1382 of the old Civil Code, in causal connection with the damage — namely the demolition cost. The reasoning: had the architect complied with his duty to inform, he would have been more involved from the outset, he would have warned about the risk of starting the works before the expiry of the appeal period, and the damage would not have occurred or would have been less.
For the building owner, this is an important ruling: an architect who fails in his duty to inform about his own tasks can be held liable for the demolition cost — even though the direct cause of the demolition lies in the annulment of a permit over which he had no control.
The limits: expert investigation and subsidiarity
Not every permit problem automatically leads to a successful claim. The Court of First Instance of Brussels (Brussels Dutch-speaking Court no. 2021/1294/1, 26 July 2021, T.App. 2023, issue 3, 23) ruled on a building owner who had had a duplex apartment converted into a triplex. Instead of a staircase, he chose a lift. Afterwards, the fire brigade indicated that the installation was not in accordance with the environmental permit. The building owner summoned the developer, the architect and the installer and requested the appointment of a court expert.
The court dismissed the application on the basis of the principle of subsidiarity: the applicant did not provide any prima facie evidence of his claim. A court expert is not intended to make up for a failing burden of proof. The building owner could therefore not try to obtain information "via" an expert that he should have gathered himself first.
The practical lesson: a claim for permit problems requires a minimum of your own documentation — site correspondence, e-mails with the architect about the planning situation, photos, findings by the authorities, fire brigade advice — before you may ask a court to appoint an expert. A mere suspicion of irregularity is not sufficient.
Mistake and fraud as alternatives
In addition to the duty to inform and non-performance, Belgian law offers two further angles for permit problems: mistake (article 5.33 Civil Code) and fraud (article 5.36 Civil Code). Where the contractor or architect deliberately gave you incorrect information about the validity of the permit, or where you were essentially mistaken about the lawfulness of the project, this may lead to nullity of the contract with restitution of what has already been performed.
Article 5.33 of the Civil Code requires the mistake to concern an element of the contract that was decisive for the party and that the other party was or should have been aware of. In the case of architects and contractors, who are professionals in the field of planning law, this "should have known" test is set relatively low.
For the difference between contractual liability and the action for annulment, and for the broader context of your rights, see the pillar on rights and obligations of the building owner in construction contracts.
And what if the permit did exist, but the contractor deviated from it?
Another situation: the permit is valid, but the contractor deviates from what it states. A storey height that does not match, a window in a different location, an extension that has not been permitted. In this scenario, the construction contract itself is not at issue — the contractor is breaching his contractual obligation to carry out the works in accordance with the plans and the permit.
The contractor's duty to warn arises here in a twofold manner: he must warn the building owner when he sees that an execution choice deviates from the permit, and he must himself refuse to work contrary to the permit without an express written instruction. For more on the duty to warn, see the spoke on the contractor who failed to warn.
What do you do in practice?
Where you are faced with a permit problem that threatens to lead to restoration, regularisation or demolition, some basic principles apply.
Gather your file: all correspondence with contractor and architect, the permit file, the opinions of advisory bodies, the site meeting minutes, the official notifications from the authorities. Request an independent assessment: a second architect or a lawyer can assess the legal position of your contractor and architect on the basis of their duty to inform and their supervisory duty. Instruct a lawyer in good time: claims for breach of the duty to inform or non-performance are time-barred within ten years of the fault (article 2262bis Civil Code), but claims for annulment of the contract may be subject to shorter periods. Investigate all liability insurance policies: both architect and contractor have compulsory professional liability insurance, and this insurance can in most cases be addressed directly — even in the event of bankruptcy of the architect or contractor.
Reius Advocaten assists individuals and businesses in permit disputes combined with construction files. The combination of administrative law (permit) and private law (construction) requires an integrated approach. Contact us at info@reius.be for an initial assessment of your file.