A subcontractor performs work on a construction project for months. The main contractor invoices the client and gets paid. But the subcontractor? He watches his invoices remain outstanding, receives empty promises, and eventually phone calls go unanswered. The main contractor slides into payment difficulties, sometimes even bankruptcy. The subcontractor is left empty-handed — while having already paid the wages of his own employees.
Against this classic scenario, Belgian law has developed a powerful weapon: the direct action based on Article 1798 of the old Civil Code. A statutory security that allows the subcontractor to approach the client (project owner) directly for the services he has performed on the latter's behalf. Since a Constitutional Court ruling in 2021, this can even be done extrajudicially — via a registered letter, without a writ of summons. But timing is crucial, as the bankruptcy of the main contractor can suddenly close this gate.
What is the subcontractor's direct action?
Article 1798 of the old Civil Code gives the subcontractor a statutory right: he may directly approach the client for the services rendered for the execution of that client's project, up to the amount the client still owes the main contractor at the time the action is exercised.
This is a so-called imperfect direct action, meaning that the object of the claim is only fixed at the moment of exercise. Until that moment, the client can still make a discharging payment to the main contractor. From the moment the subcontractor exercises his claim, the client can no longer do so — at least not for the amount of the claim exercised.
The Antwerp Court of Appeal formulated this in its judgment of 22 October 2020 (RW 2022-23, no. 26, 1028) as follows: by exercising the direct action, the client's assets are called upon and, for that assignment, he can no longer make a discharging payment to the main contractor. The direct claim can however only be honoured by the client to the extent that its collateral — namely the main contractor's claim against the client — is still available in the main contractor's estate at that moment.
The rationale behind this rule: protection of the subcontractor as the economically weaker link in the chain, and prevention of situations in which the main contractor receives payment from the client without paying his own subcontractors.
Conditions for exercise
Four conditions must be cumulatively satisfied:
A valid subcontracting agreement. Between subcontractor and main contractor there must be a contract for services, under which the subcontractor provides services that the main contractor in turn passes on to the client.
Non-payment by the main contractor. The subcontractor must demonstrate that his claim against the main contractor is due and has not been paid.
A still available claim of the main contractor against the client. This is the critical point: at the time of exercise, the client must not yet have paid everything to the main contractor. The direct action can only succeed up to the amount still outstanding.
A link with the same project. The services the subcontractor claims must have been performed for the execution of the contract between the main contractor and that specific client. Work for other projects cannot be included in the claim against this client.
Extrajudicial exercise — Constitutional Court 81/2021
For a long time there was debate over whether the direct action could only be exercised by way of a writ of summons, or also extrajudicially. The Constitutional Court settled this in its ruling No. 81/2021 of 3 June 2021.
The Court held that Article 1798 of the old Civil Code does not infringe Articles 10, 11 and 13 of the Constitution, in the interpretation that it allows the subcontractor to exercise his direct action against the client by registered letter, and thus by extrajudicial action render inadmissible or unfounded any pending legal proceedings between the contractor and the client concerning the sum that forms the subject of the direct action.
The ruling refined the mechanism. Regardless of the form in which the subcontractor brings his direct action to the client's attention, it has the effect that a court seized of a payment claim by the main contractor against the client cannot rule on that entire claim before the direct action is resolved. However, exercising the direct action does not prevent the main contractor from bringing a legal claim for payment against the client — a claim already pending is not ipso facto rendered inadmissible or unfounded.
For the main contractor faced with a dispute with the client and confronted with an extrajudicial claim from his subcontractor, the Court offers a procedural way out: he can summon the subcontractor in forced intervention under Articles 16, second paragraph and 813, second paragraph of the Judicial Code. If the subcontractor fails to appear and does not file submissions, a default judgment can be rendered. If the main contractor considers the extrajudicial claim to be an abuse of process, he can claim damages from the subcontractor.
Antwerp 22 October 2020 — bankruptcy as blockage
A crucial warning for subcontractors: the bankruptcy of the main contractor closes the gate. The Antwerp Court of Appeal ruled on 22 October 2020 (RW 2022-23, no. 26, 1028) that the bankruptcy of the main contractor means that the claims of the bankrupt main contractor against the client are no longer available from that moment. From the judgment declaring bankruptcy, the direct action based on Article 1798 of the old Civil Code can therefore no longer be exercised (in application of Article XX.116 of the Code of Economic Law).
Practical consequence: as soon as a subcontractor notices signs of payment difficulties at his main contractor (delayed payments, changing excuses, bankruptcy rumours in the sector), he must act quickly. A registered letter to the client stating the outstanding amounts, together with a copy to the main contractor, is the first step. Waiting until bankruptcy is declared means losing this statutory security.
Antwerp Business Court 22 December 2022 — mandatory law
Another important question in practice: can the direct action be contractually excluded? For example, by a clause in the subcontracting agreement whereby the subcontractor waives his right to approach the client directly?
The Antwerp Business Court (Antwerp division) ruled clearly on 22 December 2022 (TBO 2023, no. 3, 128 and TRVRPS 2025, no. 1, 81): that is not possible. Parties cannot validly exclude the action under Article 1798 of the old Civil Code. Due to the important protective and security functions of this article, and the principle that statutory securities are mandatory law, the subcontractor's direct action is also mandatory law. The subcontractor cannot waive it in the agreement with the main contractor. A clause providing for such waiver is null and void and cannot prevent recourse to Article 1798 of the old Civil Code to directly claim payment from the client.
For subcontractors this means: even where their contract with the main contractor contains a waiver clause, they can still rely on the direct action. For main contractors this is a warning: including such a clause offers no protection and may even raise questions about other clauses in the contract — think of the doctrine of unfair terms between businesses.
What changes with Book 7 of the Civil Code?
The draft of Book 7 of the Civil Code of 16 April 2024 modernises and broadens the direct action. Article 7.4.31 governs the "direct action of the auxiliary person against the principal" and builds on the existing system.
Paragraph 1 of Article 7.4.31 provides: if the contractor does not pay his auxiliary person the sums contractually due, the auxiliary person has a direct action against the principal, up to the amount of the services rendered for the benefit of that principal. Exercise requires that the principal has remained debtor towards the contractor for services provided for the principal, the performance of which the contractor has fully or partially assigned to the auxiliary person. The direct action is exercised by notification. It is ineffective if it reaches the principal after the claim for payment of the contractor has become unavailable due to a seizure or a situation of concurrence affecting the contractor's estate.
An innovation: in a chain of auxiliary persons, each auxiliary person can exercise the direct action against the principal of his contracting party. The protection therefore extends beyond just the first layer of subcontractors.
Paragraph 3 provides a practical solution in the event of a dispute: in case of dispute between the auxiliary person and the contractor, the principal may deposit the amount with the Deposit and Consignment Office or on a blocked account in the name of both the contractor and the auxiliary person at a financial institution. The principal is obliged to do so if either the contractor or the auxiliary person requests this in writing.
Paragraph 4 expressly codifies the Business Court case law: any limitation or exclusion of the direct action is deemed unwritten.
Practical action plan for subcontractors
First step — internal file preparation. Which invoices are outstanding? Which services were performed for which specific project of which specific client? Gather quotes, site reports, photos and order confirmations documenting the services provided.
Second step — registered letter to the client. Stating the outstanding amounts, invoice details, identification of the project, and an express mention that you are exercising the direct action under Article 1798 of the old Civil Code. Send a copy to the main contractor (transparency, and it prevents surprises).
Third step — watch the timing. At signs of bankruptcy: act immediately. The Antwerp ruling of 22 October 2020 makes clear that the bankruptcy judgment closes the gate.
Fourth step — in case of dispute. If the client or main contractor disputes the claim, you can rely on the possibility of deposit with the Deposit and Consignment Office (already a common practice today, expressly codified in Article 7.4.31 § 3 of the new Book 7). At the same time, prepare judicial proceedings, summoning both client and main contractor.
Reius Advocaten assists subcontractors in exercising their direct action, from drafting the registered letter to, if necessary, substantive proceedings. For clients we analyse claims received and advise on the appropriate response. Contact us at info@reius.be.
Want to know your full position as a client? Read our guide on the rights and obligations of the client.