Reius Advocaten – Vastgoedrecht Brussel

Advocaten - Avocats - Lawyers

Reius Lawyers · 363 Avenue Louise box 26 · 1050 Brussels · info@reius.be · +32 2 616 08 10 Printed on 5 November 2026
Construction & Contracting

Additional Works: Can the Contractor Charge Extra?

Vianto Pashku - Lawyer · · 8 min
Table of contents

In short

The final invoice is significantly higher than the quote. The contractor points to "additional works" that were never put in writing. Is that allowed? When must you pay, and when not? A tour through the old Civil Code, recent Supreme Court case law and the upcoming Book 7 of the Civil Code.

You signed a quote for EUR 80,000. The contractor delivered, but the final invoice comes to EUR 105,000. "Additional works," he says. A slightly thicker floor, an extra pipe rerouted, a wall where no wall appeared in the plans. None of these additional works were agreed upon in writing beforehand. Can the contractor simply charge for them?

The answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no. Belgian construction law contains a specific rule for additional works on buildings at a fixed price (Article 1793 of the old Civil Code), but case law has adjusted that rule over the years. In addition, the contractor's duty to inform plays a role, especially when the client is a consumer. And the upcoming Book 7 of the Civil Code abolishes Article 1793, in favour of a more general information regime. Those who know their way around do not have to accept an additional-works invoice without question.

The starting point — a fixed price remains a fixed price

When a contracting agreement is concluded at a fixed price (lump sum, "marché à forfait"), that constitutes a strong commitment for the contractor. He bears the risk of performance: if the works turn out to require more materials or more time than anticipated, that is in principle his problem. The price remains the price.

The draft Book 7 of the Civil Code expressly confirms this principle in Article 7.4.8. The service provider must perform the assignment for the agreed price, and when a lump-sum price has been agreed, the service provider cannot demand any increase, even if the assignment requires more work or more expenditure than had been anticipated.

An exception remains possible when unforeseen and excessive circumstances make performance of the contract disproportionately burdensome. But the threshold is high, and this rule can moreover be contractually excluded.

What does Article 1793 of the old Civil Code say (current law)?

For the construction of buildings at a fixed price, Article 1793 of the old Civil Code contains a specific rule: the contractor or architect can only obtain a price increase where the client agrees in writing to the changes or enlargements, and the price is agreed.

This is not merely an evidentiary rule. Without written consent and an agreed price, any price increase is unlawful. Case law and legal scholarship interpret this article restrictively: it applies only to contracting agreements whose object is the construction of a building (Cass. 4 October 1951, RW 1951-52, 503). It does not apply to other contracting or service contracts — such as pure renovation without construction, infrastructure works in other contexts, or service agreements generally.

For classic new-build works at a fixed price, however, the rule is clear: without a signed addendum or a clear written agreement, the additional charge is not legally enforceable.

When additional works are nevertheless permitted without a written document

However, the case law of the Supreme Court has developed an important nuance that often proves decisive in practice: proof of consent can also be derived from the parties' conduct.

In its judgment of 5 December 2022 (AR C.22.0134.N), the Supreme Court confirmed that a contracting agreement can be proved by the conduct of one of the parties, such as ordering additional works. The Court referred to Article 8.31, second paragraph of the old Civil Code on extrajudicial admissions. Under that article, an extrajudicial admission can arise from the conduct of one of the parties, such as the performance of an agreement, and such conduct can be demonstrated by any means of evidence.

Practical consequence: a client who has additional works carried out, does not dispute them during the works, pays advances for those additional works, or allows the site to continue without protest, will find it difficult to refuse payment afterwards. The Court of Appeal of Mons developed this on 2 June 2022 (JLMB 2023, issue 36, 1608) by holding that where the customer had paid EUR 3,000 excluding VAT to the contractor, he had thereby expressed his consent to the performance of the works at that price.

However, the same case law contains an important warning for the contractor: he bears the burden of proof for both the client's consent and the agreed price. The Court of Appeal of Mons held that the contractor had not proved that the client had agreed to the price he was claiming. He had not provided the slightest evidence to support his allegations, although it would have been easy to submit documents such as invoices for the purchase of materials, price lists or quotes from other professionals. On the basis of Article 1134, paragraph 3 of the old Civil Code (today Article 5.73 of the Civil Code), which enshrines the principle of good faith, the Court held that the price had to be reduced to an amount corresponding to normal performance of the agreement.

The contractor's duty to inform

Alongside the rules on written consent, another line of case law comes into play: the contractor's duty to inform about the financial consequences of changes.

The Court of Appeal of Antwerp held on 16 April 2024 (DAOR 2025, issue 153, 20) that in the absence of information on additional works, the consumer may assume that all works carried out by the contractor were included in the original agreement. Concretely: the consumer does not have to pay compensation for additional works if the contractor did not comply with his duty to inform.

The underlying reasoning of Book 7, as formulated in the Explanatory Memorandum accompanying the abolition of Article 1793, supports this: the article aimed to protect the client, but that protection is also achieved in other ways, particularly on the basis of the duty to inform incumbent on the construction contractor under general contract law. When changes or enlargements to the assignment are being considered, the construction contractor must warn the client about the financial implications.

A similar logic applies to the architect. The Court of Appeal of Antwerp held on 10 September 2024 that the transparency requirement of Article VI.37 § 1 of the Code of Economic Law must be construed broadly. A fee clause that is unclear as to what exactly the hourly rate covers does not meet the clarity and comprehensibility requirement applicable to consumer contracts. Such a clause is then, in case of doubt, interpreted in the sense most favourable to the consumer (Article VI.37 § 2 of the Code of Economic Law).

What changes with Book 7 of the Civil Code?

The draft Book 7 of the Civil Code of 16 April 2024 abolishes Article 1793 of the old Civil Code. The Explanatory Memorandum reasons: the article departs from general contract law, where the principle of consensualism prevails and consent can be given either tacitly or expressly. Protection of the client is henceforth achieved through the general duty to inform in the law of obligations (Articles 5.16 et seq. of the Civil Code) and through B2C protection in the Code of Economic Law.

For the issue of additional works, Article 7.4.8 of Book 7 also introduces new rules concerning unknown circumstances. The service provider may ask the client to renegotiate the contract with a view to adaptation or termination if five conditions are cumulatively met: circumstances that already existed at the conclusion of the contract make performance excessively burdensome to the extent that it cannot reasonably be required; those circumstances were unforeseeable; they are not attributable to the service provider; the service provider has not assumed the risk; and neither statute nor contract exclude that possibility.

If the renegotiations are rejected or fail within a reasonable time, the court may, at the request of one of the parties, adapt the contract to bring it into line with what the parties would reasonably have agreed, or terminate the contract in whole or in part. The claim is dealt with as in summary proceedings.

Important: the possibility of price renegotiation in the event of unknown circumstances can be contractually excluded. A client who wants certainty about his lump-sum price can stipulate in his contract that Article 7.4.8 of Book 7 does not apply. For classic additional works (without unforeseeability), the general rule then remains that a price increase requires an agreement between the parties.

What if you refuse to pay for additional works?

First, the burden of proof. The Court of Appeal of Mons (2 June 2022) emphasises that the contractor must prove that the client agreed to the price. Anyone who refuses to pay the additional-works invoice compels the contractor to provide that proof — and in practice, that is often where the shoe pinches.

Second step: written dispute within a reasonable time. Immediately upon receipt of an invoice that you consider wrongly includes additional works, send a registered letter of protest indicating which items you dispute and why. Silence or paying part without reservation may be interpreted as consent.

Third step: gathering evidence. Which quotes or specifications did you receive in advance? What was and was not included? Have you ever confirmed the additional works to the contractor in writing? Is there correspondence or are there emails showing your consent to certain changes — or precisely not?

For consumers, a further specific layer applies: the contractor as an undertaking must clearly communicate the main characteristics of his service (Article V.2 of the Code of Economic Law) and his clauses must be transparent (Article VI.37 of the Code of Economic Law). An opaque additional-works clause or an hourly-rate arrangement whose application is unclear can be countered with the rule "in dubio contra proferentem". Read more in how to prove your arrangements without a written contract with your contractor.

Reius Attorneys assists you with the analysis of disputed additional-works invoices, from the written dispute to, if necessary, judicial proceedings. Contact us at info@reius.be for an initial analysis of your file.

Want to understand your full position as a client? Read our guide on the rights and obligations of the client.

Frequently asked questions

Can my contractor charge for additional works without my signature?

For the construction of a building at a fixed price, Article 1793 of the old Civil Code requires written consent from the client and an agreed price for the additional works. However, the Supreme Court (5 December 2022) accepts that the parties' conduct may suffice as evidence — an extrajudicial admission through performance of the agreement. Anyone who allows additional works to be carried out without protest or without agreeing amounts in advance risks having consent inferred. For other contracting or service contracts, the strict written-form requirement of Article 1793 does not apply.

What do I do if the final invoice is much higher than the quote?

Respond by registered letter within weeks of receipt. Indicate which items you dispute and why (no written consent, no agreed price, lack of information). Ask the contractor to provide his evidence — invoices for materials, price catalogues, emails about the additional works. If appropriate, pay the undisputed part under express reservation. If the dispute persists, have the matter legally assessed before proceeding to enforcement measures.

Does verbal consent to additional works count?

For the construction of a building at a fixed price, Article 1793 of the old Civil Code is strict: written consent and an agreed price are required. A verbal agreement is in principle insufficient. However, it can be confirmed by subsequent conduct — for example, the client who allows the additional works to be carried out, pays an advance or lets the site continue. For other contracting agreements (renovation without construction, service agreements), the general consensual rule applies: verbal agreements are valid, provided they can be proved.

Do I have to pay for additional works I did not request?

In principle, no. The contractor must prove that you consented both to the additional works and to their price. The Court of Appeal of Antwerp (16 April 2024) held that, in the absence of clear information, a consumer may assume that all works carried out were included in the original quote. But anyone who saw the additional works being carried out without protest risks having their conduct interpreted as tacit consent. So react quickly and in writing when you see unannounced works arising.

What if the contractor has to do extra work due to unforeseen circumstances?

At a fixed price, the contractor in principle bears the risk of unforeseen difficulties. The draft Book 7 of the Civil Code (Article 7.4.8) introduces a limited regime for "unknown circumstances" in which the service provider can request renegotiation, but only if five strict conditions are met: pre-existing circumstances, unforeseeability, non-attributability, no assumption of risk, and no statutory or contractual exclusion. Moreover, this regime can be contractually excluded — clients seeking certainty are well advised to stipulate this.

Can I have the price of additional works reduced if it is abnormally high?

Yes. The Court of Appeal of Mons (2 June 2022) held that the court has a marginal review power over the price on the basis of the principle of good performance of agreements, which prohibits the contractor from demanding an abnormally high price. Where the contractor fails to provide evidence of his pricing and the client can produce quotes from other professionals that are considerably lower, the price can be reduced on the basis of Article 5.73 of the Civil Code (good faith) to an amount corresponding to normal performance.

What will the upcoming Book 7 of the Civil Code change about the additional-works regime?

Article 1793 of the old Civil Code will be abolished. Protection of the client shifts to the general duty to inform (Article 5.16 of the Civil Code) and to B2C protection in the Code of Economic Law. For unforeseen circumstances, Article 7.4.8 of Book 7 introduces a limited renegotiation regime. Until Book 7 enters into force — which is not yet the case — the old regime continues to apply to new contracts. Upon entry into force, a transitional regime will apply to existing agreements.

Unsure about your situation?

The lawyers at Reius are ready to provide you with personal legal advice.

Book a consultation →