The contractor has left, the acceptance report has been signed, the balance has been paid. Two years later, you suddenly see a crack running through the plasterwork, moisture in the corner of a room, a piping problem that was invisible until then. No risk of collapse, but nothing minor that you could simply wipe away either. A defect that, had you known about it at the time of acceptance, you would never have accepted as such.
For such situations, the concept of minor hidden defects exists. It is not a synonym for "smaller" defects — these are all defects that are not serious enough to trigger the ten-year liability, but which nevertheless fall outside the scope of acceptance without reservation. The regime is nuanced: the client has time, but not unlimited time. Waiting for a quiet moment to react is usually the wrong answer.
What are minor hidden defects?
The Court of Appeal of Antwerp put it succinctly on 26 April 2022 (TBO 2023, issue 5, 250): minor hidden defects are shortcomings in, on or around the construction work and its function, which do not fall within the scope of the ten-year liability but are nevertheless sufficiently serious that the client would not have accepted the works had he known of the existence of these defects.
The definition captures three elements. First: the defect must be substantial. Trivial cosmetic flaws are not covered — these belong to the visible defects covered by acceptance. Second: the defect must be hidden at the time of acceptance. What a reasonably attentive client could have seen at acceptance is covered by his acceptance. And finally: the defect must not be stability-threatening — that would fall under the ten-year liability. The boundary between the two regimes is not always sharp, and when in doubt, an expert opinion is decisive. For the other regime, see how the ten-year liability of contractor and architect works.
The double time limit
This is where the pinch is sharpest for clients: there are two time limits running in parallel, and you must respect both.
The reasonable or useful period after discovery
The Court of Appeal of Ghent held on 21 January 2022 (TBO 2023, issue 4, 171) that the liability claim based on minor hidden defects (including for the breach of an alleged duty to warn) must be brought in a timely manner, meaning within a reasonable or useful period. The Court added that the contractor's liability for hidden defects is essentially a continuation of the contractual liability, since acceptance does not extend to those defects.
"Reasonable" is not a fixed number of weeks or months. The purpose is that it must be useful to make findings — the longer one waits, the more difficult it becomes to determine the cause of a defect afterwards. In practice, this means: report the defect by registered letter as soon as you or a professional discover it, and take steps to organise findings within weeks, not months.
The ten-year limitation period
In addition to the reasonable period after discovery, the claim falls under the ten-year limitation period of Article 2262bis of the Civil Code, which starts running from the acceptance-completion. The Court of Appeal of Liège confirmed this dual framework on 16 February 2022 (T.Verz. 2023, issue 4, 453): the claim must be brought in a timely manner from the moment the client discovered or should have discovered the defect, in such a way that the precise cause of that defect can be established with sufficient certainty. At the same time, it is subject to the ten-year limitation period from acceptance-completion.
The difference with the ten-year liability is technical but important: for minor hidden defects, it is a limitation period, which can be interrupted by a formal notice or by acknowledgement of the debt. For stability-threatening defects, it is a forfeiture period, which cannot be interrupted and expires absolutely.
Proof of the hidden nature
The burden of proof lies with the client. He must demonstrate three things: the existence of the defect, its hidden nature at the time of acceptance, and the fault of the contractor.
The Court of Appeal of Ghent (21 January 2022) clarified that liability for minor hidden defects requires proof of a hidden defect, as well as of a fault of the contractor. It does not follow from anything that the contractor's fault must necessarily consist of a shortcoming in the duty to carry out the work according to the rules of the art. Other faults — such as the breach of a duty to warn — also qualify.
In practice, proving the hidden nature means assessing what an attentive client could have seen at acceptance. A crack entirely under a suspended ceiling is hidden. A leaking pipe in an embedded wall is hidden. A loose socket visibly wobbling at the time of acceptance is not.
For technical matters, an expert investigation is usually necessary. The Court of Appeal of Brussels emphasised on 4 January 2024 (JLMB 2024, issue 27, 1204) that it is up to the client to prove the defects he complains of, and that a bailiff's report is not sufficient to prove the contractor's shortcomings when it concerns technical issues. Poor-quality photographs are equally insufficient to establish the origin of the defects. An adversarial expert investigation, in the presence of the contractor, is in most cases the foundation of the evidentiary file.
What if you wait too long?
Inaction has a clear legal sanction: acquiescence. The Court of Appeal of Antwerp ruled on 26 April 2022 (TBO 2023, issue 5, 250) that the absolute silence and inaction of the client cannot reasonably be interpreted otherwise than as acquiescence on his part towards the contractor. Anyone who observes the defect, does nothing, and only takes action years later, can be held to account on that basis.
The practical consequence is clear: as soon as you or a professional identify a hidden defect, react in writing within weeks, not within months. A registered formal notice with a description of the defect, date of discovery and request for an adversarial expert investigation is the standard route. If you are meanwhile waiting for repair quotes or for a second opinion, at least arrange an interim notification in which you reserve your rights.
The link with the duty to warn
A specific variant of minor hidden defects is one where the contractor allegedly breached his duty to warn. The Court of Appeal of Ghent (21 January 2022) held that a contractual liability claim for breach of an alleged duty to warn under a construction contract is to be regarded as a claim for indemnity for hidden defects. The client's acceptance can logically only relate to what is known to him at that moment.
Concrete consequence: even if the physical execution of the work is technically correct, a contractor who has failed to warn the client of a risk can still be held liable — under the same regime as for hidden defects. For details, see what consequences it has if your contractor did not warn you.
What will change with Book 7 CC?
The legislative proposal for Book 7 CC of 16 April 2024 substantially reworks this matter. Three separate periods will come into force for what in current case law is one regime of minor hidden defects.
Conformity period (Article 7.4.17 CC)
The contractor is only liable for conformity defects that come to light within a period of ten years from the acceptance of the completed assignment. This is a delineation of the scope of application: defects that appear later no longer fall under the contractor's liability.
Notification period (Article 7.4.18 CC)
The client shall notify the contractor of the conformity defect within a reasonable period after he has discovered or should have discovered it, and at the earliest from delivery. The reasonable period is assessed on the basis of all relevant circumstances and in particular the nature of the assignment, the nature of the conformity defect, the capacity of the parties and customary practices. If the client does not provide notification within this period, he loses the right to invoke the conformity defect.
Limitation period (Article 7.4.19 CC)
The claim for a conformity defect is time-barred two years from the notification of that defect. This period is suspended during negotiations between the parties or during the judicial or adversarial extrajudicial expert investigation.
The entire system is thus aligned with sales law: one concept of conformity, one overall period for liability (10 years), followed by a notification period (reasonable) and a limitation period (2 years after notification). The client gains clarity; the contractor gains certainty. For stability-threatening defects, a separate regime continues to apply under Article 7.4.49 CC, with absolute nullity of exoneration clauses.
Action plan when minor hidden defects are discovered
Immediately notify in writing. By registered letter, with the date of discovery, description of the defect, photographs or other evidence. Request a response within a reasonable period (two to four weeks).
Preservative expert investigation. Preferably adversarial, with the contractor present. If he refuses to cooperate, a court-appointed expert can be requested via the procedure of Article 962 of the Judicial Code. The Court of First Instance of Brussels (Dutch-speaking) emphasised on 26 July 2021 (T.App. 2023, issue 3, 23) that such a claim requires a prima facie case — a court-appointed expert is not intended to remedy a failing burden of proof.
Claim within reasonable period. If the contractor does not respond or responds insufficiently, a writ of summons or a reasoned claim. The difference with ten-year liability: the period after discovery is "reasonable" and not absolutely determined, but waiting more than a year without explanation is risky.
Reius Advocaten assists you at every stage, from the first formal notice to the expert investigation and the substantive procedure. Minor hidden defects require both technical and legal precision. Contact us at info@reius.be for an initial analysis of your file.
Would you like to know your full position as a client? Read our guide on the rights and obligations of the client.