The association of co-owners (in Belgian law, the VME) takes decisions by majority. For most matters, an ordinary or reinforced majority suffices, but for the most far-reaching decisions — acts of disposal over common immovable property — the law requires a four-fifths majority. Since an important ruling of the Court of Cassation of 9 March 2023, we also know that such a four-fifths decision is not automatically valid: it must also pass a proportionality test. This changes the way a co-ownership association must justify serious decisions.
Which majority for which decision?
Belgian apartment law provides for a graduated system of majorities, depending on the seriousness of the decision. The more far-reaching the decision for the property rights of the individual co-owners, the higher the required threshold.
An ordinary majority suffices for day-to-day management. For amendments to the common parts, a two-thirds majority applies (Article 3.88 § 1, 1° of the Civil Code). For the most serious category — acts of disposal over common immovable property — Article 3.88 § 1, 2° of the Civil Code requires a four-fifths majority. Acts of disposal are decisions that affect the existence or legal status of the common property itself: a sale, the creation of real rights, or the durable disposition of a common part.
The distinction between an act of management, an amendment of the common parts and an act of disposal is not always obvious, yet it determines the validity of the decision. If a decision is taken with too low a majority, it may be challenged as an irregular decision.
In practice, acts of disposal include, among others, the sale of a common part, allowing a co-owner to durably and exclusively use a common part, converting a personal right of use into a real right, or the creation of an easement or another real right burdening the common parts. In each case, the legal status of the property itself changes, and not merely the way in which it is managed or maintained. Precisely because such decisions irreversibly affect the assets of each co-owner, the legislator attaches the strictest threshold to them.
Disposal affects the right of ownership
Why exactly a four-fifths majority for acts of disposal? Because such a decision directly interferes with the right of ownership of each co-owner. A person holding a share in the common parts sees that share co-determined by what the majority does with those parts.
The Court of Cassation explicitly linked that observation, in its ruling of 9 March 2023, to the European Convention on Human Rights. An act of disposal over common immovable property constitutes an interference with the right of property as protected by Article 1, first paragraph, of the First Additional Protocol to the ECHR. That provision protects the peaceful enjoyment of possessions.
This elevates the four-fifths rule from a purely internal voting quorum to a safeguard anchored in fundamental rights. The majority may not simply dispose of the minority's share.
The underlying reasoning ties in with the broader protection enjoyed by the right of property. A co-owner holds not only their private unit, but also an undivided share in the common parts. If the community disposes of those parts, it interferes with an asset that legally belongs, in part, to the individual owner. The ECHR accepts that such interference is possible in the general interest, but only under strict conditions. It is precisely that conditionality which the Court of Cassation introduces into apartment law.
The proportionality test: four-fifths alone is not enough
The core point of the Cassation ruling is that reaching the four-fifths majority is, in itself, not sufficient. The decision must in addition strike a fair balance between the general interest of the community and the protection of the peaceful enjoyment of the individual co-owner's property.
Specifically, the Court requires a reasonable relationship of proportionality between the means used and the aim pursued. A decision that seriously restricts a co-owner's property rights must therefore rest on a thorough and objective justification, not on a vague or subjective ground.
The Court gave a striking example: a decision restricting the rental of a storage space to non-residents requires a thorough justification. An argument along the lines of "we're a bit afraid of it" is not sufficient. The association must demonstrate what objective interest the restriction serves and why no less intrusive alternative was available.
What does this mean in practice for the co-ownership association?
For a co-ownership association that wants to take a serious decision — and for a co-owner who opposes it — the debate shifts. Counting the votes is no longer enough. The substantive justification of the decision becomes open to judicial review.
A co-ownership association would do well, for every act of disposal, to record the justification in writing and in objective terms in the minutes: which general interest is being served, why is the chosen measure proportionate, and which alternatives were weighed. That care makes the difference when the decision is later challenged before the justice of the peace.
For the individual co-owner who feels aggrieved, the mirror image is equally relevant. Anyone wishing to challenge an act of disposal is no longer confined to the question of whether the voting quorum was reached. They can also argue that the decision is disproportionate: that it restricts their property rights more than necessary, that the justification is vague or subjective, or that a less intrusive alternative was available. The burden of proving an impaired interest rests with the claimant (Article 8.4 of the Civil Code), but the threshold for overturning an insufficiently reasoned act of disposal has been noticeably lowered by the Cassation ruling.
This ties in with the broader distinction between irregular and unlawful decisions. A decision formally adopted by the correct majority may nevertheless be unlawful and therefore voidable where there is a disproportion between the aim pursued and the harm suffered by the minority, especially where the most damaging solution is chosen while alternatives were available.
A four-fifths majority for retention?
A procedural insight from recent case law is that the required majority also operates in the opposite direction. When, in a Hasselt case of 18 April 2023, a vote was taken on the removal of a ventilation installation placed without authorisation, 68% voted against removal. That amounted to a de facto two-thirds majority wishing to retain the installation — precisely the majority required for an amendment to the common parts. The installation was allowed to remain.
Anyone wishing to steer a decision would therefore do well to consider how the agenda item is worded: a vote "in favour of removal" produces a different outcome than a vote "in favour of retention".
At the same time, that procedural cleverness must not overshadow the substantive test. Even an installation retained through a de facto majority may later fall if it permanently harms the appearance of the building or if the justification for retention proves insufficient. Here too, the combination of the correct majority and a tenable, objective justification remains the only durable basis for a decision that will stand up before the justice of the peace.
Practical conclusion
Since Cassation's ruling of 9 March 2023, the four-fifths rule for acts of disposal is more than a mere arithmetic exercise. A valid decision requires both the correct quorum and a proportionate, well-reasoned justification that respects the peaceful enjoyment of each owner. The broader framework of powers and decision-making within the co-ownership association can be found in our pillar on the operation and powers of the co-ownership association.
Is your co-ownership association preparing a serious decision, or do you as a co-owner wish to oppose an act of disposal affecting your rights? Reius Advocaten advises on the correct majority, the justification and the deadlines for challenge. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.