In large residential sites — think of an estate with multiple blocks, a mixed complex with retail on the ground floor and housing above, or a phased development — management is rarely conducted by a single association of co-owners. Belgian law allows the structure to be split into a main association and several sub-associations. This brings order to the management, but also creates pitfalls, particularly when a dispute arises and you have to determine which association you must precisely address.
Why sub-associations?
The co-ownership law, contained in Articles 3.84 et seq. of the Civil Code, provides the possibility of establishing several associations of co-owners within one large complex. There is then a main association that manages the parts common to everyone — think of the access road, the central infrastructure, the shared utilities — and alongside it, sub-associations that each manage a delineated set of private common parts.
This split is not an administrative luxury. It allows the residents of block A not to have to decide together and pay together for the lift or the roof of block B, and vice versa. Each sub-association manages its own common parts as designated in the deed of division, while the main association is responsible for what genuinely belongs to all owners. It is a logical structure for sites where different buildings or functions coexist.
Each sub-association decides only on its own parts
The division of powers between the main association and the sub-association is strict. The Justice of the Peace of Hasselt clarified this in a judgment of 3 January 2023. Where private common parts are managed by a sub-association, the general assembly of that sub-association can only take decisions on the private common parts assigned to it in the deed of division.
In other words: a sub-association may not decide on parts belonging to the main association or to another sub-association. If it does so anyway, its decision is taken outside its competence and is therefore challengeable. This ties in with the broader principle that an association decision falling outside its competence is irregular and can be contested by a co-owner.
The assignment of the common parts to the correct association takes place in the deed of division. In the event of a dispute, that deed is therefore the first document you must consult to know who is responsible for what.
The deed of division and the co-ownership regulations together constitute the statutes, and these are enforceable against all holders of a real or personal right on a unit (Article 3.93 § 1 CC). What the deed of division assigns to a particular sub-association therefore applies not only between the original parties, but also against later buyers and tenants. A co-owner cannot escape the structure by claiming that he was unaware of it or did not consent to it; the statutes bind him as soon as he acquires a right to a unit. This reinforces the importance of a correct and clear delineation in the deed of division of what belongs to the main association and what to each sub-association.
The procedural pitfall: whom do you summon?
This is where the greatest practical difficulty lies. When you wish to bring a claim concerning common parts, you must involve the correct association in the proceedings. If you summon the main association while the matter concerns private common parts of a sub-association — or vice versa — you risk having your claim declared inadmissible or unfounded against the wrong party.
This is no theoretical risk. In complex structures, it is not always immediately clear which part falls under which association, especially when the same syndic manages several associations and the general assemblies are in practice combined into one meeting. That factual combination, however, does not change the legal fact that these are separate legal persons, each with its own competence and its own standing to sue.
Enforceability: summon "in the presence of"
How do you solve this in practice? When you direct a claim against one sub-association, but the outcome also affects the other associations, it is wise to summon the other associations "in the presence of", so that the judgment is enforceable against them.
Suppose that a repair to a common part gives rise to a discussion about whether the costs fall to the main association or to a sub-association. If you only involve the main association in the proceedings, a sub-association can later argue that it is not bound by the judgment because it was not a party. By bringing all involved associations into the procedure, you avoid the situation in which the decision cannot be enforced against one of them.
This precaution is particularly relevant for large sites with a shared syndic organising mass meetings. The simplification in the field should not make you forget that each association stands legally on its own.
Along the same lines, it is important that decision-making per association remains transparent. When one syndic combines the meetings of several associations into one occasion, there is a risk that decisions are taken or reported back without it being clear on behalf of which association the vote was cast. For the validity of the decisions and for their subsequent enforceability, it is necessary that the minutes state unambiguously which association took which decision, with what majority and on which parts. A lack of such clarity makes decisions vulnerable to challenge.
Practical points of attention in disputes
For those confronted with a dispute in a split structure, some rules of thumb apply. Always start with the deed of division to establish the assignment of the common parts. Then determine whether the contested part falls under the main association or under a sub-association. Identify the correct legal person — each association has its own company number and its own syndic, even if in practice this is the same person. And in case of doubt or shared interests, involve the other associations "in the presence of" in the procedure.
This care at the start of a case prevents a substantively strong matter from stumbling over a procedural error in the choice of the opposing party.
Consider a concrete scenario. In an estate with three blocks and a shared underground car park, damage occurs to the access ramp leading to the car park. Does that ramp belong to the main association, because all residents use it, or to a sub-association, because it physically adjoins one block? The answer lies in the deed of division and determines who must bear the repair and whom you must address. If the wrong association is summoned, the case can suffer years of delay. Moreover, a cost allocation laid down in the deed of division cannot be unilaterally rearranged by an individual sub-association: any change to the distribution keys or to the assignment of parts follows the majority and formal requirements of the competent assembly.
Practical conclusion
Sub-associations bring order to the management of large complexes, but also divide competences and standing to sue strictly. Each association decides only on its own parts as designated in the deed of division, and in the event of a dispute, your case stands or falls with the choice of the correct opposing party. The broader framework of the functioning and powers of the association of co-owners can be found in our pillar on the powers and functioning of the association of co-owners.
Are you in a complex with multiple associations and is there uncertainty about who decides on what or whom you must address? Reius Advocaten unravels the structure on the basis of your deed of division and determines the correct procedural strategy. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.