When does co-ownership law actually apply? For anyone picturing a classic apartment building with several floors, the answer seems obvious. But the rules of the so-called Co-ownership Act — today found in Book 3 of the Belgian Civil Code — reach further than that. They also apply to holiday parks, horizontally divided sites and even to small co-ownerships with only two lots. At the same time, it is possible under certain conditions to withdraw a building from that regime. This article sets out when the regime applies and what the consequences are.
What determines the scope?
Article 3.84 of the Civil Code defines the scope of co-ownership law. The regime applies to any immovable property whose ownership is divided among several lots, each containing a private part and a share in the common parts.
Crucially, article 3.84 covers both vertical and horizontal division. The classic vertical division — a building split into floors and apartments — is the familiar form. But a horizontal division of functionally connected buildings is also covered. As soon as private lots with common parts exist and those parts must be jointly managed, co-ownership law applies in principle.
As a result, associations of co-owners arise in situations that one would not at first sight label as an "apartment building".
Holiday parks and unbuilt plots
A telling example was addressed by the Justice of the Peace of Dinant on 11 August 2023. The case concerned a holiday village or weekend residence park including unbuilt plots. The question was whether the owners of those unbuilt plots had to contribute to the common charges.
The court held that owners of unbuilt plots are also liable for their share in the common charges, regardless of whether the plot is inhabited or built on, and regardless of whether it actually generates waste or other consumption. Membership of the association of co-owners and the duty to contribute flow from the right of ownership over a lot, not from its actual use.
That is an important nuance for anyone owning a building plot or an unbuilt lot within a larger, jointly managed domain: you contribute to the charges, even if you do not yet live or build there.
Small co-ownerships: also with two lots
Co-ownership law does not apply only to large complexes. Even a building with only two lots belonging to different owners falls within the regime. This has concrete consequences, particularly for management.
The Justice of the Peace of Ostend confirmed in a judgment of 19 December 2023 that the appointment of a syndic is legally mandatory in every building with two or more lots belonging to different owners (article 3.90 of the Civil Code). That obligation applies even where the building has only two owners. The association of co-owners must moreover be registered with the Crossroads Bank for Enterprises and hold an enterprise number.
This is a common mistake in small co-ownerships. Two neighbours who each own one half of a divided townhouse often think they can handle their affairs informally. Legally, however, they form an association of co-owners (VME) and must appoint a syndic. If they fail to do so, the appointment of a syndic can be requested from the Justice of the Peace, and a claim concerning the common parts cannot be validly brought as long as the association is not properly represented in court.
Being within scope brings further obligations that often surprise small co-ownerships. Thus they too are subject to the statutory duty to build up a reserve fund for non-periodic expenditure, alongside the working capital for ordinary, recurring costs (article 3.86 § 3 of the Civil Code). That reserve fund cannot, in principle, simply be reimbursed: on 13 February 2024 the Justice of the Peace of Genk annulled a decision by which an association wanted to refund the reserve fund without regard to the ownership quotas. Whoever becomes an owner acquires the building together with its financial history — a factor that regularly triggers disputes when a lot is transferred.
Withdrawing a building from the regime
The law allows, under certain conditions, a building to be withdrawn from co-ownership law by means of a so-called abridged deed of base. This can make sense for small or simple constructions where a full-fledged association-based management would be unnecessarily burdensome. But such withdrawal has consequences, including for the relationships between the owners.
The Justice of the Peace of Deurne dealt on 1 March 2023 with a case in which a building had been withdrawn from the Co-ownership Act. There was damage to a drainpipe that had to be repaired urgently. One of the co-owners, manager of a contracting company, had the repair carried out and invoiced it through his company to the other co-owners. He based his claim on management of another's affairs (negotiorum gestio).
The court rejected the claim. The company was a third party and not itself a co-owner, and by invoicing commercially the disinterestedness required for negotiorum gestio was exceeded. The judgment shows that withdrawing a building from co-ownership law does not simplify mutual accounts, but may actually give rise to new disputes over who may invoice what and on what basis.
Mandatory law: no contractual departure
A final, fundamental feature: the provisions of co-ownership law are of mandatory law (article 3.100 of the Civil Code). The Justice of the Peace of Genk confirmed this on 13 February 2024. This means that one cannot freely depart from them in the by-laws or through mutual arrangements.
A clause in the deed of base or a decision of the general assembly that runs counter to a mandatory statutory provision is ineffective. Thus a developer cannot grant permission that circumvents the regulations or the law, and the association cannot simply contract away certain statutory duties — such as the appointment of a syndic or the creation of a reserve fund. The mandatory character protects each co-owner against by-law constructions that would erode his statutory rights.
Who decides whether something falls within the by-laws?
The scope also raises the question who ultimately decides whether a given use or operation fits within the intended purpose of the building. That assessment does not fall to the general assembly, but to the court. The Justice of the Peace of Ostend held on 10 October 2023 that it is the court — and not the general assembly — that sovereignly determines whether an operation falls within the deed of base. The general assembly cannot therefore itself bindingly decide that a particular use of a lot falls outside the by-laws; it can put its position to the court, which decides on the basis of adversarial evidence.
This is an important safeguard. A majority cannot vote a minority owner out of his use by unilaterally declaring that his activity does not match the intended purpose. The factual and legal characterisation remains a judicial competence, which protects the individual co-owner against an overly broad reading of the by-laws by the group.
Practical conclusion
The scope of the Co-ownership Act is broader than many people think: it covers both vertical and horizontal division, holiday parks with unbuilt plots, and even co-ownerships with only two lots. Withdrawal is possible, but does not necessarily simplify relations, and the mandatory character leaves little room for tailored solutions. Anyone wanting to know how the association actually functions once the regime applies will find an overview in our pillar on the powers and functioning of the association of co-owners.
Are you unsure whether your situation falls under co-ownership law, or are you considering withdrawing a building from it? Reius Attorneys reviews your deed of base and its consequences for management. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.