The general assembly has ruled, and you fundamentally disagree. Perhaps the item was not even on the agenda. Perhaps someone voted who should have abstained. Or perhaps everything went formally correctly, but the decision affects you so disproportionately that you wonder whether it can stand. Which decisions of an association of co-owners (ACO) can you have annulled, on what grounds, and within what deadline?
The law provides one procedure, but case law distinguishes two fundamentally different grounds for annulment: the irregular and the unlawful decision. Those who master the distinction choose the right strategy — and considerably increase their chances of success.
The four-month limitation period: the clock first, then the substance
Article 3.92 § 3 of the new Civil Code gives every co-owner the right to ask the justice of the peace to annul or amend a decision of the general assembly, where that decision is irregular, fraudulent or unlawful, or where it causes them personal harm. The action must be brought within a period of four months from the date of the general assembly.
Three features of this deadline deserve emphasis:
It is a strict limitation period (forfeiture). Not a period of prescription. After four months, the right itself disappears — no interruption, no suspension, no extension due to force majeure or ignorance.
It runs from the assembly, not from the minutes. Anyone who only receives the minutes three weeks after the GA effectively has three weeks less to assess, seek advice and issue proceedings. Being present at the assembly — or having yourself informed in good time — is therefore not a luxury.
It applies per decision. Every decision of every GA starts its own deadline. A decision you let pass in year one cannot be challenged in year three — not even where its consequences only become tangible later.
In practice we see co-owners who strategically secure the deadline: they issue proceedings just before the four months expire, while continuing dialogue with the ACO in parallel about an amicable solution. That is legitimate — those who wait until dialogue breaks down are usually too late.
The irregular decision: law or by-laws breached
A decision is irregular where, in the course of its adoption, the law or the by-laws have not been complied with. The justice of the peace of Ostend I set out the distinction clearly on 10 October 2023. Irregularity has two faces:
Substantive irregularity concerns the content of the decision: the GA exceeds its powers, or the required majority has not been reached. Classic example: a decision on an act of disposal (4/5 required) taken with a simple majority. Or a GA that itself bindingly "characterises" what only the court can assess — in the Ostend case the GA had ruled that a commercial operation did not fall under the statutory purpose provisions, and the court recalled that this characterisation belongs to the court, not to the majority.
Formal irregularity concerns the procedure: defects in the notice of meeting, a vote on an item not on the agenda, defects in the minutes, or a vote in which someone participated who should have abstained.
Two practical examples from recent case law make this concrete:
The item not on the agenda. A co-owner asked at the meeting itself, from the floor, whether he could install a socket for charging his electric car. The item was abruptly added to the agenda and voted on immediately — negatively. That vote was annulled: no binding vote can be taken on an item not validly placed on the agenda. Owners must be able to prepare themselves; anyone reading the agenda must know what will be decided.
The vote involving a conflict of interest. A property-developer co-owner voted on the approval of a statement of account concerning his own passed-on costs. Annulled for breach of the duty to abstain (art. 3.87 § 9 CC). At the second vote on the same statement he abstained personally, but voted through proxies from other owners — annulled again: those who cannot vote personally cannot do so via proxy either. See on this figure also the spoke on the clause promoteur.
The unlawful decision: formally correct, substantively disproportionate
More difficult is the unlawful decision. Here everything is formally in order: the item was on the agenda, the majority was reached, no one voted who should have abstained. And yet the decision may still fall.
The justice of the peace of Ostend I described it on 10 October 2023 as follows: an unlawful decision creates a disproportion between the objectives of the majority and the individual interest of a co-owner. Typically the majority chooses the most harmful solution while equivalent alternatives with less prejudice were available, or lets itself be guided by subjective rather than objective motives.
The review is a weighing of interests — and in it the claimant must do his homework. Article 8.4 CC places the burden of proof on those invoking the harm: you must concretely demonstrate your personal harm, quantified where possible.
The contrast between two heat-pump cases illustrates this strikingly. In Wavre the justice of the peace annulled a refusal by the GA on 6 August 2021: the owner had invoked high electricity prices as personal harm and produced a calculation showing the concrete benefit of the heat pump. The bare refusal in the face of that quantified harm was unlawful. In Ostend II by contrast a refusal on 25 May 2022 did hold up: the ACO reasoned that it preferred a collective heating approach to individual installations — an objective, policy-based reason that tipped the balance of interests in its favour.
The lesson: a GA that refuses must give reasons. An owner who challenges must quantify. Whichever of the two fails to do their homework, loses.
A third example from case law: a GA decided to fully redistribute the reserve capital to the co-owners — outside the statutory distribution according to shares. A recent purchaser objected: he had bought an apartment with accumulated reserve capital, and would now have to watch it be handed out and then start saving from zero again. The decision was annulled. The combination of an irregular distribution key and real personal harm carried the case.
What the court does and does not do
One boundary deserves particular attention: the justice of the peace annuls, but takes no discretionary decisions in place of the ACO. Anyone who has a refusal annulled does not thereby obtain authorisation — the matter returns to the general assembly, which must decide again, this time within the parameters the court has drawn.
That became painfully clear in a file in which the owner of a rooftop apartment had asked the GA for a private right of use over part of the roof. The GA refused; the owner filed an appeal with the justice of the peace — neatly within the four months — mainly to preserve the deadline while continuing dialogue with the ACO. The dialogue broke down, the case was argued on the merits, and the court dismissed the claim: there is no legal basis whatsoever requiring a general assembly to grant anyone a private right of use. The GA may refuse, provided it does not refuse unlawfully. The difference between "I do not get what I want" and "the refusal is unlawful" is precisely what these proceedings turn on.
Strategy: which ground do you choose?
The choice between irregularity and unlawfulness is not an academic question — it determines your burden of proof and your chances of success.
Irregularity is documentary. You produce the notice, the agenda, the minutes, the voting result. The proof is on paper. If there is a formal defect, annulment is almost mechanical. Always start here: screen the procedure for defects before entering the substantive discussion.
Unlawfulness is a balancing exercise. You must demonstrate a disproportion, quantify personal harm, and make it plausible that less harmful alternatives were available. That requires preparation: quotes, calculations, photos, possibly a technical report.
Cumulate where possible. Nothing prevents you from invoking both grounds in a single writ: primarily the irregularity (quicker proof), subsidiarily the unlawfulness (safety net if the formal defect does not carry enough weight).
And above all: build your file before the meeting. Have your agenda items placed on the agenda in good time and in writing. Have your objections recorded in the minutes. Vote against and have that noted — those who voted in favour will later struggle to explain what personal harm they suffer. The general assembly is not only a decision-making moment, it is where your later procedural file is written. For the full framework of majorities and voting prohibitions, see the pillar on the ACO in practice.
Conclusion
Challenging a GA decision is not a game of chance, but a matter of technique: the right ground, the right evidence, and above all the right timing. The four-month deadline is inexorable, the burden of proof lies with you, and the court annuls but does not decide in place of the ACO.
Do you doubt whether a decision of your general assembly can be challenged? Do not wait until the deadline is pressing. Contact us at info@reius.be or via the contact form for an initial evaluation of your file.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.