You live in an apartment building and identify a construction defect: water seeping into your unit, cracks forming, a leaking terrace. You raise the issue at the general meeting and ask the Owners' Association (in Belgium: 'vereniging van mede-eigenaars' or VME) to take action against the developer. But the group refuses: the upstairs residents notice nothing, do not want to contribute to the cost of proceedings, and the Association remains inactive. What can you do as an individual co-owner? Belgian case law offers more options than many people think — including compelling the inactive Association to act itself.
Why an Owners' Association remains inactive
It is a familiar and very human pattern. A co-owner on the ground floor experiences rising damp or water ingress; the residents on the higher floors notice nothing and see no reason to contribute to the costs of proceedings against the developer, whether won or lost. For them, such proceedings offer little short-term benefit.
The consequence is that the affected owner has to fight within the group simply to get action. Sometimes he is even told not to bother the rest of the Association with "his" problem. Yet that attitude overlooks an important point: a problem that visually manifests itself within a private unit may very well have its cause in the common parts — a missing damp-proof course, a defect in the foundations or the façade. And in that case it is indeed the Association that must act.
First step: put the matter on the agenda and document it
Before going further, it is crucial to build a case file. Have your complaint formally placed on the agenda of the general meeting and expressly request that the Association take the necessary action against the developer. The minutes that result serve as proof that you put the Association on notice and that it failed to act.
Equally important is technical substantiation. A unilaterally commissioned report from a construction expert — measuring is knowing — demonstrates that the problem affects not only your unit but the salubrity of the building, and therefore the community. Armed with such a report, you open up a very different case and avoid the discussion becoming bogged down in internal resentment. It also convinces the upstairs residents that action concerns the entire building.
You can litigate yourself — for your own share
If the Association remains inactive, you can, as an individual co-owner, bring a claim yourself against the developer, contractor or architect. The Business Court of Antwerp confirmed that the standing of the Owners' Association in relation to the common parts is not exclusive. The architect and the main contractor — and also the developer — can be sued by the Association for defects in the common parts, but equally by an individual co-owner, albeit up to the extent of his share in the co-ownership.
In the case that gave rise to this ruling, an owner experienced water ingress in her ground-floor unit, presumably due to a missing waterproofing course at the junction with her private area. The Association initially took the view that it was not its concern. The woman went to the Business Court herself and summoned the developer. When the Association later did commence its own proceedings, joinder was requested, and the court confirmed that the individual owner's claim was indeed admissible. How this standing is precisely divided between the Association and the individual owner is set out in our spoke article on standing of the Owners' Association and the co-owner.
You can compel the inactive Association to act
Going further is also possible. An individual owner can ask the Justice of the Peace to order the Association itself to carry out the necessary works. In a case before the Justice of the Peace of Hasselt (judgment of 2021, following an ordeal that had begun in 2015), an owner had been experiencing moisture problems with moss growth for years due to defective water management. The Association had been slow to act.
The Justice of the Peace ruled that the fact that the Association had in the meantime summoned the developer before another court did not prevent this co-owner's claim from being granted. The Association was ordered to carry out the works — including high-pressure removal of the moss — subject to a penalty payment. Moreover, if the Association failed to comply within nine months, the owner was authorised to have the works carried out at the Association's expense by a contractor of her choice. The judge thereby recognised that, through the Association's inaction, the individual owner had lost time, suffered loss of enjoyment and was entitled to a solution.
One nuance emerged on appeal: the penalty payment linked to the settlement of invoices was set aside, because a penalty payment cannot be used to enforce a monetary payment. The core — the order requiring the Association to perform in kind — remained intact.
The difficulty: proving that it is a common problem
Not every claim succeeds. A recurring stumbling block is the evidence that the defect truly affects the community and is not merely a private issue. In one case where cracks — clearly more than ordinary settlement cracks — were found in six of the twenty apartments, the Association's claim was held inadmissible because the court found that it had not been sufficiently established that the problem was a common one — the observations had only been made in individual units.
This illustrates why a thorough technical report is so important. The cause of a defect is often not visually apparent: cracks in individual units may point to a stability problem of the entire building, even if they manifest themselves separately in different places. A party — whether the Association or an individual owner — that wishes to demonstrate that the defect concerns the common parts is well advised to have a construction expert identify the cause rather than merely document the visible symptoms.
The same case reveals a further sensitivity: once the claim was declared inadmissible, the Association dropped the matter because only six of the owners wanted to persevere and no majority could be reached. The six affected owners were left with their cracks. A strongly substantiated case from the outset might have avoided that outcome.
The flip side: inaction can prove costly for the Association
For an Owners' Association, this is a clear warning. A problem visually observable in a private unit does not mean that the cause lies there; often it is located in the common parts. An Association that does nothing in response to such a report risks being ordered later to carry out the works itself — even subject to a penalty payment. It is therefore sensible for an Association to respond alertly to complaints from individual owners rather than brushing them aside.
One point of attention for the claimant owner: you must be able to show that you put the Association on notice to take the necessary steps, typically through an agenda item at the general meeting. Compensation for loss of enjoyment or lost time is not automatic and depends on what you can prove.
Practical conclusion
If the Association remains inactive in the face of a construction defect, you are not powerless. Build a case file through agenda-setting and a technical report, litigate for your own share if necessary, and as a last resort ask the Justice of the Peace to compel the Association to carry out the works. The broader framework of acceptance and liability can be found in our pillar on the acceptance of a new-build apartment.
Are you facing an Owners' Association that ignores your construction complaint? Reius Advocaten assists individual co-owners in applying the right pressure and, where necessary, prompting the Association to act. Contact us at info@reius.be.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.