For a long time, the rules on unfair terms were reserved for consumers. Between undertakings, contractual freedom prevailed, with only good faith and abuse of rights as general limits. That changed on 1 December 2020, when the Act of 4 April 2019 inserted a new Title 3/1 into Book VI of the Code of Economic Law (CEL). Since then, Articles VI.91/1 to VI.91/10 CEL also apply to B2B contracts — with direct impact on construction contracts, architect agreements and subcontracting.
The consequences have been underestimated by many undertakings. Clauses that appeared for years in standard terms of contractors and sector federations — unilateral price-modification clauses, exemptions for gross fault, restrictions on evidence — today risk being declared null. For corporate principals, developers and even for associations of co-owners with predominantly professional units, this is good news, provided they know which clauses are challengeable and how. This article sets out the black and grey lists and discusses how they play out in the construction sector.
Scope: broader than you might think
The B2B regime applies to contracts concluded between undertakings, with a few exceptions. Construction companies, developers, engineering firms and architects operating as companies all fall within its scope.
An important extension: Article VI.91/1, § 3 CEL provides that the regime also applies to contracts concluded between an undertaking and an association of co-owners (Article 3.86 of the Civil Code), where more than twenty-five per cent of the shares in the common parts are allocated to units that, according to the by-laws, may have a professional purpose. In practical terms: for mixed or predominantly professional apartment buildings, B2B protection applies at the level of the association, even where individual owners are private persons. This has practical consequences for construction, management and maintenance contracts with the syndic or with external service providers.
The general test: manifest imbalance
The core of the regime is set out in Article VI.91/3 § 1 CEL: a clause is unfair where, alone or in conjunction with other clauses, it creates a manifest imbalance between the parties' rights and obligations.
When assessing this, the court looks at all circumstances: the nature of the performances, the general economy of the contract, applicable trade usage, and the other clauses. Importantly, the test does not target price or the equivalence between performance and counter-performance, provided these are drafted in clear and comprehensible terms. It concerns the structure of the reciprocal obligations, not the commercial balance.
For a construction dispute, this means that when you challenge a clause as excessively favourable to your contractor or counterparty, the court will not rule on the price itself, but on how risk, responsibility and remedies have been allocated.
The black list: four clauses that are always unfair
Article VI.91/4 CEL lists four clauses that are unfair without the possibility of rebuttal:
1° Unilateral irrevocable commitment while the undertaking's performance depends on its own will. You are bound, but the other party can withdraw from performance at any time. In construction, this occurs in clauses reserving to the contractor the right not to commence works without any justification, while the principal is already bound.
2° Unilateral right of interpretation for the undertaking. A clause stating "in case of dispute, the contractor decides on the meaning of this agreement" is always null.
3° Waiver of any means of recourse in case of dispute. A clause prohibiting you from bringing court proceedings, however the dispute is structured, is always null.
4° Irrebuttable acknowledgment or acceptance without actual knowledge before contract formation. A clause stating "the principal is irrebuttably deemed to have known and accepted all general terms" while those terms were not actually communicated in advance, is always null.
The grey list: eight clauses presumed unfair
Article VI.91/5 CEL contains a grey list of eight clauses that are presumed unfair, unless the contrary is proven. For construction contracts, the following are particularly relevant:
Unilateral price modification without a valid reason. A clause allowing the contractor to unilaterally modify the agreed price without a clear and objectively verifiable reason is presumed unfair. Classic price-revision formulas (based on an index such as the construction materials price index) remain possible, provided they are drafted clearly and comprehensibly.
Tacit renewal without a reasonable notice period. A framework contract that automatically renews without allowing you to give timely notice falls under this presumption.
Transfer of economic risk without counter-performance. A clause shifting the entire performance or market risk onto the principal, where it would normally belong to the contractor, is presumed unfair.
Inappropriate limitation of statutory rights in case of breach. A clause preventing you from terminating, suspending or seeking substitute performance in the event of serious breach by the contractor is suspect.
Exemption from liability for intent, gross fault or essential obligations. A clause releasing the contractor from liability for its intent, its gross fault, or the non-performance of the essential obligations forming the subject matter of the contract, is presumed unfair. This directly affects classic exemption clauses in contractors' general terms.
Restriction of means of evidence. A clause stating "only complaints supported in writing will be considered" or imposing a pre-determined evidentiary regime to your detriment falls under this presumption.
Damages amounts manifestly disproportionate to the loss. Liquidated damages clauses that are manifestly excessive compared to the potential actual loss are challengeable — including in a B2B context.
Particularly important: the public policy nature of ten-year liability
On top of the CEL review, a strict regime applies to liability clauses in the construction sector. The Court of Cassation confirmed in its judgments of 12 February 2021 (Cass. AR C.20.0066.N) and 10 February 2022 (Cass. AR C.19.0594.N) that the specific liability of architects and contractors for defects threatening the stability of the works (Articles 1792 and 2270 of the old Civil Code) is a matter of public policy.
This has three consequences that trump any B2B clause:
A clause excluding ten-year liability is null. A clause limiting liability in the case of concurring faults of the architect and the contractor to each party's share of the loss is null — joint and several (in solidum) liability remains. The bill on Book 7 of the new Civil Code carries this rule forward in Article 7.4.49, § 3, which declares any exclusion or limitation of the stability-threatening conformity liability absolutely null.
For the broader framework on ten-year liability, see the article on ten-year liability of the contractor and the architect.
Practical: what do you do with an unfair clause?
The sanction is clear: an unfair clause is null, and this nullity can be raised by the court of its own motion. The rest of the contract remains in principle intact, unless the contract cannot survive without the void clause. Reinterpretation or "saving" the clause is excluded in B2B — the all-or-nothing approach of consumer law has been carried through.
When you sign contracts with contractors, architects or service providers as a corporate principal or association of co-owners, a thorough review by a lawyer is worthwhile. Not to negotiate away every less favourable clause, but to identify the real red lines from the CEL and public policy. For the broader framework of your position as a principal, see the pillar on rights and obligations of the principal in construction contracts.
Reius Advocaten assists undertakings, developers and associations of co-owners in drafting, reviewing and challenging construction and architect contracts. For a review of your contract or an ongoing dispute, contact us at info@reius.be.