You own an apartment and your ceiling has been leaking for months. You raise it at the general meeting, fail to secure a majority, and the managing agent shrugs. May you go to court yourself? Or must you wait endlessly for the association of co-owners (AoC) to wake up?
The answer is more nuanced than many co-owners think. Standing to sue in co-ownership is non-exclusive: both the AoC and the individual co-owner may bring proceedings, each for their own share or interest. Those unfamiliar with this principle get bogged down in unnecessary waiting for a passive majority. This spoke sets out the three main questions: who can sue, in what capacity, and what do you do if the AoC remains inactive?
The statutory basis: Article 3.92 § 1 NCC
Since the 2010 reform of apartment law, and carried over unchanged into the New Civil Code, Article 3.92 § 1 NCC grants the AoC its own standing to sue. The AoC may act in court — as claimant or defendant — to defend the common interests, whether or not together with one or more co-owners. This seems obvious, but until 2010 it was legally contested: a legal entity without a clear patrimonial basis would have no procedural interest. The legislator settled that debate by expressly conferring standing on the AoC in the Apartment Act itself.
A first implication follows from the limited purpose of the AoC (see The AoC in practice). The AoC can only sue within its speciality: the management and preservation of the common parts. A claim falling outside that purpose — for example an objection against a neighbouring plot's environmental permit — will be rejected by the Council for Permit Disputes. The AoC may not do everything, and what it may not do, it cannot bring before the courts either.
A second implication follows from the word "non-exclusive". The Act does not deprive the individual co-owner of their own right to act for their share. That is more than an academic detail — it is the legal escape route for anyone facing a passive AoC.
What can the individual co-owner do?
The Enterprise Court of Antwerp, Hasselt division, ruled on 22 March 2023 in a telling case. A co-owner of a ground-floor apartment had reported water infiltration on his terrace for years. Two successive general meetings had refused to take action against the developer. When the owner decided to sell his apartment, the water damage proved an insurmountable obstacle to sale. He ultimately sued the developer himself.
The developer defended with an admissibility objection: this single owner could not bring the claim, since it concerned repair of the common parts — a matter for the AoC. The court rejected that defence. The AoC's standing is non-exclusive. The individual co-owner was entitled to sue the developer, "admittedly by virtue of his share in the co-ownership". When it later transpired that the water problem also manifested elsewhere in the building, the AoC joined the proceedings — but the co-owner's own claim remained admissible.
Three principles flow from this:
One: The individual co-owner may sue the architect, main contractor or developer on grounds such as ten-year liability (art. 1792 old CC / art. 5.244 NCC), contractual liability, or minor hidden defects. He does so for his own share in the common parts — not for the full amount of the damage to the AoC.
Two: The claim is not inadmissible merely because the cause lies in the common parts. On the contrary: precisely when the cause lies in the common parts and the AoC will not cooperate, this case law offers a direct way out.
Three: The claim is admissible before and during any parallel AoC proceedings. A later AoC claim does not "absorb" the individual claim — both proceedings may be joined, but both stand legally on their own feet.
What can the AoC itself do?
The AoC acts through its statutory representative: the managing agent. A claim brought by the AoC without a validly appointed managing agent is inadmissible (JP Ostend I, 19 December 2023). Appointment — and, where necessary, an emergency appointment in the absence of one — is therefore the first step.
The Enterprise Court of Antwerp ruled on 3 November 2022 in a case where the developer defended himself by arguing that he had never concluded any agreement with the AoC — only with the individual purchasers. The court rejected this. The rights of the individual co-owners with respect to the common parts have come into co-ownership as a divided ownership right, managed by the AoC. The AoC can therefore sue in respect of the common parts, even if it is not legally a direct contracting party with the developer. The AoC acts as legal successor to the rights of the individual owners for the management and disposal of the common parts.
The same ruling showed that the AoC may also challenge an exoneration clause which the developer had included in his standard deed. The clause limited liability for minor hidden defects to one year after provisional acceptance — three cumulative grounds rendered it void. The spoke on exoneration clauses in developer contracts develops this further.
And the managing agent? An independent right of initiative?
The managing agent is not an autonomous party to proceedings. Decisions on the substance of a claim — deciding whether the AoC will litigate, which lawyer it appoints, what amount it commits — fall within the sovereign competence of the general meeting. The Court of First Instance of Brabant reiterated this sharply in an early-COVID decision: the resolution to bring legal proceedings concerning the common parts falls within that sovereign competence of the GM and cannot simply be delegated to the managing agent or the council of co-ownership.
But the managing agent does have scope for precautionary measures and urgent claims (art. 3.92 § 1 NCC). Specifically, he may:
- have a court expert appointed in summary proceedings to establish an acute construction defect
- interrupt limitation by a judicial writ, to safeguard the AoC's rights
- lodge an appeal within the four-month period where there is no time for an extraordinary general meeting
Condition: the GM must subsequently ratify his decision. If the GM does not, the managing agent bears personal risk for the costs incurred. In the COVID context, one judge even accepted that proceedings had been started before the formal GM resolution because the health context made normal functioning of the organs impossible — a decision which itself shows that the rule is not absolute but is strictly applied.
A final long-standing grievance: the managing agent who runs the construction dispute "over the heads of the co-owners". In practice, the managing agent sometimes conducts discussions with the lawyer alone, reports back only to a few owners, and does not involve the group in strategic choices. That is risky: at any turn in the proceedings (a settlement offer, a court judgment with unexpected consequences), the managing agent stands alone against a dissatisfied group. Good practice is to take the whole group along through regular updates and scheduled interim decisions.
What if the AoC remains inactive?
This is the sharpest practical question. The AoC has jurisdiction but refuses to act. The individual co-owner can go to court for his own share — but what if the repair requires works to the common parts on which only the AoC can decide?
The Justice of the Peace of Hasselt I dealt with such a case on 27 April 2021. A co-owner had insisted for years on a moisture problem which also manifested itself in moss growth and façade damage. The AoC had only belatedly initiated proceedings against the developer. By then an expert report was available which clearly described the problem and the solution. The co-owner went to the JP requesting that the AoC itself be ordered to carry out the works — under penalty payment.
The JP granted the claim. The AoC was ordered under heavy pressure to remove the moss and treat the façades. If this was not carried out within nine months, the claimant co-owner was entitled to appoint a contractor himself at the AoC's expense. A penalty payment was imposed to enforce that deadline. On appeal the judgment was reformed on one point (a penalty payment could not be imposed on the payment of invoices — separate from the possibility of a penalty payment on the execution of works), but the core stood: a passive AoC can be ordered to perform.
Three points of attention for such a claim:
One — building a file. You must be able to show that you have repeatedly asked the AoC to act. Agenda items at successive GMs, with minuted answers, are decisive. Also send registered notices of default to the managing agent as soon as the problem manifests itself.
Two — tortious versus contractual. In the Hasselt case, the claimant relied on Article 1382 old CC (today art. 6.6 NCC). The judge did not address this expressly, but there is debate whether co-owners can sue each other in tort — they are, after all, contractually bound via the by-laws. In practice it works cumulatively: one relies on the Apartment Act (the AoC's duty of management) and subsidiarily on Article 6.6 NCC. That gives the judge two parallel grounds.
Three — damages. The Hasselt decision ordered performance, but not compensation for loss of enjoyment. Anyone also seeking financial damages must claim them expressly and prove the causal link between the AoC's delay and the damage. That is technically difficult if you yourself have been silent for years — another argument for acting quickly.
What if the individual co-owner wishes to litigate jointly with the AoC? Two techniques exist. Either both parties join in one set of proceedings: the AoC sues for the common parts, the individual owner for his share. Or the co-owner gives a contractual mandate to the AoC to act for his share as well, so that a single claim suffices and the proceedings do not swell unnecessarily. The choice depends on the number of affected owners and the complexity of the file.
Cost regime: Article 3.92 § 9 NCC
One last, often forgotten rule. A co-owner whose claim against the AoC is declared fully well-founded is exempt from his contribution to the fees and costs — which are distributed among the other co-owners (art. 3.92 § 9 NCC). The same applies to a co-owner sued in a claim which later proves unfounded.
The Justice of the Peace of Genk applied this on 13 February 2024 and confirmed that even partial success gives rise to a proportional contribution by the AoC to the costs of the claimant co-owner. That lowers an important threshold: anyone litigating alone against a passive majority need not fear that his own AoC contribution will hit him twice.
Practical consequences
Anyone confronted with a passive AoC now knows:
- You can sue yourself for your share, even if the cause lies in the common parts
- You can, in parallel, have the AoC ordered to perform, under penalty payment
- You first build a documented file via agenda items at GMs and registered notices of default
- If your claim against the AoC succeeds, you are exempt from your contribution to the costs
The choice between litigating alone, jointly with the AoC, or having the AoC ordered to perform, depends on the extent of the damage, the number of owners involved and the nature of the repair. To weigh this concretely, contact us at info@reius.be or via the contact form for an initial assessment of your file.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.