Reius Advocaten – Vastgoedrecht Brussel

Advocaten - Avocats - Lawyers

Reius Lawyers · 363 Avenue Louise box 26 · 1050 Brussels · info@reius.be · +32 2 616 08 10 Printed on 5 November 2026
Apartments & Co-ownership

Buying an Apartment Under the Breyne Act: Your Rights During the Formation Phase

Door Vianto Pashku, advocaat - Lawyer · · 11 min
Table of contents

In short

You are buying an apartment off-plan. The building does not yet exist, but the association of co-owners (ACO) already exists in law. What are your rights in that twilight zone between purchase and first general assembly? Who pays what? When can you intervene? We explore the interface between apartment law and the Breyne Act.

You are buying an apartment off-plan. The building does not yet exist, the acceptance file sits on a notary's desk, and the association of co-owners (ACO) already exists in law from the moment the first preliminary contract is signed. What are your rights in that twilight zone between purchase and first general assembly? Who pays what? When can you intervene in decisions?

This spoke explores the interface between apartment law and the Breyne Act. It is the phase where most pitfalls lie — for those who do not know the difference between the actual building, the legal ACO, and the powers of the property developer pending the first acceptance.

The Breyne Act in two sentences

The Breyne Act of 9 July 1971 protects the buyer of a dwelling or apartment that has not yet been erected or is under completion. The act imposes mandatory minimum rules on any agreement in which the purchase or construction takes place before final acceptance: form and content of the agreement, payment schedule (phased according to construction progress), guarantee obligation, and above all a four-moment structure for acceptance.

Those four moments are: the provisional acceptance of the common parts, the provisional acceptance of the private parts, the final acceptance of the common parts, and the final acceptance of the private parts. At least one year must elapse between provisional and final acceptance (art. 9 Breyne Act). For those wishing to fully grasp the four-moment structure, please consult the spoke four acceptance moments in an apartment building.

When does the ACO come into legal existence?

Here lies the first pitfall. The ACO comes into being by operation of law as soon as a building is divided into private and common parts and the first transfer of ownership takes place — not only after acceptance, not only after the first general assembly. The moment of creation is linked to article 3.84 of the new Civil Code (NCC) and typically falls on the first authentic deed of transfer before the notary.

In an off-plan purchase under the Breyne Act, this means: the ACO exists for years before a single resident sets foot in the building. When you are the tenth buyer and your deed has been passed, you join a legal entity that already exists in law — even if the first nine buyers have never met, even if no syndic has yet been appointed, even if the first floor is still being erected.

From its creation, the ACO must, in principle, comply with all statutory obligations of apartment law: appoint a syndic (art. 3.89 NCC), organise a first general assembly, build up a reserve fund from the moment of acceptance. In practice, all of this still falls under the developer's direction — which creates fertile ground for the promoter's clause (see the separate spoke on clause promoteur).

Cost transfer: the pivotal 2 September 2021 ruling

The key practical question in this phase: who pays what? During construction there are utilities, a site insurance, an ABR policy (all site risks), security costs, possibly a site warehouse. Upon acceptance there is a block policy, energy costs for the common parts, the fee of the first syndic, administrative costs of the ACO.

Before 2021 there was little clarity on the pivotal moment. Some developers passed on invoices to the ACO for costs incurred before acceptance — site-related expenses that the developer itself should have borne.

The Court of Cassation handed down a ruling on 2 September 2021 that sets this straight. Common costs transfer from the developer to the ACO from the moment of the provisional acceptance of the common parts. Not earlier. Even if the sale deed provides for a different transfer moment, this cannot bring forward the transfer with respect to the use of the common parts.

The practical effect is sharp. When a developer — sometimes acting as first syndic that he has appointed himself — presents settlements for:

  • Site-related utilities (electricity and water during construction): the ACO should not pay these. They are a business cost of the developer.
  • ABR site insurance: remains with the developer until acceptance.
  • Other construction costs: same.

When you as buyer or ACO are confronted with such a settlement, you can demand the split between pre- and post-acceptance. A detailed cost analysis, linked to the Cassation ruling of 2 September 2021, is often sufficient to have that settlement revised. For the broader allocation of charges between developer and ACO, see allocation of charges between developer and ACO.

The four acceptance moments in practice

In an ideal world, the four acceptance moments follow each other neatly. In practice, things go differently. Two scenarios often arise:

Scenario 1 — The developer postpones the provisional acceptance until full payment. Some developers refuse to sign acceptance until the buyer has paid the last instalment. That may seem logical from a commercial viewpoint, but it can constitute abuse of rights. The court of Antwerp ruled on 11 June 2019 that a developer who kept refusing acceptance despite objectively completed works was abusing his rights. He was ordered to proceed with acceptance nonetheless.

Scenario 2 — The buyer refuses provisional acceptance due to defects. That refusal may be lawful — for instance because an expert report demonstrates fundamental defects. One nuance: when an expert report specifies the defects such that they are known and remediable, the developer may not endlessly keep refusing acceptance because a few details remain. One ruling emphasised that in such a case, the postponement of several years can be charged to the developer — concretely: he bears the costs of that postponement period, not the buyer.

For those wishing to fully grasp the strategic timing and grounds for refusal, please consult the spoke on four acceptance moments in an apartment building in the construction cluster.

The guarantee and notarial retention

The Breyne Act imposes a guarantee obligation on the developer (art. 12 Breyne Act). For most developers, this means a 5% guarantee by an approved financial institution. That guarantee is released in two phases: the first half upon provisional acceptance, the second half upon final acceptance (art. 3 § 6 of the Royal Decree of 21 October 1971).

In addition, apart from the Breyne Act, a notarial retention is often provided for. A portion of the sale price — typically 5 to 10% — remains with the notary as a guarantee until a specific event occurs (acceptance, regularisation of a permit issue, resolution of a specific dispute). The Court of Appeal of Brussels qualified on 18 October 2019 such a notarial retention as a penalty clause when it was linked to a regularisation obligation within a given period. Concrete outcome in that case: the regularisation was finalised two days after the deadline expired — but because the effective enjoyment of the lot concerned was in the meantime assured, the court ruled that the amount did not automatically go to the buyers. The penalty clause had to be moderated according to the actual damage.

Two practical consequences:

One: if you as buyer rely on a notarial retention to safeguard your rights, you cannot count on an automatic forfeiture in your favour. The judge will assess proportionality.

Two: if you as developer negotiate a notarial retention, bear in mind that it may be requalified by the judge as a penalty clause and moderated on the basis of article 5.97 NCC.

The voting prohibition of article 2 § 3 of the Royal Decree implementing the Breyne Act

When the first general assemblies are held, the developer is often still a co-owner — for unsold lots or for lots whose acceptance is not yet finalised. He therefore sits at the table and has voting rights in proportion to his shares.

Here article 2 § 3 of the Royal Decree of 21 October 1971 comes into play. During the general assembly, the rights of the developer as co-owner are suspended when the acceptance of the building is discussed. He may vote on the budget, on minor maintenance work, on the appointment of a new syndic — but not on his own acceptance. The rationale is evident: he would be judging himself.

The Royal Decree implementing the Breyne Act develops this as an autonomous rule, separate from the general duty of abstention of article 3.87 § 9 NCC. This has practical consequences for procedural argumentation: when you as co-owner wish to prevent the developer from voting on his own acceptance, you would do better to rely on the Royal Decree of the Breyne Act than on article 3.87 § 9 NCC. The basis is autonomous, the assessment clearer, and the outcome more predictable.

For the broader context of the duty of abstention and the prohibition on voting by proxy, see the pillar on the ACO in practice.

Turmoil at the first general assemblies

The first general assemblies in a newly built building are often turbulent. Two scenarios typically occur:

Scenario A — Disagreement about the developer's settlement. The developer presents a settlement charging costs that are partly site-related (and therefore his own) and partly ACO-related. Co-owners who contest their bills cannot simply have the settlement dismissed — they must challenge it at the right moment (within four months of the AGM, art. 3.92 § 3 NCC), with the right arguments (Cass. 02/09/2021 for the pre/post-acceptance split).

Scenario B — Disagreement about the acceptance itself. An individual owner refuses to accept that his private lot has been delivered; he consequently also refuses any contribution to the ACO. Another couple is in dispute with the developer over technical defects in their apartment, and that discussion colours every AGM. In some extreme cases, an administrator is appointed by the court — a figure from the reformed apartment law — to defuse the ordinary functioning of the building.

The justice of the peace of Beringen appointed an administrator in a recent case in precisely such a constellation: a newly built building in which a couple could not resolve their acceptance issues, the first syndic (proposed by the developer) was written off as biased, and the ACO was no longer functional. The administrator was appointed to be able to take objective decisions temporarily alongside the syndic.

In most cases the remedies remain more classical: challenge of AGM decisions before the justice of the peace, appointment of a provisional syndic in case of conflict of interest, or action for acceptance based on abuse of rights against the developer. Which remedy is appropriate depends on the phase of the dispute and the number of affected owners.

Insurance in the transition phase

An often overlooked detail in the transition from construction site to operational building: the insurance chain. During the works, typically the contractor or developer holds an ABR policy (all site risks), which covers the site and the building under construction. As soon as provisional acceptance takes place, the ABR policy lapses and must be replaced by a block policy in the name of the ACO.

In the transition lies a coverage gap: if the ABR policy ends on date X and the block policy only comes into force on date X+5, the ACO sits without cover between those dates. A mistake by many beginning syndics. It is therefore advisable to negotiate the block policy prior to provisional acceptance and to link the effective date to the exact provisional acceptance.

In addition, legal expenses insurance is recommended for the ACO, especially in new-build buildings where the likelihood of construction disputes is real. The ordinary block policy typically does not cover contractual construction disputes — a legal expenses policy fills that gap. For an extensive construction site on an adjoining plot, the policy can moreover cover substantial neighbourhood nuisance.

Strategies for the buyer

Three strategies for those buying an apartment off-plan:

Strategy 1 — Read the purchase deed with surgical precision. Pay attention to the identification of the private and common parts, the plans, the estimated delivery period, the guarantee arrangements, and any notarial retentions. Compare with the base deed. Contradictions between the two are a red flag.

Strategy 2 — Document all communication with the developer. Emails, letters, meeting minutes, personal commitments — anything the developer promises you at the sales stage (e.g. "you may install air conditioning", "you will receive extra glazing on the façade") is a personal agreement he cannot impose on the ACO (see clause promoteur). You will therefore have to go back to the drawing board with the ACO after acceptance — and your written proof of the agreement is what remains to you.

Strategy 3 — Be present at the first general assemblies. The decisions taken there colour the functioning of the ACO for years. A four-month forfeiture period (art. 3.92 § 3 NCC) runs from each AGM — those absent will read this in the minutes and may already be too late by the time they challenge. For the challenge itself, see the spoke on irregular versus unlawful ACO decision.

Conclusion

The formation phase of an ACO under the Breyne Act is a legal pivot phase. The ACO already exists but does not yet function fully. The developer is still dominant, but his rights are limited. The four acceptance moments structure the transition, and the Court of Cassation sharply fixed the pivotal moment for costs on 2 September 2021.

Those who as buyer or as beginning ACO go through this phase would do well to seek legal advice early. Many pitfalls are laid in the first two years; many of them can be neutralised through timely and well-structured procedural defence. Contact us via info@reius.be for an initial evaluation of your case.

In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.

Frequently asked questions

From when does the ACO pay the building's costs?

From the provisional acceptance of the common parts. The Court of Cassation ruled on 2 September 2021 that this is the statutory pivotal moment, even if the sale deed points to a different moment. Costs from before that provisional acceptance — site-related utilities, ABR site insurance, security costs during construction — remain with the developer.

When does the ACO come into legal existence?

Upon the first transfer of ownership of a lot in a building divided into private and common parts (art. 3.84 NCC). In an off-plan purchase this can therefore be years before acceptance. The ACO then exists in law but does not yet function operationally — the first general assembly often only follows around or after provisional acceptance.

What is the "four-moment structure" under the Breyne Act?

The Breyne Act distinguishes four acceptance moments: (1) provisional acceptance of the common parts, (2) provisional acceptance of the private parts, (3) final acceptance of the common parts, and (4) final acceptance of the private parts. At least one year must elapse between provisional and final acceptance. Each moment has its own legal consequences — transfer of risk, transfer of costs, release of guarantees. For the full elaboration, see the spoke four acceptance moments in an apartment building.

May the developer postpone acceptance until full payment?

Not automatically. When the works are objectively completed and the developer keeps refusing acceptance until he receives the last instalment, this may constitute abuse of rights. The court of Antwerp on 11 June 2019 ordered a developer to nonetheless proceed with provisional acceptance, despite his refusal. The assessment depends on the actual degree of completion and the reasonableness of the refusal — a court expert is often decisive.

How much guarantee must the developer provide?

Under the Breyne Act this is typically a 5% guarantee by an approved financial institution (art. 12 Breyne Act). The guarantee is released in two phases: 50% upon provisional acceptance, 50% upon final acceptance (art. 3 § 6 of the Royal Decree of 21 October 1971). In addition, a notarial retention can be negotiated for specific guarantees (acceptance, regularisation). Such retention is usually assessed by the judge as a penalty clause that can be proportionately moderated.

May the developer vote at the general assembly on the acceptance of his own building?

No. Article 2 § 3 of the Royal Decree of 21 October 1971 (Royal Decree implementing the Breyne Act) suspends the rights of the developer as co-owner during an AGM deliberation on acceptance. This is an autonomous rule, separate from the general duty of abstention of article 3.87 § 9 NCC. On other agenda items (budget, syndic appointment, minor works) he may vote.

What is an administrator and when is one appointed?

An administrator is a court-appointed figure, introduced in the most recent reform of apartment law, who can take objective decisions temporarily alongside the syndic when the ordinary functioning of the ACO is disrupted. Appointment typically takes place at the request of co-owners jointly representing at least 1/5 of the shares, before the justice of the peace. In new-build buildings this figure is sometimes deployed when there is a stalemate between buyers, developer and syndic and the first general assemblies become paralysed.

What if the developer is still owner of unsold lots?

He remains co-owner for those lots and has voting rights at the AGM in proportion to his shares. However, he may not vote on his own acceptance (art. 2 § 3 Royal Decree Breyne Act) or on decisions personally affecting him (art. 3.87 § 9 NCC, also when voting by proxy). He must moreover contribute to the common costs in proportion to his shares — clauses exempting him from that contribution are void under article 3.100 NCC.

Unsure about your situation?

The lawyers at Reius are ready to provide you with personal legal advice.

Book a consultation →