The syndic is the most visible face of the association of co-owners (ACO) — and often the most discussed figure at the general assembly. What if they fail to do their job? What if there is no syndic at all? What if they delegate their duties to an employee, or refuse to hand over the file to their successor? This spoke sets out the appointment, replacement and court-ordered replacement of the syndic, guided by recent case law.
The appointment is mandatory — even in small buildings
Article 3.89 of the Belgian Civil Code makes the appointment of a syndic mandatory as soon as a building falls within the scope of the co-ownership law: at least two units belonging to different owners, with common areas. The law makes no exception for small buildings. A subdivided townhouse with two apartments and a shared staircase falls within its scope just as much as a residential tower with two hundred units.
That this is not an academic issue was shown by a recent ruling in which two owners of a small co-ownership battled each other before the justice of the peace over usage rights and the qualification of common areas. The judge never reached the substance. He found that the claims concerned the management and rights of disposal over common areas, that representation of the ACO rests with a syndic — and that there was no syndic. Sanction: the claim was inadmissible at that point. Through an interlocutory judgment, the judge invited the parties to first have a syndic appointed by petition.
The lesson is twofold. Procedurally: without a syndic, there is no valid representation of the ACO, and without valid representation, no admissible claim regarding the common areas — a principle reaffirmed by the justice of the peace of Ostend I on 19 December 2023. Practically: even small co-ownerships where "everything is arranged informally" run a real litigation risk as long as they have no syndic.
A nuance for the smallest buildings: the law allows co-ownerships whose nature of common areas justifies it to exclude the application of the mandatory co-ownership law in an (abridged) deed of base — but only as long as all co-owners agree. Case law on what happens when one owner subsequently wants to reverse that exclusion is inconsistent: some judges stick to the contract, others accept that a syndic can still be appointed on first request when the actual relationships show that an independent manager is needed — for example because the owners are making each other's lives miserable. Anyone in such a situation would do well to have their position legally reviewed in advance.
Judicial syndic versus provisional syndic
When appointment via the general assembly fails, the law offers two judicial emergency routes. They are often confused, but differ fundamentally in situation and procedure.
The judicial syndic is appointed in the event of absence: there is no syndic at all. Any interested party — a co-owner, but also a creditor of the ACO — may petition the justice of the peace to that end by unilateral petition (art. 594, 21° Judicial Code). The procedure is quick and simple, precisely because there is no opposing party to be heard: there is no sitting syndic.
The provisional syndic is appointed when a syndic does exist, but is prevented from acting or in default (art. 3.89 § 8 Civil Code). Here the procedure is adversarial: the sitting syndic must be able to defend himself against the accusation that he is not properly performing his duties. The provisional syndic then acts temporarily, alongside or in place of the sitting one.
Two recent applications show how the case law handles this:
Ganshoren, 21 April 2023. Co-owners requested a provisional syndic because of persistent poor management. The sitting syndic defended himself by arguing that a general assembly had since taken place — management had therefore resumed. The justice of the peace rejected that defence: the fact that a GA has been held does not undo the established shortfall in proper management. The provisional syndic was appointed.
Antwerp 6, 27 October 2021. A syndic who was himself unable to perform his duties had appointed an employee without BIV/IPI accreditation and given him full final responsibility — right down to drafting minutes "on behalf of" the syndic. The justice of the peace saw this as a violation of Article 3.89 § 6 of the Civil Code, which only allows delegation of powers with the express consent of the GA and for a limited duration or specific purposes. Result: the decisions of the GA in question were annulled and a provisional syndic appointed.
The choice between the two figures thus determines your procedural route: no syndic → unilateral petition, judicial syndic; failing syndic → adversarial summons, provisional syndic. Choosing the wrong route means losing time — and in a conflict situation, time is rarely an ally.
The ordinary replacement: dismissal and reappointment
Beyond the judicial emergency routes, the main road of course remains the general assembly. The GA appoints the syndic and may dismiss him at any time by simple majority. The syndic contract is limited by law to a maximum of three years, renewable by express decision of the GA — tacit renewal is excluded.
Three points of attention when replacing:
The written agreement. The law requires a written syndic agreement. In practice, however, many syndics operate for years without one. This opens discussions about fees: those without a written agreement have a shaky title to their remuneration. Since the legislative amendment that entered into force on 1 January 2019, the syndic must also submit a list of his rates for supplementary services — the "menu". Services not on that list cannot in principle be charged. Any ACO in a fee dispute with a syndic without a written agreement or rate list therefore has a solid defence. Conversely, realism applies: those who paid fees without protest for fourteen years and reappointed the syndic each time will find it difficult to reclaim everything retroactively.
The handover of the file. A departing syndic must transfer the complete file of the building to his successor — accounting, contracts, technical documents, and expressly also the digital files. The court of first instance of Brussels recalled on 19 June 2023 that this is a statutory, contractual and deontological obligation. A syndic who holds the file hostage — for example pending disputed fees — can be compelled to hand it over in court, if necessary under penalty payment.
The accounting legacy. In buildings that have gone through several syndic changes, the accounts are sometimes structurally polluted: years of anomalies that no successor can fully reconstruct. Case law shows itself pragmatic here: after several changes and years elapsed, full correction is often simply no longer possible. This argues for thorough due diligence when taking over a management mandate — and for the ACO: raising anomalies in a timely manner, not years later.
The syndic and the notification procedure: don't decide alone
A recurring pitfall in daily management deserves a separate mention here. When a co-owner notifies works via the notification procedure of Article 3.82 of the Civil Code (a charging point, air conditioning, solar panels — see the spoke on alteration works and the notification procedure), the question arises who assesses whether that procedure applies at all and whether an objection is filed.
The answer: not the syndic alone. A syndic who unilaterally decides whether a notification suffices or GA authorisation is required takes on a responsibility that may backfire once the discussion escalates. Good practice is that he submits the point to the general assembly — or, more workably, that the ACO provides in a rules of procedure of the council of co-ownership that the council, together with the syndic, takes a position on the application of the notification procedure, with a mandate to respond on behalf of the ACO. This way, procedurally what must be done has been done, the syndic does not bear sole responsibility, and the applicant, in the event of refusal, has a formal document to exhaust his rights before the justice of the peace.
When the syndic litigates
The syndic represents the ACO in court, but does not himself decide on proceedings on the merits — that is the sovereign competence of the general assembly. He may, however, take urgent and conservatory measures: summary proceedings for the appointment of an expert, an act interrupting prescription, initiating an eviction action against a tenant causing serious nuisance. In each case: subsequent ratification by the GA. The full framework is set out in the spoke on the procedural capacity of the ACO, syndic and co-owner.
A special case is the syndic who — usually in new-build files — has been proposed by the developer or is even the developer himself. This constellation generates structural conflicts of interest: over the settlement of construction costs, over acceptance, over proceedings against the developer. Case law has repeatedly annulled votes by such a developer-syndic on his own settlement due to conflict of interest. For that issue, see the spoke on the clause promoteur.
Roadmap for the dissatisfied ACO
In summary, for those who want to get rid of their syndic or have none:
Situation 1 — No syndic. Unilateral petition to the justice of the peace (art. 594, 21° Judicial Code) for the appointment of a judicial syndic. Fast, simple, no adversarial debate.
Situation 2 — Syndic in default, GA blocked. Adversarial summons for the appointment of a provisional syndic (art. 3.89 § 8 Civil Code). Document the poor management: unanswered registered letters, unimplemented GA decisions, missing statements. An interim GA does not cure the shortfall (JP Ganshoren, 21 April 2023).
Situation 3 — Syndic functions, but trust is gone. The ordinary route: put the dismissal and appointment of a successor on the GA agenda. Simple majority suffices. Request quotations from candidate syndics in advance, so that the assembly can immediately reappoint and no vacuum arises.
Situation 4 — The departing syndic does not cooperate. Formal notice for the handover of the file (including digital files), followed by a claim under penalty payment. The threefold basis — statutory, contractual, deontological — makes this a strong claim (Court of First Instance Brussels, 19 June 2023). Also do not forget a BIV/IPI disciplinary complaint as a lever with a professional syndic.
If you are unsure which route suits your situation, or if you want to conduct the appointment procedure correctly without admissibility risks: contact us at info@reius.be or via the contact form for an initial assessment of your file.
In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.
Would you like to know exactly how the ACO works and decides? Read our guide on the powers and operation of the ACO.