You built or renovated, and afterwards it turns out that the contractor did not warn you about a risk they should have known about. A thatched roof without a spark arrestor, a pipe running too close to a power cable, workmanship that would cause moisture problems in the long term. Were they entitled to remain silent because the client and the architect had approved the plans? The answer is nuanced: a contractor's duty to inform does exist, but its boundaries have been drawn more sharply by case law in recent years.
Many clients believe that the absence of a warning automatically leads to liability. Sometimes it does, sometimes it doesn't. Over the past three years, the Court of Cassation and the courts of appeal have developed a clear distinction between what a contractor technically should have flagged and what they were legally required to disclose. This article sets out that distinction, along with the three scenarios you are most likely to encounter in practice and the remedies you can invoke.
What is a contractor's duty to inform under Belgian law?
The duty to inform — often also called the duty to warn — is not a formal rule contained in a single article, but a consequence of the good faith that binds every contracting party. In the new Civil Code, its precontractual basis is found in Article 5.16 CC, which obliges parties to provide each other with the information required by law, good faith and custom, taking into account the parties' capacity and their reasonable expectations. During performance, Article 5.73 CC develops the same principle as a supplementary effect of good faith.
The draft Book 7 CC extends this duty in Article 7.4.12, § 1, 4° and § 2: the service provider must supply the client with information and take the safety measures required by law, good faith and custom. In concrete terms: a contractor who, as a professional, identifies an execution-related risk falling within their expertise must warn the client — even if they did not create the risk themselves.
Technical responsibility is not automatically legal liability
Case law has introduced an important nuance. The Ghent Court of Appeal ruled on 16 December 2022 (Ghent no. 2021/AR/1531, T.Aann. 2023, issue 2, 231) on a contractor who had carried out works on a chimney on a thatched roof, without alerting the occupants to the desirability of a spark arrestor. When a fire subsequently broke out, the contractor was sued.
The court-appointed expert established technical responsibility: a professional is expected to know the fire risk of a thatched roof. However, the first-instance judge — confirmed on appeal — ruled out legal liability. The reasoning: a spark arrestor was not legally required, was not demanded by fire insurers, and was not recommended in the guidelines of the Belgian Building Research Institute (WTCB/BBRI). The fact that the contractor had not warned did not constitute a fault causally connected to the damage.
The lesson: technical responsibility is a necessary but not sufficient condition. For legal liability, the failure to warn must amount to a genuine fault, assessed against statutory obligations, sectoral guidelines and the reasonable expectations of a professional.
When it does apply: cables, pipes and statutory requirements
It is different when the contractor breaches a statutory obligation. The Ghent Court of Appeal (Ghent 4 October 2023, TBO 2023, issue 6, 279) dealt with a case in which a contractor had carried out works near gas pipes without first securing the located gas shut-off valves and using a crane in the immediate vicinity.
The court held that contractors carrying out this kind of work have a duty to consult, a duty to locate and, where necessary, a duty to coordinate. These duties stem, among other things, from the General Regulation on Electrical Installations (AREI/RGIE) and from the duty of care of a professional contractor. By failing to take these steps, the contractor committed a fault. The network operator was not blamed: a cable operator cannot be expected to re-check its plans after every excavation notification.
When the duty to warn is anchored in a statutory or regulatory framework, it therefore weighs more heavily than when it rests only on "what a good professional would do".
Extension to minor hidden defects
A breach of the duty to warn has an important follow-on effect: it can still lead to liability after acceptance of the works, through the doctrine of minor hidden defects. The Ghent Court of Appeal ruled on 21 January 2022 (Ghent 9th chamber, TBO 2023, issue 4, 171) that a contractual liability claim based on breach of an alleged duty to warn must be handled as a warranty claim for hidden defects.
The reasoning is logical: acceptance by the client can only relate to what was apparent to them at that moment. A concealed risk was by definition not apparent. Liability for hidden defects then requires proof of a defect and of a fault — and that fault does not necessarily have to consist of a departure from the rules of the trade. A breach of the duty to warn suffices.
The client must, however, act in a timely manner, within a reasonable or useful period after discovering the defect. For what this means for your specific case, see the spoke on minor hidden defects after acceptance of construction works.
Difference with the architect's duty to warn
The architect has their own, broader duty of supervision. They assess plans, execution and choice of materials against the rules of the trade and the statutory framework. The contractor, by contrast, has a duty to warn within their own technical expertise, no more. Both duties can overlap, but they do not replace each other.
In cases of concurrent faults, architect and contractor can be held liable in solidum. For the broader framework on the role and liability of the architect, see the spoke on the architect who does not supervise the site.
What can you claim in the event of a breach of the duty to inform?
If the contractor failed to warn you of a risk they should have known about, and this omission constitutes a fault in the legal sense, the full arsenal of contract law remedies opens up.
Damages for the additional cost of repairing the defect or completing the works. Price reduction where repair is impossible or disproportionate to the fault. Substitute performance by a third party, at the defaulting contractor's expense. And in serious cases, termination of the contract. Which remedy is appropriate depends on the stage of the works and the nature of the defect. Our spoke on dismissing your contractor discusses when termination is justified.
How do you prove that the contractor failed to warn you?
The burden of proof lies with the client, but the court applies Article 8.31 CC flexibly. Three factors carry weight.
The absence of written warnings in site correspondence, minutes of site meetings or email exchanges is strong negative evidence. The technical seriousness and recognisability of the risk — a professional contractor is deemed to know the rules of their trade, and when statutory requirements apply (such as the AREI/RGIE), ignorance is no excuse. A court-appointed expert who concludes that a professional should have flagged the risk closes the evidentiary circle.
In practice, it is usually advisable to first appoint an amicable or court-appointed expert. Their findings form the basis for any further action, both in negotiation and before the court. Building a case on photos and personal observations alone rarely provides sufficient evidentiary weight for technical matters. For the broader framework of your rights as a client, see the pillar on rights and duties of the client in construction contracts.
If you have a case in which you suspect that your contractor concealed a risk, contact us in good time at info@reius.be. The reasonable period for minor hidden defects runs from the discovery of the defect, and the ten-year limitation period of Article 2262bis CC starts running from acceptance of the works. Delay costs rights.