Reius Advocaten – Vastgoedrecht Brussel

Advocaten - Avocats - Lawyers

Reius Lawyers · 363 Avenue Louise box 26 · 1050 Brussels · info@reius.be · +32 2 616 08 10 Printed on 5 November 2026
Apartments & Co-ownership

Developer clauses: why authorisations rarely hold up

Door Vianto Pashku, advocaat - Lawyer · · 11 min
Table of contents

In short

You bought off-plan and the property developer gave you written authorisation for an air-conditioning unit, heat pump or terrace extension. Five years later, the association of co-owners (ACO) challenges that authorisation. Can they do that? Yes — and it is happening more often. We explain why the clause promoteur is legally fragile and what remedies you have as a buyer or as an ACO.

You bought an apartment off-plan and the property developer allowed you to install an air-conditioning system, a heat pump, an extension of your terrace or an additional glass panel. He duly gave you written authorisation for this. Five years later, the general meeting suddenly sends a different signal: that authorisation is not valid, the installation must be removed, or you will pay penalties. Can they do that?

Yes, and it is happening more often. The mechanism is called the clause promoteur — an umbrella term for arrangements, authorisations or clauses that the property developer has included in the deed of division (basisakte) or in the individual purchase agreement, often in his own interest or in that of an individual buyer, but bypassing the general meeting. In recent years, case law has firmly reined in these constructions. This spoke addresses the three main questions: what does the law say, which authorisations survive, and what do you do when the ACO turns against you?

The deed of division as the building's constitution

The deed of division is more than a notarial document. According to settled case law of the Belgian justices of the peace, it is the source and the measure of the rights of every co-owner. Anyone who buys a lot in an apartment building buys it together with the deed of division — literally: it is an inseparable part of the title of ownership.

Under Article 3.93 of the new Civil Code (NBW), the statutes of the co-ownership (the deed of division and the rules of co-ownership) are enforceable against all holders of a real or personal right in the building. What is in the statutes applies — and what is agreed outside them does not, in principle, apply vis-à-vis the ACO or the other co-owners.

This has one immediate consequence: when selling off-plan, the developer may not grant any enforceable authorisation that deviates from what is stated in the deed of division itself. He is not the general meeting. He can promise something in his own relationship with the individual buyer, but that promise is a personal agreement that does not concern the other co-owners. When the ACO later decides differently, the developer's authorisation falls.

The Hasselt I ruling of 14 February 2023

A co-owner had received written authorisation from the developer upon purchase to run air-conditioning pipes through common ceilings and shafts to connect the outdoor unit to his indoor unit. Once the works were complete, the property manager raised the matter at the general meeting: it had never been discussed with the ACO, the installation used common parts, and the pipes were visible.

The owner defended himself with the developer's authorisation. The justice of the peace of Hasselt I rejected this defence on 14 February 2023. The reasoning proceeds in three steps:

Step 1 — The developer does not have the powers of the general meeting. Allowing a co-owner to use common shafts or ceilings is a decision that only the ACO can take, via Article 3.88 NBW (works on common parts) or Article 3.82 NBW (notification procedure for alteration works). The developer cannot usurp that power.

Step 2 — The authorisation circumvents the rules of co-ownership. The rules of co-ownership typically provide that interventions on common parts require prior approval by the general meeting. An authorisation from the developer in a private agreement cannot hollow out that regulatory provision. Enforceability works the other way round: the rules are enforceable against all owners, including anyone who invokes a private arrangement with the developer.

Step 3 — The authorisation is null and void insofar as it breaches the rules. Article 3.100 NBW expressly makes the provisions of apartment law a matter of mandatory law. Contractual deviations that erode the statutory regime are null and void — not voidable upon request, but absolutely null and void by operation of law.

The practical outcome: the owner had to remove the installation or apply for new regularisation from the general meeting. The developer's clause offered him no protection. To learn which majorities are required for such regularisation, consult the spoke on alteration works and the notification procedure.

Unilateral amendment of the deed of division by the developer

A second variant of the clause promoteur is the so-called revision clause: a provision in the deed of division that allows the developer unilaterally to make changes to the deed itself, without a prior decision of the general meeting. Such clauses are common in projects that have not yet been fully completed or whose final layout is only established later.

Case law has consistently held these clauses to be invalid. A revision clause allowing a developer unilaterally to amend the deed of division or to carry out or authorise a structural intervention without input from the general meeting undermines the fundamental right of every co-owner to participate in decisions on his ownership foundation. It conflicts with the principle that the deed of division belongs to everyone, and that everyone must be informed of and able to vote on amendments.

A nuance enshrined in law since 2018: Article 3.85 § 1/1 NBW allows minor, non-essential amendments during the construction phase, provided they are formalised in a notarial deed of correction and provided they do not affect the essential characteristics of the project. What qualifies as "minor" is assessed by the courts; converting two studios into one apartment does not qualify. For the construction phase itself, before the first general meeting, and for the impact of amendments on the establishment of the ACO, see our spoke buying an apartment under the Breyne Act — your rights during the establishment phase of the ACO.

Conflict of interest at the general meeting

A third variant is particularly harmful because it affects the functioning of the general meeting itself. Some developers include provisions in the deed of division allowing them to continue playing a role in the management after handover — for instance by appointing themselves as first property manager, or by reserving certain lots whose costs are channelled through the ACO.

In a case handled by the justice of the peace of Hasselt, a developer — who had appointed himself as property manager after the establishment of the building — voted on a settlement of construction costs, part of which was passed on to the ACO. The court held that this voting behaviour constituted a conflict of interest: the developer was voting on a settlement that personally concerned him. He should have abstained.

In a second vote on the same settlement, the developer again did not leave the meeting room, this time did not vote personally, but used the proxies of other owners to secure a favourable vote. That vote was also annulled: Article 3.87 § 9 NBW prohibits voting not only in one's own name, but also by proxy in the same matter. Anyone who may not vote personally may also not vote by proxy.

The justice of the peace went one step further. Because he had to annul two consecutive votes on the same settlement, he ruled that "enough was enough" and ordered the ACO to have the settlement for the relevant period redrawn — in this case not by a court-appointed expert, but reviewed on the merits. For how to challenge such decisions, see the spoke on irregular versus wrongful ACO decisions.

Privatised common parts via the developer

A fourth application of the clause promoteur concerns the arrangement of common parts for exclusive use with the developer's consent. A classic case: the owner of the top-floor apartment obtains permission from the developer to arrange the landing outside his door to his own taste, to build a niche, to modify floor and wall coverings — all while retaining the common status of that landing in the deed of division.

In a case in Ostend, the general meeting subsequently requested that the owner restore these parts to their original state. The justice of the peace annulled that decision: he held that the eighth floor was in fact only used by this one owner, and that the ACO had no demonstrable benefit in reversing those works. The arrangement was therefore maintained.

Important: this ruling is not a licence for authorisations by the developer. What was decisive here is not the developer's authorisation itself, but the balancing of interests between the ACO and the individual owner — an assessment characteristic of the wrongful decision within the meaning of Article 3.92 § 3 NBW. The owner had, after all, requested regularisation from the general meeting, and this had been refused without genuine reasoning. It was that refusal that was annulled, not the developer's authorisation that was upheld.

The fiction that the developer remains "involved" in his project

Some developers exercise a de facto grip on the building even after handover, from a kind of personal attachment to their creation. A telling example comes from a ruling of the Litigation Chamber of the Belgian Data Protection Authority in a case where, years after handover, a developer still operated and managed the building's security cameras. The cameras were on common parts, and the footage was accessed and analysed by the developer.

The Litigation Chamber was clear: the data controller for the camera footage is the ACO, not the developer. Management of that footage belongs to the ACO, which must also be able to decide autonomously whether cameras are installed at all. The clause in the statutes making the installation of cameras mandatory was also criticised: by imposing such an obligation in the statutes, the developer deprives the ACO of its free will to make a considered choice about cameras. This conflicts with the spirit of the apartment law and with the GDPR.

Practical consequence: even before formally amending the statutes, the ACO may decide to decommission the cameras, or to take over their management from the developer. The statutory clause imposing the opposite is not binding.

Exclusion of contributions by the developer — the classic

A fifth, older variant of the clause promoteur concerns the exclusion of contributions to costs for unsold lots still held by the developer. The developer typically argued that his empty lots did not generate costs (no water consumption, no electricity use, no lift use), and therefore did not have to contribute.

Settled case law has invalidated that exclusion. The obligation to contribute arises from ownership of the lot, not from actual use. Article 3.86 NBW provides that all co-owners must contribute to the common charges — a provision considered, as a reflection of former Article 577-2 of the Civil Code, to be a matter of public policy as regards the obligation to contribute itself. A clause in the deed of division exempting the developer or any other co-owner from that contribution breaches this principle and is null and void.

For the transition of costs between the construction phase and the operational phase of the ACO — another pivotal point where the developer and the ACO meet — our analysis of the allocation of charges between developer and ACO refers to Cass. 2 September 2021. The transfer of costs is tied to the provisional acceptance of the common parts, not to any authorisation from the developer.

What do you do if you are faced with a clause promoteur?

Three scenarios, three strategies:

You are a buyer and you have received an authorisation that the ACO contests. Request regularisation without delay at the general meeting. The developer's authorisation offers you no legal shield — but it is an argument in the balancing of interests that the court will conduct in any challenge to an ACO decision ordering removal or reversal.

You are a co-owner and the ACO is doing nothing about an unlawful clause promoteur. Summon the ACO before the justice of the peace, possibly jointly with the neighbour co-owner whose installation you contest. Seek annulment of the authorisation on the basis of Articles 3.93 and 3.100 NBW. Keep the four-month time-bar for challenging general meeting decisions in mind (see the pillar on the ACO in practice).

You are in a general meeting where the developer is voting on a settlement that concerns him personally. Raise the conflict of interest under Article 3.87 § 9 NBW, demand that the developer leave the room and refrain from using proxies. Have that protest minuted — it is your legal foot in the door if you later wish to challenge the decision.

In each of these situations: act quickly, document everything in writing, and do not hesitate to seek legal advice. The clause promoteur is fragile in settled case law, but you still need to take the correct procedural steps to be rid of it definitively. Contact us at info@reius.be for an initial assessment of your file.

In re. In jure — Thorough in the facts. Considered in the law.

Frequently asked questions

What is a "clause promoteur"?

It is an umbrella term for clauses, arrangements or authorisations by which the property developer — often in the deed of division or in an individual purchase agreement — bypasses the general meeting to fix decisions that bind, or should bind, the association of co-owners (ACO) and the other co-owners. Typical examples: unilateral amendment of the deed of division, authorisation to use common parts, exclusion of contributions for unsold lots, or self-appointment as first property manager. Case law has firmly reined in these constructions.

Is a written authorisation from the developer to install an air-conditioning unit valid?

In principle, not vis-à-vis the ACO. The justice of the peace of Hasselt I ruled on 14 February 2023 that the developer does not possess the powers of the general meeting to allow deviations from the rules of co-ownership. The authorisation remains a personal arrangement between you and the developer; it creates no rights against the other co-owners. In case of dispute, you will still have to request regularisation from the general meeting via the notification procedure (Art. 3.82 NBW).

Can a revision clause in the deed of division stand?

No, not if it allows the developer to amend the deed of division or to grant authorisations unilaterally, outside the general meeting. Settled case law and legal scholarship regard such revision clauses as invalid because they conflict with mandatory law (Art. 3.100 NBW) and because they hollow out the fundamental right of every co-owner to participate in decisions on his ownership foundation. Minor, non-essential amendments during the construction phase remain permitted via a notarial deed of correction (Art. 3.85 § 1/1 NBW).

May the developer vote at the general meeting?

Yes, for the lots he still owns — with two important exceptions. Under the Royal Decree implementing the Breyne Act, he may not vote on the acceptance of the building. Under Article 3.87 § 9 NBW, he may not vote on decisions that personally concern him (e.g., a settlement of construction costs he himself is passing on). This duty to abstain also applies to voting by proxy — anyone who may not vote personally may also not vote through proxies obtained from others.

Can the developer appoint himself as first property manager?

A first property manager may be nominated in the deed of division, but the general meeting must ratify that appointment at its first meeting. A developer who appoints himself as property manager without limit and without ratification by the general meeting is exercising an appointment on shaky legal ground. Worse still: in such a set-up, he will be constantly in a conflict of interest — over his own costs, his own acceptance of the works, his own settlements. Such a case typically fares badly under court scrutiny.

How long do I have to challenge a clause promoteur?

There is no fixed time limit for the nullity of the clause itself — a null clause remains null. But if you wish to challenge a general meeting decision partly based on a clause promoteur, the four-month time-bar of Article 3.92 § 3 NBW applies. So do not wait. For the actual removal or regularisation of an installation placed years ago, a limitation period may in the meantime run. Reacting quickly is always better than relying on justice after the fact.

Is there a statutory prohibition on clauses promoteurs?

Not as a general prohibition, but through several statutory ingredients that together undermine the framework: Article 3.93 NBW (enforceability of statutes), Article 3.100 NBW (mandatory nature of apartment law), Article 3.87 § 9 NBW (duty to abstain), and the Royal Decree implementing the Breyne Act (voting prohibition on acceptance). Combined, they render most clauses promoteurs vulnerable to nullity, provided they are challenged in good time and properly.

Unsure about your situation?

The lawyers at Reius are ready to provide you with personal legal advice.

Book a consultation →